7 ms·
The Surface RT experience was summed up best for me by the wife of a Microsoft employee and friend of mine: "it makes me feel stupid". I guess she'll be stickin
by mikestew 13y ago
The Surface RT experience was summed up best for me by the wife of a Microsoft employee and friend of mine: "it makes me feel stupid". I guess she'll be sticking with her iPad.
Me, I didn't think it was that bad. Though I, too, wondered "why wouldn't I just buy and iPad?" Seems that's a question everyone else asked themselves.
- mjn 13y agoNot sure it'd be sufficient, but the entry-level model is considerably cheaper. $350 for a Surface, $500 for an iPad.
- cclogg 13y agoBut then you have the iPad Mini too...
- rgbrenner 13y agoIsn't the $350 figure after the recent price cut?
- anigbrowl 13y agoThey should have launched Surface as it sown OS instead of trying to be Windows. I actually want an Intel Windows tablet because there's a bunch of audio software I'd use that will never be available on the iPad and it would be great to have a touch interface for my-obscure-applications. but Windows RT was the worst of both worlds - since it doesn't do anything in particular, I might as well just buy an iPad (if I want groovy, albeit somewhat limited, apps) or a Kindle Fire (if I just want to surf the web and consume content).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- honestcoyote 13y agoThat might help now, though I suspect it won't help much, but at release, and for a long time afterwards, the Surface was $599.
- shinratdr 13y agoAs of a couple days ago, and you're choosing to ignore the true entry level device in the iPad line, the iPad mini which can't match on specs but does beat it on price, portability and form factor. I can't think of a single person I've talked to about purchasing a tablet that considers specs except for myself so that's hardly the motivator some would make it out to be.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoHigh resolution screen on the iPad 3 was great. That was one important spec.
- zmmmmm 13y ago> "why wouldn't I just buy and iPad?" There's exactly one answer to that question: office. 9 hours of office in a device the size of a pad of paper. But the problem is, the exact people who would buy RT for that reason cannot use it or would not want it for a range of other factors (for example, it cannot join a domain). And now with the new Intel chips there is no reason at all, because you can get 9 hours of office from a full Win8 tablet.
- mtgx 13y agoBut it wasn't optimized for tablets. It's the same experience you would've gotten with Office ten years ago on "tablet PC's". And why would you want real Office on a tablet anyway? Fost most of the stuff you'd be doing on a tablet, you're probably better off with a free/much cheaper Office alternative that's also touch-optimized.
- mdmarra 13y agoOffice 2013 is touch optimized.
- shinratdr 13y agoLike Windows 7 was "touch optimized". In other words, it isn't.
- binarycrusader 13y agoOh really? The reviews seem to disagree: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/07/why-bother-the-sad-state-of-office-2013-touch-support/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/07/why-bo...
- workbench 13y agohttp://cdn.arstechnica.net//wp-content/uploads/2012/07/touch-outlook-2013-ribbon-composite.png http://cdn.arstechnica.net//wp-content/uploads/2012/07/touch... lol
- olegbl 13y ago
- MatthewPhillips 13y agoI own a Surface RT and don't particular like it. I could list all of the reasons (it's slow, most of the software is bad, the corners are sharp, etc) but I don't think they have anything to with why it didn't sell well. Probably price is the only thing that matters here. Price and exposure. You can't compete with name brand -- no matter the merit -- if you can't beat them in price.
- gcb0 13y agowow. and the ipad doesn't? i'm shocked. really. i'm not trolling, belive it or not, but i fell like in a straight jacket using any iOS device.
- Zarel 13y agoI think what mikestew means is that the Surface RT makes her feel stupid because she can't figure out how to use it.
- mikestew 13y agoCorrect, the iPad apparently does not make her feel stupid. Hence my following comment about how she'll probably be keeping her iPad. It would seem my wording made the answer obvious, but I'm open to suggestions on how it could have been more clear.
- tootie 13y ago"why wouldn't I just buy and iPad?" Because they are expensive and completely locked down?
- CamperBob2 13y agoAs opposed to a Surface?!
- rbanffy 13y agoUnlike the Surface RT?
- kabdib 13y agoMy wife got one, and the first week she had it she was surfing forums and mucking around with the task monitor and RegEdit (!) in order to deal with some runaway process caused by an errant app. Maybe a game. We never found out. It's supposed to be designed so it can't go haywire that way, but it does. Fail. Never heard of such a problem on an iPad. The Windows division might think it knows how to deliver a tablet-friendly OS, but really, it doesn't. It's clownville; they don't understand how to do box-level security (as on consoles) and they don't know how to do stability at the level required by a "mom" consumer product. (The Xbox group took Win8 and had to do extensive modifications in order to make it play well -- the original mandate from the execs were "run Win8 without any changes" and /that/ would have been a fucking disaster). If Microsoft is serious about putting a real "tabletized" version of Win8 in consumer hands, they need to do a bunch of housecleaning and internal education. It's a mess.
- ghshephard 13y ago"Never heard of such a problem on an iPad." My iPad has now reached the point where, if I don't carefully set it into Airplane mode, Battery drains in 24 hours, even when asleep. I don't know if it's my mail client, or a background task being woke up by a geofence, or one of the GPS/WiFi radios - but I can't reliably leave it sitting around for several days anymore. So, now I get into the game of "Disable Location Services for All applications, Disable Notification Services for All Applications, Turn off all Radios - NOW, turn on a small handful of services, and observe for a week - if everything looks good, turn on some more - keep doing so until the battery starts draining in 24 hours, and then try and identify the errant applications" My #1 gripe about the iPad continues to be battery draining because of background tasks. If I could only "Force" the iPad into NO MULTITASKING, Single Damn Application at a time and NOTHING else mode, Don't Check Email, Don't Check GPS, Don't play music, Don't Download - I'd be happy. The only reliable way I've found of guranteeing this is to power it down - but it takes a long time (90+ seconds) to power it up each time I want to use it, which kind of detracts from the device... So, no - iPad is not perfect. I would say 50% of my time this trip, when I went to use it, battery was completely dead so I ended up with my MacBook Air sitting on my chest to do reading.
- 13y ago
- mistermann 13y agoThe iPad interface makes me feel like the general public is stupid. It is so terribly inefficient and dumbed down in so many ways that I have a huge incentive to use anything else.
- workbench 13y agoThe general public ARE stupid