3 ms·
The paper you link to is pay wall protected so I'm loathe to dismiss it without actually reading it...but the fact that it's been cited once and has this in its
by danso 13y ago
The paper you link to is pay wall protected so I'm loathe to dismiss it without actually reading it...but the fact that it's been cited once and has this in its abstract:
> Motivation -- To evaluate people's acceptance of the minimalist approach to information visualization.
Um, OK...there are so many things wrong with that as a scientific hypothesis that I don't even know where to start. Perhaps the fact that this hypothesis was tested against a single example is a sufficient red flag? Doesn't it feel a bit of a stretch to refer to this study's findings so matter of factly?
In any case, though, I agree with this study. And so maybe would Tufte...it's not about what people prefer, it's about what people actually learn and understand from the graphics. Is your purpose to clarify and educate? Or to please the eye? I don't think Tufte would ever argue that he would win in a contest of the latter (it is true, though, that elegance often correlates with simplicity)...so what this "study" is trying to prove entirely misses the point.
Do a study of whether an average group of people are more drawn to the works of Ernest Hemingway versus Dan Brown...I don't think you'd find the results of that study being a conclusive argument that Dan Brown is among our greatest writers.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThe study was scientific in measuring subject preference. That doesn't say much obviously. Many people prefer hamburgers to salads, and eye candy is often preferred even when it reduces efficiency.