4 ms·
Ask HN: Is it illegal to require users to be under a certain age?
Many sites require that users be over a certain age, for example Facebook requires users to be at least 13, most dating sites require users to be legal adults, as do most porn sites. It's obvious why that's all considered perfectly legal and reasonable.
Is it legal to require users to be under a certain age (eg 30)? Does anyone have personal experience with this, or know of any sites with such requirements? My concern is an age discrimination lawsuit. I've been building web businesses since the mid 1990s, but I honestly have never run across this issue before, and I suspect it's a murky area legally; as in, it's not technically illegal, but someone could definitely sue you for age discrimination and have a case, but that doesn't mean someone will ever bother to do so.
- anigbrowl 13y agoNot a lawyer, but FWIW: if it's employment-related, tread very carefullyYou could specify that a potential employee must be 'in touch with what's new and hip' but it's risky to say that you won't hire anyone over 30 (as well as maybe unwise). If you're looking to hand out scholarships or somesuch, it's probably much less of an issue. If you want to make Logansrun.com* where everyone has to be under 30 to join up and waste time on your social network, you're probably safe, as old and middle-aged people are not a protected class that I'm aware of. * Of course being able to reference Logan's Run dates me as over 40.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> As in, it's not technically illegal, but someone could definitely sue you for age discrimination and have a case Did you just say that age discrimination both is and is not illegal?
- adventured 13y agoThat's sort of correct. There's nothing inherently illegal about discrimination: it just means to recognize a distinction between. Most types of discrimination are legal. Work places always discriminate when they pick the best candidate. There are many instances in which age discrimination is not illegal (I listed three examples in the post). Facebook is a massive age discriminator for example, and it's entirely legal; ditto porn sites. American drinking laws age discriminate against 20 year olds (so every liquor store is an age discriminator). Sometimes age discrimination is considered illegal, and sometimes it is not. My question was whether it's illegal to require users to be under the age of 30. I plan to age discriminate against people of certain ages (under 18, over 30).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> My question was whether it's illegal to require users to be under the age of 30. I was referring to your statement that you believed that it was: 1. Technically not illegal to do so, and 2. That if you did so, someone would "be able to sue for age discrimination and have a good case". You seemed to believe both sides on the illegality issue not just of age discrimination in a broad sense, but of the specific act.
- adventured 13y agoObviously you can be sued for things that aren't technically illegal, and you can lose due to a sympathetic jury. I'm not certain on the legality of this context, but I have generalized industry knowledge accumulated from the past 18 or so years (that is, at best I can make a decent guess). I was hoping someone with direct experience on this issue might respond. In this case in which the legality doesn't appear to be well determined, there may very well not be a single law on the books when it comes to restricting usage of a site to people below a certain age. However, a jury might set an example then and there; and given the litigious times we live in, that's a real risk. I think you run the lawsuit risk at all times these days, but if I know for certain this isn't illegal right now, then it boosts my confidence that in a lawsuit situation I at least have a fighting chance.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Obviously you can be sued for things that aren't technically illegal, and you can lose due to a sympathetic jury. If the trier of law -- which is the judge, not the jury, in a jury trial -- finds that the facts claimed in a suit don't meet the standards for a violation of the law, the case will be dismissed (assuming the defense moves for a dismissal on the grounds of non-suit, which is fairly routine in any case where there is even a remote question) without ever reaching the jury. And even if the suit alleges an offense which meets the definition of a violation of the law, but the judge feels that the evidence presented doesn't support those allegation (such that no reasonably jury could find the allegations true based on the evidence presented), the judge is obliged to enter a judgement for the defense even in the face of a jury verdict in the opposite direction. So, while people can write and file a suit for anything that suits their fancy, it takes more than that and a sympathetic jury to result in liability.
- random_us3rnam3 13y agoDisney's Club Penguin is an example of a site with implicit maximum age restrictions. Per the "How do I become a member?" FAQ [1]: "It's very simple to become a Club Penguin member. Before you purchase a membership, you'll need to ask an adult for their permission. "Once you have an adult's permission, visit our Membership page together to add a membership to your penguin account. " [1] http://www.clubpenguin.com/help/help-topics/membership/how-do-i-become-member http://www.clubpenguin.com/help/help-topics/membership/how-d...