6 ms·
It seems like one of the foundations of this article is that customers tend to regret their in-app purchases. I don't doubt that this could be the case, but I'd
by baddox 13y ago
It seems like one of the foundations of this article is that customers tend to regret their in-app purchases. I don't doubt that this could be the case, but I'd love to see studies done on this topic. I would think that, even if you assume game devs are greedy or motivated primarily by profit, at least some of them would think that the best long-term play would be to not make users regret their purchases.
- sillysaurus 13y agoI'm a game developer. I want to make one thing clear: The people who make these sorts of games aren't gamedevs. They are social engineers. It's unfortunate that the distinction hasn't been very clearly defined. It's not true that just because they've created an interactive loop that they've made a game.
- pico303 13y agoI agree. We shouldn't call these things games. They are predatory social assaults on the unsuspecting.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- yareally 13y agoI relate it to casino gambling without the small potential of being able to get a payout in return.
- baddox 13y agoThese things aren't mutually exclusive. Feel free to hinge your argument on a wildly restrictive definition of "game" that is shared by virtually no one, but I think there are better arguments to be made.
- philwelch 13y agoIf by whiskey...
- andrewingram 13y agono true scotsman...
- baddox 13y agoThere's no point to use purely semantic arguments to try to bash these guys. Clearly I wasn't using the term "game dev" with the intention of drawing any comparisons to your livelihood, except for the obvious comparison which is that you both produce interactive applications that most people would call "games."
- sillysaurus 13y agoNo no, it's a distinction I've wanted to make for a long time. It's a positive thing to encourage discussion of how game development is different from social engineering, and what social engineers can learn from game development fundamentals.
- andrewingram 13y agoThis may be an example of the "no true scotsman" fallacy. You're saying no true game developer would use social exploitation in this way. Implying that any game developer who does, isn't in fact a game developer. The problem with this approach is that it absolves any such person who considers themselves a true game developer of the responsibility. I think it's more valuable to view social engineering as the dark side of game development, and look for ways to minimise it. It's similar to the way software developers often come up with (or are asked to come up with) "dark patterns" to manipulate users into signing up for stuff or buying stuff without realising it. It's our responsibility as developers to recognise when this is happening and actively work to stop it.
- dsirijus 13y agoI've actively started to work on a blog series called The Dark Side of Game Design, while at the same time working on a game "from the dark side" for which I've gotten funded for. Should be interesting exploration of morality and ethics in it. Only real shame is that current game design of the game I'm working on doesn't include parody of it all. I'm just not that good a game designer yet. :)
- dominostars 13y agoI can tell you from my admittedly limited mobile social game development experience that user acquisition is really expensive. You need the users you get to make lots of purchases. If your purchases suck, or elicit regret, you're not going survive for very long. It is very common industry advice that purchases should feel really good and provide instant gratification. Industry experts know that once a user makes a first purchase they have a smaller barrier of entry for making more. The industry is all about whales, not about making a quick buck on a user who doesn't know better. Of course there are companies who don't know any better that are trying to money grab as much as possible, but they're not as successful as you might think. They achieve ranking with a large advertising budget before disappearing into obscurity. But what a lot of people don't want to accept is that a game like FarmVille is a good game that many people legitimately enjoy and feel good spending money on.
- chii 13y agoLots of people feel good spending money on heroin, and it also makes them feel good (proven - it chemically makes you feel good!). But you can't possibly agree that heroin is good for you, nor those who make or sell it is justified in making and selling it.
- dominostars 13y agoI did not discuss the morality of addictive game mechanics. I was responding to the assertion that people regret making in app purchases. The author was operating under the assumption that users are being misled or tricked into making purchases that they would later regret. I was merely explaining why most successful IAP-driven games could not reach success this way.
- xerophtye 13y agoInteresting point. But the whole point of social engineers is to figure how to make people WANT to buy stuff (not make them buy stuff) and that includes making them enjoy their purchases. What i understand from the article is that people don't regret their purchases immediately. What they regret is the realization that they spent way too much on their game. And thus there should be mechanisms to avoid that regret. And so i love the 2nd suggestion.