3 ms·
You know, arcade games were sometimes freakishly hard so that you'd stand there pumping quarters in to try again and again. Nobody called that immoral. I don't
by derefr 13y ago
You know, arcade games were sometimes freakishly hard so that you'd stand there pumping quarters in to try again and again. Nobody called that immoral. I don't think there's anything wrong with charging for continues (or health potions, or clean bombs, or whatever.) Telling you how much money a game makes off people, and how much you've spent on it, won't help you to decide whether the tactics it's using to get you to give it that money are ethical.
- ricardobeat 13y agoGames have their own dynamics, the expectations and rewards are different. Now, when you download a 'free' drawing app and then find out the pen costs $5, it's just an annoyance; it builds resentment and lowers your trust in the app store. There is no reward other than what you already expected to be there, and even when done well (eg Paper) it still feels a tad bit dishonest.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- w4 13y agoThat sort of thing is a reaction, by developers, to Apple's unwillingness to add demos (and consumer's unwillingness to shell out when there's no demo). Calling it a "pen" is probably not the best way of marketing it, but basically you're buying the full version. The free install is a trial. If Apple added demoing all of that would vanish pretty quickly, I suspect.
- voltagex_ 13y agoThere's a difference between putting a piece of metal in a slot and pushing a button that's vaguely connected to your bank account. I'm sure one of the recent 99% Invisible podcasts had something about the increase in revenue when slot machines were able to use credit cards, or banknotes.
- hrktb 13y agoA key difference is that in an arcade game you have to pay to start, and you have no expectations of free play (you have to beat the game to not pay anything more). The same model for in-app purchass would be good actually.
- chii 13y agoAKA, instead of free to play, its pay to play!
- lucian1900 13y agoI've only ever played arcade games as an adult, a few years ago. They seemed very exploitative to me, tiny play times for gigantic costs.
- jsight 13y agoWhen you feed coins to an arcade machine, you are essentially renting someone else's equipment for some period of time. The idea that occupying someone else's machine for a longer period of time would cost more than for a shorter period is a reasonable expectation on the part of the consumer[1]. There is no similar expectation when purchasing a game. It doesn't make sense for me to have to rent more time on a game on my own hardware[2]. [1] Nevertheless, the comparison is apt in some ways, as the process of encouraging people to feed more coins often distorted the gameplay in the same was as it does with IAP-based games. [2] I know, the current reason for much of this is that MANY casual gamers are resistant to put even $1 down initially. There are very few models that work for games targeted at this crowd, and IAP may actually be the best approach here.