7 ms·
This is a fascinating comment, but one bit leaves me confused: How come you still have to pay rent?
by mkl 13y ago
This is a fascinating comment, but one bit leaves me confused: How come you still have to pay rent?
- mitchellh 13y agoI'm not sure I understand this question? If you're asking why I don't own a house, its because I'm not quite ready to make that commitment at this point in my life. :) I'm happy with the flexibility of paying rent, and I pay a REALLY low amount of rent (by San Francisco standards) in a nice place. I'm content.
- prawn 13y agoObviously much depends on your exact financial position and the state of the real estate market, but you don't have to live where you buy forever. It can be advantageous to get into the market and rent out your property if you get bored, leveraging your tenants rental payments.
- kintamanimatt 13y agoIt can be extraordinarily disadvantageous too. Property prices are still extremely high and it's not clear whether this is sustainable over the long-run. Buying or selling a house (at least where I have experience) is a slow, expensive, and fragile process; there are significant costs for both parties. Renting out a property isn't fun either. Finding suitable tenants and dealing with repairs and other silliness, or paying a property management company that's often despised by tenants, isn't necessarily trivial. Rents might not cover mortgage payments in certain economic periods, especially when factoring in additional expenses. The time that's spent dealing with this headache could be better used doing something else. Lastly, certain types of mortgages might prohibit renting, and I've seen people caught with their pants down over this. Owning a place is a burden. It can make financial sense to do so in some situations but I'd be reluctant to buy unless I truly felt I was going to remain in one location for a long (>10 years) period of time. I certainly wouldn't feel like I could just rent it out if I wanted to hop, skip, and jump to a new location after a year or two, or less. Of course, all my experience is based on buying and renting in the UK. It might be different wherever you are.
- prawn 13y agoIt is different in Australia though it's not an especially liquid asset anywhere. Market has flattened, but it's still strong. Prices tend to double every ten years but moved more quickly recently. Haven't heard of anyone not able to rent their property out. Most people who can afford to will buy property. There is no expectation that rent will cover a mortgage - you pay the shortfall and it's still a deal worth considering.
- kintamanimatt 13y agoThe difference between the UK and Australia is Australia has tight controls on foreign property ownership, and it can be quite a hassle to buy if you're not a long-term visa holder or citizen. Long-term visa holders also have to sell the property at the end of their stay.[0] Australia also has a decent number of moderate-stay (<=12 months) temporary residents (working holiday, etc) that aren't allowed to buy under FIRB guidelines, or don't have the fiscal means, both of which increase demand for rentals. I strongly doubt whether the increasing price of housing is sustainable. If it's increasing beyond that of inflation, it's a bubble and people simply just aren't going to be able to afford it. People on the upswing of any market become complacent that prices will always continue to rise, but this isn't necessarily true. The future is yet to be determined, and who knows what will happen. I have known landlords who have had their properties vacant for several months at a time. Their mortgages continued though and this put a lot of pressure on them financially. There's also the issue of tenants that end up not paying, or paying late, etc. You're not wrong and your strategy has a strong superficial appeal: property ownership with flexibility! Properties can be rented out, it's possible to find great long-term tenants, and it's even possible to break even or make a slight profit as an amateur landlord. Your strategy can be made to work, it's just the costs probably aren't worth it unless you're a landlord with a good number of properties. I'd argue the actual flexibility is marginal compared to renting; if I want to leave my rented property, I can do so quite easily and with minimal moving costs. I do appreciate the cost of this flexibility too though: I'm paying someone else's mortgage with nothing to show for it in the long term. Also, owning has the distinct advantage of control: nobody's going to be a more accommodating landlord to me than me! [0] This assumes that the property is a second-hand dwelling, not one bought from a new developer, or been renovated, or any of the other exceptions that come to mind.
- chii 13y agobit odd you hasn't paid rent but instead paid a mortgage, would you have been better off financially?
- protomyth 13y agoQuite a lot of people aren't better off. In fact, a lot of them have underwater mortgages because they listened to the "house is an investment" crowd. Buying a house and losing your job / income source, can cause some pretty long term unemployment since it is hard to move with an anchor around you. As a country, we would have been a lot better off if a lot more people had been renters.
- derleth 13y ago> the "house is an investment" crowd They are. What people neglect to mention is that some investments, houses included, fail to pan out, and leave you worse off than you were before. Simply assuming that a mortgage builds useful equity is financially illiterate: If houses were a sure thing, everyone and every institution would buy them. The really insidious idea is the idea that buying a house is what a mature, responsible person does, and that you can't be a mature, responsible person unless you're paying down a mortgage. This is marginally less potentially harmful to your future happiness than the idea that mature, responsible people smoke five packs of cigarettes a day.
- wazoox 13y agoTo make your argument clearer: if you buy a house and don't bring a significant amount of your own money to the deal (let's say 20 to 30% of the whole), as during the first years of the mortgage you're mostly paying interest and almost no capital, you're actually throwing your money down the drain in exactly the same way as you'd do paying a rent, BUT with the added responsibilities coming with the mortgage on one hand, and owning the house on the other hand.
- protomyth 13y agoNicely stated (wish I had done a better job of it). That's basically the trap. Some people can do that and a house makes sense. People like to own. A lot of people bought a house and fell into the trap you describe. A lot of those people didn't have good job mobility in the local area[1]. 1) I would love to see a study from about 2000 to now on all the folks that defaulted and what their down payment was combined with the job outlook for their profession.
- Kiro 13y agoI don't know what country you live in but in my country you still have to pay rent for apartments you own. This fee goes to maintaining the building etc.
- LaGrange 13y agoIn many countries that's a normal, reasonable course of action. I wouldn't buy a home unless I had a proper reason to do so (most likely wanting modifications that wouldn't go past the landlord, though I'd rather look for something for-rent that already fits me first). Unless you have cash, the failure scenario in case of buying is extremely nasty. Also, there's a lot of administrative and maintenance related work that, in case of rented, is not my problem anymore.
- jtheory 13y agoMy wife & I bought a house about 7 years ago, and we still like the house, but wish we hadn't bought it. There are quite a few areas of expertise required to manage a property, and if you don't have them yet it can cost you (both in money and time). Sure, you can hire someone else to do repairs. But how will you know what repairs are required (do you ask the roofer if this is a patch job, or if a new roof is needed)? How do you know what a given repair or renovation should reasonably cost? How do you find trustworthy contractors? The ones everyone recommends will be busy through next year, more or less, and the unknowns are exactly that. What tasks can you reasonably do yourself (without experience) as opposed to hiring someone? I.e., shower grout, replacing a light fixture, installing a dishwasher/stove, installing shelving, replacing a door lock, putting weather stripping around windows, small painting jobs, etc.. My wife & I had a few years with significantly lower income. If we had been renting, we would have rented a cheaper place for those years. But we own a house -- so we basically just spent a few years unable to afford to maintain it properly. More recently, we now have kids and have been thinking of leaving the area entirely -- moving to a different city, or possibly leaving the country. But to sell or rent the house, we should finish renovation/repairs first. And the selling market isn't great now, but becoming a landlord -- especially remotely -- would require a whole new set of skills. I've learned a hell of a lot (mostly through error) over these years, but these are not all skills I have wanted to learn, or how I've wanted to spend my time; the fact of buying the house forced an awful lot of experiences after it. If you rent, you pay someone else to handle all that. If they do a poor job, you look for a better place (and it's not fun to find a new place and move, but it's not a huge deal).
- 13y ago
- 300bps 13y agoMy previous house I bought in 2005. I paid $492,000 for it and sold it 5 years later for $420,000. Oh and I paid 6% commission to sell it, 1% transfer tax to buy it, 1% transfer tax to sell it and I put about $60,000 of capital improvements into it. My current house I paid $567,000 for it and it's worth $540,000 based on my most recent appraisal. Again, paid 1% transfer tax to buy it and if I ever sell it (I hope to God not) I will pay 1% transfer tax and 6% Realtor "tax". Notice I didn't mention routine maintenance and fixing things that broke during the last several years? Believe me when I say I wish I would've rented. I'd have about $200,000 more in my bank account right now.
- larrys 13y ago"Believe me when I say I wish I would've rented. I'd have about $200,000 more in my bank account" Because you had a bad outcome. So first w/o getting into the math numbers which I will assume are correct I will say the following. Looking at any decision strictly by the numbers may make you come to the wrong conclusion and is a reason why it sometimes can be a mistake to look at only one angle (financial or, say, engineering) when making a decision. For example the housing stock when renting tends to be more transient and less stable than with buying (people coming and going). Now even if you can rent a house in a stable neighborhood (rather than an apartment building) that is primarily owned and occupied by owners (as opposed to renters) you still end up with the issue of a) having to rely on someone else (the landlord) to fix things. b) not being able to make improvements to the property (because you need approval or because why put in a new kitchen to something you don't own?) and c) The neighbors may treat you differently if you are a renter (may or may not happen may or may not matter simply pointing out). You are of course also susceptible to the whims of the landlord rent wise and have the costs of moving if you need to do so. Owning (as does owning a business rather than being an employee) also comes with certain "psychic" benefits that are hard to quantify and, most importantly, have different value to different people. Personally (and I've rented obviously) I prefer to own because that way I can do what I want when I want even recognizing that it might cost me more to live that way. I also buy cars I never lease. I like to sell when I want to sell and not have to wait for the term to end. Other people are looking for another type of certainty (that isn't important to me) or perhaps don't have the cash flow or need the cash flow for something else. Everybody is different. As far as your situation you bought in 2005 and in hindsight you are not happy with the decision. I've had ups and downs with real estate as well (more ups though over time). "I paid $567,000 for it and it's worth $540,000 based on my most recent appraisal." Doesn't mean anything until you decide to sell it though. I have a property (investment) that I bought for about 50k, could have sold at the top for, say, 180k, is worth now perhaps 125k. Unless I want to sell none of that really matters (don't need to finance it or anything) only thing that really changes is the property tax. "Notice I didn't mention routine maintenance and fixing things" Once again some people may prefer to take care of this in something they own and not be bothered by it (just like some people don't want to wait for the "tech guy" to come and get the PC running). Personally there are pros and cons to each thing. If the A/C breaks in my house I would rather not have to wait for a management company to scramble a repairman to fix it. Everyone is different.
- jonnathanson 13y agoAside from the personal financial risks detailed (quite well) in the comments below, there's also the PITA factor. Homeownership is a Pain In The Ass. Especially if you live in a "shared community," such as a condo building in SF, with a strong-willed HOA. Especially if you live in a home or building with any sort of construction issues -- most of which will reveal themselves, by Murphy's Law, the week after you lift contingencies and close escrow. Especially if you are the least bit neurotic about home prices, the state of the market, and the preservation of your principal (to say nothing of positive ROI). Buying is not for the faint of heart, the easily stressed, or anyone who's even slightly uncertain about the direction of the next 5-10 years of his life. Some people just don't want the headache. And you don't know how big a headache it really is until you've taken the plunge. I know more than a few former homeowners who have sworn they'll never buy again, regardless of whether it makes financial sense.