2 ms·
"So IMHO the right approach is a top-down rewrite..." This is almost always an extremely bad idea: http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html h
by jimbokun 13y ago
"So IMHO the right approach is a top-down rewrite..."
This is almost always an extremely bad idea:
http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000069.html
I have no inside knowledge, but wouldn't be surprised at all if many of the problems of the new NYC 911 system is due to a decision to rewrite the code from scratch, losing much of the knowledge and bug fixes embedded in the old system's source code.
- josh2600 13y agoI know but you have to understand, Joel makes excellent points, but if most of the systems are written in COBOL it makes them hard to extend over time. We're talking about software from 1984 in some cases although it's all littered with security holes, bad interfaces and slow response times. In the case of NY, I could agree with you, but I would say that the problem was significantly overcomplicated. There are better systems that could be used to deliver something like this. I think that, yes, sometimes you do need to do a top-down rewrite, especially when everything is wrong. I do agree with your point that the NY incident is likely attributable to poor software design, but I disagree with the conclusion that any rewrite would suffer from the same malady.