7 ms·
There are a ton of /8 still assigned to companies that don't need them. Ford, GE, IBM, AT&T (x2), Xerox, HP (x2), Apple, MIT, CSC, Eli Lilly, Nortel, Prudentia
by ars 13y ago
There are a ton of /8 still assigned to companies that don't need them.
Ford, GE, IBM, AT&T (x2), Xerox, HP (x2), Apple, MIT, CSC, Eli Lilly, Nortel, Prudential Insurance, DuPont, Cap Debis, Merck, SITA.
All of those can return their /8. That's 18 /8 potentially available.
And does the DoD really need 12 /8's? I get that they want to network every person, gun, ship, tank, truck and plane. But none of those need to be on the public internet. (Well, maybe the people do - but 1 /8 should be enough for that.)
- Afforess 13y agoRumormill at IBM is that we bought some random companies a while back just for their IPv4 blocks. You didn't hear that from me though.
- jychang 13y agoDoubt it, everything on IBM is natted to a 10.0.0.0/8 or is running externally to 9.0.0.0/8. Source: I work at IBM, in a division that was another company that was bought out a few years back.
- peterkelly 13y agoI think the suggestion was that they expected those blocks could become very valuable in the future and could thus be sold for a healthy profit. I don't think GP meant that IBM wanted to actually use those addresses themselves.
- wmf 13y agoIBM is using 9/8. AT&T is one of the largest ISPs in the world. Hopefully any legacy space that isn't used will come up for sale soon.
- recuter 13y ago> All of those can return their /8. That's 18 /8 potentially available. If say, Apple is using at least a little bit of that /8 here and there (safe assumption, no?) its going to be hard for them to return it. I'd wager corporations that have /8s have policies that rely on the assumption that they have the whole /8. So I wouldn't hold my breath on getting one back from them.
- xxpor 13y agoRight. How much code is out there that looks like if(recv.ip.contains("2.") { //well we know that they're from X co. }
- sliverstorm 13y agoI'm not sure if you are being sarcastic. I'd bet a lot.
- xxpor 13y agoNot sarcastic. There's a ton of code like that. I've seen it. Also, I'm surprised no one called me out on the typo and bug in my code :)
- banachtarski 13y agoI'm assuming that smiley face provides the missing paren.
- Dylan16807 13y agoThere's no reason they would have to return the entire thing. Some /16s would be fine.
- teddyh 13y agoIt would also be completely useless, as implementing the reassignment would dwarf the cost of moving to IPv6.
- michaelt 13y agoReassigning some ipv4 IPs on a handful of corporations' internal networks would dwarf the cost of upgrading the entire internet infrastructure to ipv6? I get assigned a new ipv4 IP by DHCP every time I reboot my computer. And you should hear the infrastructure people at my ISP and workplace and university squeal when you ask them about ipv6 - far too much work, they say, no plans on the horizon.
- mfincham 13y agoReturning them would only delay the inevitable by a matter of months. Deploy IPv6 today, it ain't hard.
- pyre 13y agoHow would end-user software deal with an IPv6 address though? Surely some of it is IPv6 capable already, but I would imagine that a lot of it makes assumptions about IPv4. If the OS were operating on a IPv6 network, would that software function correctly as long as the addresses were IPv4-compatible (i.e. within the IPv4 range, and not in IPv6 notation)?
- gizmo686 13y agoYou can run both at the same time. Any software that is not IPv6 compatible would still be able to connect through IPv4 and just not have access to IPv6 addresses. The bigger issue would be connecting to IPv6 only servers from an IPv4 program. The first question is how many IPv4 only programs exist in the wild. If you happen to have one, and cannot update it, then you still have the option of creating an IPv4 to IPv6 proxy for the specific site(s) you need.
- mfincham 13y ago"It depends", is unfortunately the answer. For very old software where it's not possible to patch it for IPv6 support (this is rarer than you might think!) then some kind of IPv4 NAT or a DNS64 style "application layer gateway" is required. You could also potentially add a specific wrapper for your application e.g. wrapping MySQL connections inside of stunnel allows them to run over IPv6 in version of MySQL built with v6 support, or for simple daemons you can do things like set up socat to proxy between an IPv4 socket and an IPv6 socket. Almost no software you're likely to be running is incompatible with IPv6, though. Software support for IPv6 is way ahead of actual network implementation.
- pyre 13y ago> Almost no software you're likely to be running is incompatible with IPv6 What about user inputs that only accept IPv4-formatted addresses? :P
- Negitivefrags 13y agoCan those companies sell their IPs on the open market when the normal pool has run out? Is that allowed?
- mfincham 13y agoIt depends on the policies of the RIR (Regional Internet Registry) in the region where the IPs are from. That said, if you're willing to ignore the RIR's policies (which a lot of people do) you can usually "black market" trade IP addresses, so long as you can convince your upstreams to accept them (which they usually will).
- bifrost 13y agoShort answer : no
- lmm 13y agoLegally it's an allocation, not ownership. The registry could simply revoke your allocations if it caught you selling them (though whether it would is another question).
- 300bps 13y agoWhen I owned an ISP in 1996 I paid a larger ISP money to suballocate a range of a couple /24s to me. This happens all the time - look up any random netblock on arin.net.
- Decade 13y agoThere are various reasons that the legacy IPv4 assignments are not returned. At the normal rate of IPv4 address assignment, circa 2011 when IANA ran out, reclaiming all those addresses would have delayed address space exhaustion by maybe 2 years at most. All it would have cost was unpredictable, unbound man-years of work as each organization tracked down each of their publicly addressable machines, not all of which were recorded, and vacated into smaller subnets of their address space. I'm sure you know of the servers that sometimes disappear behind walls during renovations. And some of the older machines require the kernel to be recompiled and rebooted to change their IP address. Ah, those were the days. We just have to face the fact that IPv4 was not designed to be used on a network the size of the Internet. NAT and CIDR have stretched it out amazingly, but we've stretched it out about as far as it will go. We need to switch to IPv6.
- masklinn 13y ago> There are a ton of /8 still assigned to companies that don't need them. You've got no idea how they're structured internally. Some of those companies uses their blocks to make every machine in their network globally routable, they don't "need" them but they do use them and they're part of their network architecture.
- 300bps 13y agoThey are using 16,777,214 IP addresses? I think that's quite a stretch. I work at a company that has 19,000 employees with locations all over the world. We couldn't make a dent in 16.7MM routeable IP addresses.
- masklinn 13y ago> They are using 16,777,214 IP addresses? No, they are using their block and their network strategy is predicated upon having an essentially infinite set of IP addresses available. > I work at a company that has 19,000 employees with locations all over the world. We couldn't make a dent in 16.7MM routeable IP addresses. Please note that not only can there be multiple IPs per employee, there are also IPs assigned to services and servers.
- 300bps 13y agoPlease note that not only can there be multiple IPs per employee, there are also IPs assigned to services and servers. I would ask you to please note that there are non-routeable addresses that can be used for these purposes. You do realize that the /8 they've been granted is a public Internet netblock? You realize that 99.999% of the world doesn't use public Internet addresses on their employee's workstations or internal servers? But for the sake of argument let's assume Ford (one of the owners of a /8) has 200,000 employees and that each of them is using 10 public IP addresses. That's 2MM. Then let's assume they have 10,000 servers and each one is taking up 100 IP addresses. That's another 1MM for a total of $3MM which is less than 1/5 of the addresses they're currently allocated. Oh, and Ford only has 164,000 employees and I guarantee that each employee isn't even using 1 public IP address let alone 10. And 10,000 servers with 100 public IP addresses is just as ridiculous. Do you see now how wasteful it is that certain organizations have these /8s? Beyond that, it really sounds like you don't know the difference between a public and private IP address. If for no other reason, places like Ford should have been using private IP address space for internal servers and workstations for security purposes.
- belorn 13y agoIn the global market, returning those addresses won't help at all. Currently, the only reason the American registry still has any IP addresses left, is because their pool was separated from the emerging markets in Asia. As such, if IANA would start extracting IP address as suggested, the global market would eat it up faster than IANA could collect them. It would only "work" if IANA gave all the addresses exclusively to the American pool, working towards a local Internet rather than global.
- teddyh 13y agoSee, you'd like to think so. You'd like to think that there's an easy solution not involving you, because it would mean you don't have to do anything or learn anything new. However, as pointed out in many other comments in this thread, this (and many other knee-jerk reaction "solutions") won't actually work, or would be significantly more expensive than implementing IPv6. It's been on the horizon for nearly 20 years. It's coming soon now. The IPv4 end is nigh. Repent!