7 ms·
Give Snowden his due: He made a surveillance debate possible
- lechevalierd3on 13y agoWe are winning but nothing is done and nothing will be done. The whistle blower won't be pardoned, and in a few month nobody will care about it. I so deeply wish that this is going to hurt at some point certain businesses so that some big player might use the little influence they may have to change things.
- l33tbro 13y agoSurveillance "debate"? I must have missed something.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- soganess 13y agoIn modern parlance the word debate is used place of "dialog" or "conversation", even if there is little actual debating going on.
- jstalin 13y agoWe should more than give him his due. We should throw him a frickin ticker-tape parade.
- staunch 13y agoI'll settle for a pardon.
- alipang 13y agoLike the one Bradley Manning got.
- nkassis 13y agoI know this will probably initiate a huge debate but I'm not personally convinced that what Bradley Manning released and what Snowden released is equivalent in scope. In the case of Snowden the documents seem much more targeted to exposing the problem he's trying to bring light on. While Manning made a much broad stroke release of tons of documents probably not even knowing the content of all those documents which totaled almost 500,000.
- nikatwork 13y agoI don't think that's a controversial statement [1]. Now this doesn't per se mean Manning was unethical, but the two cases should be treated very differently. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/10111819/Edward-Snowden-leaked-selectively-Bradley-Manning-did-not.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1...
- ihsw 13y agoAny person that looks at the two situations and compares them objectively would come to the same conclusion -- one was reckless and negligent while the other was intentional and targeted. At the risk of diminishing Manning's plight, I'm sure whistleblowers like Snowden are exactly the kind that Wikileaks wants supporting them. Also, it stands to reason that Manning's plight itself may have inspired Snowden.
- d23 13y agoI can never get pro-manning people to answer one simple question: what was he blowing the whistle on?
- samstave 13y agoUnchecked, indiscriminate killing of civilians in Iraq. Proving that the military was over there operating outside the spirit of what we as a supposed free democratic and just society stand for. Pretty damn simple.
- dllthomas 13y agoUnder the current administration, I'm hoping we even get any sort of meaningful response to the pardon petition (https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/pardon-edward-snowden/Dp03vGYD https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/pardon-edward-snow...). I'm holding out a tiny glimmer of hope that Obama comes to his senses enough to pardon for the domestic pieces. It doesn't seem likely, but doesn't seem to directly contradict what he's said, and maybe Obama can pre-emptively compromise with me for once...
- lukifer 13y agoThe deadline's approaching. My money is on "We are unable to comment on an ongoing investigation."
- dllthomas 13y agoThat does seem most likely, and I would not count it as meaningful. They've also said before that they don't comment on individual pardons, though I can't think of a good reason for that. In this case, though, the pardon itself would be a substantial piece of policy. I think it would be disingenuous and disrespectful of the administration to refuse comment. I expect to be disrespected, but hold out some small amount of hope that they will surprise me.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bparsons 13y agoToday was disheartening. The Guardian writes an expose on what should be the greatest political scandal of our lifetime- the fact that low level contractors and government employees can access all of our chat history, emails and browsing history. The response? No one on social media is really discussing it, CNN America only has a passing mention of it on their front page (buried near the bottom) and America goes on with its day. What does it take to get American's outraged about something?
- codex 13y agoEvidence of harm?
- frenchy 13y ago> What does it take to get American's outraged about something? sex
- conanbatt 13y agoWhen this story brokeout, i had the idea that the best way to publicize this is to find an example of a private sexual conversation on record, which they obviously have. Would have been interesting for Snowden to get one of those just in case. That, or an inside trading potential example. Money or sex is something everyone understands.
- product50 13y agoGeorge Zimmerman
- montage 13y agoTake away their Twinkies
- EliRivers 13y agoWhat does it take to get Americans outraged about something? Suggest that professional game players should take sensible safety precautions.
- adamio 13y ago
- SeanDav 13y agoWell well, a couple of people are starting to wake up. I was nearly despairing that the impact of what Snowden was saying would be lost in the snowstorm the government was trying to create to obscure his message by attacking the man. It seems the message is getting through, and that is a great thing.
- lvs 13y agoThe obsessive discussion about phone records is such an obvious straw man. Phone records are just the tip of the iceberg. It's all the other communications surveillance that we should be talking about. They'd be happy to give up phone record dragnets because they know that's not a useful repository of information anyway.
- northwest 13y agoAlso: What does everybody expect from "the debate"? Is there a way we can get out of this mess? I currently don't see any, besides the one with massive loss. Please, anybody, correct me.
- dllthomas 13y agoCall me naive, but I would be surprised to learn that these systems are being used to overtly control the electoral process. So the way out of this mess is to talk to your friends and family and make sure they understand the issues and what is at stake, and make sure they do the same. Elect politicians who will do better - Obama promised and didn't deliver, but the issue only seemed to matter to a sliver of what were basically his base anyway. In the wake of an election with this issue more front-and-center, because the people have demanded the issue remain more front-and-center, I'm not convinced you'll see the same behavior.
- ihsw 13y agoThe electoral process has already been subverted through gerrymandering and a two-party system. All the good, honest, hard-working folks get stuck together with the parasites and psychopaths. In either party there is a very wide range of people from salt-of-the-earth types to scum-of-the-earth. If you don't utilize gerrymandering then you lose, and if you're campaigning in a third-party then you lose.
- dllthomas 13y agoBut that's not anything new, and there's not any reason to expect that subversion to prevent fixing these issues, and fundamentally if enough people are convinced, things will change - "enough" is higher than it probably should be, but I'm not convinced it's higher than it would need to be for a successful revolution or the like.
- northwest 13y ago> Elect politicians who will do better How? The 2-party system will simply not allow it. They have the monopoly over the 2 "choices" we're given each time. They will continue to give us "choices" that they can control. Remember how one of the earlier whistle blowers revealed that Obama had been under surveillance earlier? People who are under surveillance are controllable. If they are allowed to access power, it's really not a stretch to think that they just have the function of a puppet. The 2 parties are controlled by the campaign money donors, which are mostly corporate interests. Do you remember how the Republicans ejected Ron Paul from the debates by quickly changing the rules when he got traction? (Not that I would really want Ron Paul for President.) The media are controlled by the same interests, just look at how little coverage you find about the new slides in the mainstream media, today.
- md224 13y agoNSA response to today's revelations: http://www.nsa.gov/public_info/press_room/2013/30_July_2013.shtml http://www.nsa.gov/public_info/press_room/2013/30_July_2013....
- northwest 13y agoNeat. > Defending Our Nation. Securing Our Future. ...I read that as... Defending Our Own Money. Securing Our Own Power.
- readme 13y agoNSA surveillance foiled this potential terrorist and he is now incarcerated: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Najibullah_Zazi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Najibullah_Zazi He was going to bomb NYC subways. Please, if you're going to participate in this so called "surveillance debate", stick to facts and refrain from hyperbole.
- northwest 13y agoThat's a good thing. But still, they let the other ones go: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-23493323 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-23493323 Is that part of the old "keeping the threat alive" strategy? (Considering the eternity it took them to find OBL. And the one hiccup during the hunt when Bush called the team back, when in reality they were pretty close, as I remember reading.)
- samstave 13y agoIf you're going to participate in the "surveillance debate" don't be so stupidly myopic to argue only the ridiculous point that this keeps anyone safe from "terrorists". If the NSA can literally look into any electronic conversation between anyone, then why haven't they stopped a single drug cartel? Any premeditated murder? Why hasn't a single banister been brought to justice over their internal emails detailing deliberate mortgage fraud? Why weren't they able to prove Bernie Madoff was swindling billions for years and there were many warnings? What about all the illegal insider trading of pretty much every congress person? Oh that's right, because this system has absolutely nothing to do with bringing criminals to "justice" or keeping you safe. This is digital enslavement and every single person who approves of this bullshit is complicit. Trying to say that trillions of dollars in stolen money from people (if the funds taken from taxes are used to build a digital prison around you, those funds were stolen from you) to prevent some singular supposed attack is justified is farking insane!
- tn13 13y ago"I need to reduce your freedom to keep you safe", no one can argue with that.
- tn13 13y agoSomeone should suggest to the American public that this mass surveillance is a big threat to sports and will somehow kill Baseball and Football (the one played with hand) in the country.