13 ms·
Not Constructive, a place for the discussions not allowed on Stack Overflow
- arms 13y agoInteresting idea, and even better name.
- worldsayshi 13y agoI feel like Discourse (http://www.discourse.org/ http://www.discourse.org/) would have been a good fit for a site like this.
- petercooper 13y agoHaha, I've joked with a few people there needs to be a 'CrapOverflow' as a sort of cesspit of programming 'debate' so it's good to see someone following through. (Funnily enough, I just checked and Stack Exchange owns crapoverflow.com :-))
- andrewstuart 13y agoHopefully it's not a cesspit, rather a good place to ask questions such as "which language is best for building applications such as...etc" or "which is the best of the current crop of JavaScript MVC frameworks in late 2012" or other stuff that isn't strictly technical questions with well defined technical answers.
- ircmaxell 13y agoInteresting choice of questions. Neither of which have an answer. Unless you want to discuss the fine details of the problem. In which case I'll hire your site to do the architecture for free next time I have a major project. Questions like that aren't unanswerable. They are however unanswerable without knowing a lot about your specific case (requirements, skills, staff, infrastructure, etc). So they tend not to be QA because they either get surface treatment (leading people to make bad decisions on partial information) or they lead to abuse (people taking advantage of it).
- mindcrime 13y agoQuestions like that aren't unanswerable. If by "answerable" you mean "have one, and one one, unique, correct, objectively verifiable answer, which can be determined using only the provided information". But this kind of definition of "answerable", while fairly close to what SO uses, is overly rigid and eliminates the potential of a lot of valid, useful, and insightful discussion and commentary. I understand where SO are coming from in having such a rigid definition of "answerable", and it's their site and they can run it however they see fit. But I see no reason to maintain, in the broader sense, that a Q&A site can't adopt a different position, which recognizes that the value of many questions is not in finding one, and one one, unique, correct, and objectively verifiable answer, but is rather in the discussion itself. So I guess what I'm saying is... SO has it's place, but a similar site that uses a different model also has it's place. IOW, the SO model is not the one and only valid model for a technical Q&A site.
- mbesto 13y agoHonest question - do you genuinely believe someone (or a group of people) without 100% understanding of your project will be able to definitively tell you what language/framework is best for building your application? These types of subjects have been debated to death with the general conclusion ending up with "use the tool you are most comfortable with".
- andrewstuart 13y ago
- lubos 13y agoWhat's the point submitting project that hasn't launched? Not to mention there is http://programmers.stackexchange.com http://programmers.stackexchange.com which is exactly "a place for the discussions not allowed on Stack Overflow" so really, what's the point?
- ciex 13y agoTesting the waters, getting valuable feedback, starting a conversation. What's the point of working on such a project if nobody is interested?
- andrewstuart 13y agoSo true. I have launched many projects to the sound of chirping crickets. There's a great deal to be said for building the momentum in advance of opening the doors.
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> What's the point submitting project that hasn't launched? I agree; it would be nicer if they finished at least an MVP before launching. > Not to mention there is http://programmers.stackexchange.com http://programmers.stackexchange.com (...) AFAIR it also has some track record of killing interesting and valuable discussions, so actually I think this product is a great idea.
- lawl 13y agoIf it were we'd see "moved to programmers.stackexchange.com" instead of "closed as not constructive".
- eksith 13y ago> Not to mention there is http://programmers.stackexchange.com which is exactly "a place for the discussions not allowed on Stack Overflow" so really, what's the point? http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/201263/when-should-i-use-or-not-booleanutils-istrue-and-booleanutils-isfalse http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/201263/when-s... http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/202220/moving-to-sharepoint-development-from-java http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/202220/moving... http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/163004/what-is-the-opposite-of-initialize-or-init http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/163004/what-i... http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/49806/reasons-programmers-leave http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/49806/reasons... http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/2815/what-would-you-change-about-c-if-you-could http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/2815/what-wou...
- mbesto 13y ago> Not Constructive is the place for open, subjective, opinionated, extended discussion about software development. So...Quora?
- andrewstuart 13y agoQuora is much broader in its scope and also has usage restrictions that make it basically useless.
- Lapsa 13y agoIt's doing great at increasing smug.
- eksith 13y agoQuora is a walled garden (behind FB) which I sincerely hope this won't end up as.
- Lapsa 13y agoAnd you must be "at least 13 years old". Unchecked that bullshit just to see what would happen and I got a notice, that I won't be able to retry till tomorrow. Impressive.
- eksith 13y agoI'm curious about that checkbox. The whole reason for it, I'm guessing, is because of COPPA ( Children's Online Privacy Protection Act), but then that applies only when you collect a significant amount of personal information from someone 13 or younger and/or directing them to behave a certain way. Which leads the question, why would Quora need that much information about me in the first place? I don't recall getting an "I'm over 13" checkbox when I signed up for HN and we're ostensibly doing the same thing: Discussing.
- mediumdeviation 13y agoThe same is true for most sites, even Stack Exchange, because of COPPA as mentioned below. If you mention openly anywhere that you're below 13, moderators are obliged to delete your account (since they can't keep your personal information) > Subscriber certifies to Stack Exchange that Subscriber is an individual (i.e., not a corporate entity) at least 13 years of age. No one under the age of 13 may provide any personal information to or on Stack Exchange (including, for example, a name, address, telephone number or email address). - http://stackexchange.com/legal http://stackexchange.com/legal
- DanBC 13y agoThis is a great idea. I think. There's not much to go on from the minimal page. Please would you consider changing the font colour for the email registration box? The text was very pale, and so it was very low contrast. May I ask how moderation is going to be handled? Is there going to be some form of user voting? What will you do with obvious trolls? Some people like engaging with trolls, and that can be harmful to the site. How are you going to handle the 'hot button' topics that attract inflammatory responses?
- andrewstuart 13y agoWe're hoping people might choose to become moderators. We really don't want a nasty negative trollfest. The idea is not to allow open ended mud slinging matches. Rather to allow discussion about topics that aren't strict questions with one valid answer. Free flowing discussion about software technology and software development.
- jerrya 13y agoWhat can I say? Like many people, I believe, I find the questions that have been closed, usually as "Not Constructive" to be the most helpful. I don't understand Stack Overflow, but the weird negativity over there certainly keeps me from asking or answering questions there or at most of the stack exchange sites.
- eksith 13y agoWhen the vibe turns to over-moderation I.E. strict enforcement to the point human beings are forced to act as functions with predictable output, it's tedious, Not Constructive (ironically) and overall unpleasant to even browse let alone ask questions.
- ksrm 13y agoreddit's AskScience[1] also suffered this fate. [1] http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience
- FooBarWidget 13y agoWorse, when a moderator closes a topic, it stays closed, even when they're wrong. I recently asked a question, but moderators misunderstood my question so they closed it as offtopic. I explained my question in more detail, and it should have been apparently that it is clearly on-topic, but they didn't do anything about it.
- jerrya 13y agoIt's a very frustrating site. I take the time to carefully write up a question, and many things can happen to that. * it doesn't get answered * it gets closed pretty quickly (and usually in an offputting insulting manner) * it gets changed(!) and a question I didn't ask gets answered I suspect there's a lot of frustrated wikipedians taking it out on Stack Exchange.
- JeremyCa 13y agoI have had similar experiences. Generally speaking if I'm going to take the time to write a question on SO it's because I can not find the answer already, only to have that question not answered, or worse edited beyond the questions original intent.
- funnyshit101 13y agoGet ready for heavy traffic. I have a search filter on SO for thread with a handy amount of votes that have been closed, mods are crazy on that site.
- ronaldx 13y agoThe problem is that the ideal place to host these discussions is... Stack Overflow. Their policy on open questions is dead wrong.
- brazzy 13y agoNo, it's not. They have a clear purpose: they want the site to be useful. The definitive go-to site for programmers that have a question they need answered in a way that solves their problem. Lengthy discussions can be interesting, but they don't solve problems. They're not useful. Therefore, Stack Overflow is not the right place for them. Actually they even have a place for discussions: a chat feature that can be linked to from any question.
- Karunamon 13y ago>Lengthy discussions can be interesting, but they don't solve problems. The problem is that SE's criterion for a "lengthy discussion" is so moronically short that valuable and constructive questions are getting killed off. I echo the sentiment elsewhere in this thread that I have many a time had a question answered in a thread marked as "not constructive". It's downright wrong and insulting.
- jjindev 13y agoTheir philosophy is that some people are better suited to judge usefulness than others. They apparently believe that a one-developer, one-vote system would not judge such questions "correctly."
- ronaldx 13y ago> They apparently believe that a one-developer, one-vote system would not judge such questions "correctly." I find this dichotomy fascinating. They do a fair job of justifying that democratic voting doesn't generally identify useful questions, but then again the site's main feature is a one-person, one-vote system.
- rantanplan 13y ago
- willvarfar 13y agoJudging by the points by time by rank in the front page, I 'd say this has some flags. Which would be a shame, as that kind of censure is exactly what the site is against. Every time there is any criticism of SO here, however constructive, the flaggers come out in force :(
- richardwhiuk 13y agoI suspect the flags are more likely because the title implies that there will be a discussion site, as opposed to just a launch page.
- andrewstuart 13y agoCan you explain what "points by time by rank in the front page" means please?
- willvarfar 13y agoThis post right now has 130pts after 3 hours. And its way below 3 hour stories with 50pts on the front page.
- jjindev 13y agoWho among us has not googled a problem, found the top hit at Stack Overflow, got our solution, and noticed also that the question was closed as not-something? IMHO the whole thing can be handled by upvotes (as HN demonstrates, you don't even need downvotes)
- finnw 13y agoCan you give some examples? My experience has been slightly different. I have often found stackoverflow questions (closed as NC or NaRQ) from google searches and thought "This is interesting, but I would be embarrassed if my boss saw me reading it."
- lucb1e 13y agoI was thinking about building this just yesterdaynight! Coincidentally a community I used to really like is being flooded by noobs and trolls in the past few months, that was the actual trigger. I was thinking of creating a community that was more like a combination of Stackoverflow, Hackernews, and a few older members of that other community. Anyway, it's funny how often things I thought of appear right the next day. I'm sure it's just coincidence or some other illusion, but it happens pretty regularly.
- mgav 13y agoI do generally like Stack's focus because I know exactly what I'll find when I get there: super-smart and helpful users (even if I do sometimes have questions beyond its scope).
- andrewstuart 13y agoHey there, Andrew here, I'm the OP. I want to be clear that I have the greatest respect for Stack Overflow. I think there has been nothing ever that has increased programmer productivity more than Stack Overflow. (quoting wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet) Fred Brooks said that "there is no single development, in either technology or management technique, which by itself promises even one order of magnitude [tenfold] improvement within a decade in productivity, in reliability, in simplicity." But Stack Overflow hadn't been born at that time. No language, operating system or compiler could ever have more impact on developer productivity than an effective global Q&A site for programmers - that's what Stack Overflow is and it is damn fine. It's just that Stack Overflow would be diluted and weakened by allowing open ended discussion on software technology and development. People go to SO with questions for which they want a specific answer. Not Constructive is intended to facilitate the valuable discussions about software that don't fit into that strict Q&A format. Not Constructive is for broader questions, and welcomes subjective opinion. It's not in conflict with SO, it's a complement to SO. Please do sign up at http://signup.notconstructive.com http://signup.notconstructive.com if you're interested in hearing when we launch.
- laurent123456 13y agoIt seems it's directly related to Stack Overflow but I wonder how both will be "connected"? Are you going to go to closed questions on SO and post a link to your website? Directly contacting authors of closed questions might also prove difficult since many users don't display their email address. Overall, I don't quite understand how it's going to work out. If there's no connection to SO (beside the questions being imported from there) then it's like any other forum.
- antonwinter 13y agoif nc gets enough traction, the SO moderators may be able to provide an nc link when they close questions.
- andrewstuart 13y agoThere will be no direct connection with SO. Not Constructive is just a place to come to ask open ended questions about software development, where opinions and subjective answers are considered relevant and valid. We won't be importing questions from SO.
- hermanschaaf 13y agoNo one here has mentioned Slant? I think it solves a similar problem quite well http://www.slant.co/ http://www.slant.co/
- bijanv 13y agoI was about to post the same thing. I think Slant is exactly the platform we're talking about here and it's already good to go!
- bjourne 13y ago+1! Slant.co works great because many "not constructive" questions are on the format "which alternative among $x is best for $y?" However, the site seem to be lacking in polish. For example, it doesn't remember your login and the procedure for updating and commenting on viewpoints is convoluted. Plus, there is no timestamps anywhere so it's hard to see what is going on on the site. Stackoverflow is much better from a usability perspective.
- neya 13y agoI don't know who you are. But if you are the creator of this site, you have my respect from the bottom of my heart. Stackoverflow was wonderful when it was started the way it was. The moderated content was extremely useful. But later, they decided to screw everything up by doing some stupid things like assigning too much power to moderators. I always used to assume SO was more like the real world democracy; if something isn't right, you could fix it yourself being an ordinary citizen. However, on SO, that's not the case anymore. There is a moderator on top of the users who decides what's right and what's wrong. And he goes into a 'rage mode ON' by flagging genuinely useful questions as 'inappropriate' or 'not suitable for SO', as he pleases. How can you challenge his decision? God knows. I've searched round the site to report moderators. Good luck with reporting some rogue moderator. I like the fact that you can flag something offensive easily, but I don't like the fact that it's not as easy for the reverse. Forget the moderators. Let's say you want to ask something about security with sessions in PHP. Good luck finding answers on SO. Your question will be migrated to some weird subdomain.stakcoverflow.com for which you need a separate account to maintain and collect your badges from scratch, again. That's why I knew there would be a day when someone would start something like this. Nonconstructive nails it for me. And hopefully for other disappointed SO fans too. Thanks for creating this.
- maaaats 13y agoIf you don't like that a question was closed, flag to reopen (if you have over 2k rep I believe). If you don't understand why a questions was closed or feel a moderator is abusing powers, create a post on Meta and it will be dealt with. Then the voice of the users will overrule the moderator decision. Not that complicated, really.. I can't say I recognize the situations pictured in your rant.
- albertzeyer 13y agoHave you tried to do this? Reopening usually never happens. Discussions in the comment section is totally useless and wasted time. Discussions on Meta also just repeat that your question is not for SO.
- 13y ago
- tome 13y agoI recently submitted a question to unix.stackexchange, and the next day (after it had been answered) a moderator came along and "improved" the layout of my question. Objectively the result was no worse than my original, and perhaps it was indeed better, but I can't help feeling like my private space was violated by that.
- mgav 13y agoTome, I've had the same thing happen, but I chalk it up to simply the way the site works, which I knew upfront. Occasionally, however, the "help" in refining my question isn't that helpful...
- maaaats 13y agoYour questions and answers aren't really "yours" on SE. That's the way it works. A bit unusual, but nothing wrong per se. Like Wikipedia, but that you still get credit for what you started.
- sysop073 13y agoI see this complaint an awful lot considering Stack Exchange literally tells you to go somewhere else if you feel that way: http://unix.stackexchange.com/help/editing http://unix.stackexchange.com/help/editing
- mgav 13y agoAnother option is BOTHSIDER.COM (http://bothsider.com http://bothsider.com). Tweet-sized opinions on both sides of any issue, including "not constructive" Stack issues. We are up and running right now! Disclosure: I'm a Bothsider Founder/CEO
- edtechdev 13y agoGreat idea. Imagine seeing this on HackerNews posts, or reddit, etc., even popular posts that got plenty of upvotes and had substantial discussions going on: "As it currently stands, this question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, visit the help center for guidance. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question."
- peteri 13y agoGood about time. The number of times where I have a what technologies should I use do thing X kind of question and there isn't anywhere good to ask. Might be worth looking at OSQA as platform.
- wodow 13y agoBackground from 2011: "Why does Stack Overflow sometimes seem so eager to close “off-topic” that happen to be VERY relevant to the programming community?" http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/188405/why-does-stack-overflow-sometimes-seem-so-eager-to-close-off-topic-that-happen http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/188405/why-does-stac...
- j7mbo 13y agoIt's funny, "Not Constructive" doesn't exist any more as a reason for closing.
- mataug 13y agoI assumed this was what quora was for. But let's see how this matches up? If this just a clone then probably its going to have a hard time.
- ionforce 13y agoQuora is bad at/does not specialize in answers involving code/math.
- jusben1369 13y agoSmall nitpick but you don't need the coma after "trolling" and you have the conjunctive "or" after that.
- lnanek2 13y agoLink is just a crappy sign up page, but I agree with the vast majority of comments here that some really great questions that would have been useful to me have been closed. So good to see some competition coming up! As an experienced Android developer, for example, most of the questions I see that aren't closed are simple things answered by the docs. The things I see that are closed are things I actually myself have trouble with, like which monetization solution to go with.
- smegel 13y agoThankyou. I detest stack exchange sites with a peculiar passion (I'm usually pretty relaxed about most things). Seeing incredibly useful and important questions closed for this very reason, and others mutilated by "gods" who have the right to alter questions as they see fit fills me with rage. I only end up on SO as a result of a google search, and I haven't bothered contributing for years. Even worse is superuser ~ a couple of down voted questions and comments and you get banned for life, with no recourse. I don't know what kind of Nazis run that shop. My 2c * avoid badges/karma/superpowers. It just creates an ego cult that is responsible for much of the problem. Wikipedia has this problem with elitist editors who think consensus amongst themselves trumps wikipedia's own rules. * Have a system of encouragement to improve poorly worded or duplicate questions. But any changes/closes/holds must be approved by the question owner. * Maybe think of a different name for the launch site. I'm not sure its possible to "reclaim" a word with so many bad memories attached.
- recursive 13y agoStack Overflow blog entry on why they stopped using "Not Constructive" http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2013/06/the-war-of-the-closes/ http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2013/06/the-war-of-the-closes/
- smegel 13y agoOh dear good watching all the pro SO shills leap out in defence of their kingdom is making my eyes bleed. Please, please go back home.
- joeframbach 13y agoMight as well 301 to news.ycombinator.com
- emddudley 13y agoITT: wah, wah, StackOverflow doesn't work the way I want it to. I'm right and the mods are wrong. If you don't like StackOverflow, go somewhere else. SO is successful because it has rules and boundaries. "Everything goes" just does not work well in online communities.
- eksith 13y agoIsn't this is project an effort to make that somewhere else.
- emddudley 13y agoSure is, but there's not a whole lot you can say about a sign up page. Let me know once the project has launched... then we can have a discussion on how this site actually works (or doesn't, as the case may be). My bet is that the site won't form a community and take off unless they put in some rules and boundaries. Then the complaining will start, and we'll come full circle.
- krmmalik 13y agoWell I signed up immediately. In the last 4 weeks alone, every single one of my posts on any of the stackexchange sites have been marked as "not helpful" , "not constructive" etc. I ask a simple question regards a web app, and i thought it was a genuine and innocent enough question and it got closed. The watchman culture is a little too rampant now. I'm glad this service exists and to learn that i'm not the only person affected by it. Looking forward to the final product.
- murftown 13y agoI have experienced that many of the questions I am most interested in are closed as "Not Constructive", seemingly to fulfill some artistic vision of the moderators and how they would like to "architect" the community. Very frustrating. I also had a situation where I found a bug in some Python code on an accepted SO answer, submitted an edit, and had my fix repeatedly rejected by moderators. I tracked down one of the moderators' email and asked him about it, found out that he does not know Python and that he rejected my edit because it was already an accepted answer so why should I edit it? ...? In the end, after I persuaded him that my fix was helpful by getting other developers to testify that the existing code was broken and the fix fixed it...he posted my edit as his own and took credit for it.
- _random_ 13y ago...or you could've started a new community here: http://area51.stackexchange.com http://area51.stackexchange.com. - wouldn't waste our time looking at yet another sign-up dummy page.