2 ms·
It was pretty funny. I got a good laugh, but its a good illustration of something I've been thinking about since all of this began. Its dangerous to compare th
by noonespecial 18y ago
It was pretty funny. I got a good laugh, but its a good illustration of something I've been thinking about since all of this began.
Its dangerous to compare the profits of someone like Henry Ford with someone like Richard Fuld. I'm afraid the subtlety might be lost on both politicians and the general public. There's a difference between someone who becomes rich by making things and someone who does it with "derivatives". One creates wealth. One just "makes money".
I cringe every time I hear some highbrow use the word "wealth" as just a more sophisticated-sounding way to say "money", oblivious to the difference.
If, in our zeal, we demonize the Henry Fords along with the Richard Fulds, we'll create a perfect regulatory environment to ensure that we never get another of either.
Edit: I put "derivatives" in quotes partly because I didn't want to bleat "derivatives bad" as if it should be promptly followed up by a statement of the goodness of quadrapedality, and partly because "gaming the system in order to distort the reality of risk and thereby extract unearned profits for the unaffected mitigation thereof" didn't exactly flow. I was promptly and correctly called out for it. Bummer.
- TriinT 18y agoThere's a difference between someone who becomes rich by making things and someone who does it with "derivatives". One creates wealth. One just "makes money". I respectfully disagree. Bashing derivatives used to be a fad. Now it's the norm. Not all derivatives were created equal. And, contrary to popular belief, some derivatives actually do create wealth. For instance, suppose I am a corn farmer in Iowa. Derivatives allow me to buy the option of selling X bushels of corn at a specified price Y, on day Z. Hence, I have a guaranteed revenue at some point in the future. If for some reason, the demand for corn is really low this year, I don't care because the counterparty will have to buy my corn at the specified price. Derivatives provide me insurance against price fluctuations. Thus, I can allocate my capital more efficiently because uncertanty has been reduced. Wealth is created. Of course, some will parrot that "Buffett said that derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction" even though they don't really understand what that means. Buffett is not a derivatives trader. Period. Derivatives have existed since ancient times (the Greeks and the Phoenicians used them already). If some financial products survive over 2000 years, it's because they have some value. Services create wealth too. Derivatives provide insurance, and that is a valuable service.
- noonespecial 18y agoThis is true. But the traditional understanding of derivatives and what went down in the past decade might be whole different animals. (The math and logic used to turn subprime loan bundles into AAA's is still somewhat opaque to me.) The argument might be broadened to include the traditional "financial grease" that the markets provided. As you said, bashing derivatives has become the norm, but even Henry had to raise capital. It will be extremely difficult to recover from the damage done in public opinion to financial instruments in general. "Yes, Ma'am, I know you lost all of your money on those investments, but these are good derivatives. Scouts Honor! "
- TriinT 18y agoI agree. I would like to say that I honestly believe that the way the masses perceive the markets is completely and deeply flawed. For instance, if you build a new super high-tech cruise ship which ends up sinking during its inaugural voyage, then people will perceive that failure as a design problem, and they will blame the naval engineers who designed and built the ship. Only a crackpot would claim that one should ban all ships because they're dangerous. If you create a new market and that markets fails, people will claim that it's a dangerous market and that it should be banned. No one will think that the market might have been poorly designed. When it comes to markets, moral issues such as "right" and "wrong" trump everything else. Emotion defeats reason. That's intriguing, isn't it?
- yardie 18y agoI'm still not exactly sure how they managed to turn subprimes into AAAs either but from what I've been able to understand the rating isn't determined by the type or amount of the loans but the perceived risk in it. It's like your credit rating. It doesn't matter how much you have out in credit but how you are determined as a risk. Someone with 10k in debt but a credit score of 780 is going to find it much easier than someone with no debt and no credit score. You are a known quantity, there is a number slapped on your file. The other guy is an unknown quantity, he doesn't have a history of payments so they perceive him as a lot riskier. The mortgage bundles work the same way. The banks told the agencies that there are a certain quantity of A loans, B loans, and C loans. Based on that information the bundles were given a rating. Well what happened is those A loans turned into D loans when they were unable to make payments. Then as the investors started asking for more information they found some people weren't being honest. Now the bank is stuck with these shitty assets and they are unable to lend money because it's tied up in junk. All of this is just my opinion as a financial outsider.