13 ms·
Hyperloop: riding sound’s density peak to exploit the drag equation?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- phoboslab 13y agoI'm all the opposite. It's amazing how many different solutions where proposed since the Elon Musk teased the Hyperloop. If nothing else, the Hyperloop sparked imagination everywhere. Even if most proposed solutions are impractical, the very fact that they are out there now, for others to see, think about and tinker with, is a big win.
- pwnna 13y agocan we get a page aggregating all the potential ideas?
- whiddershins 13y agothat's a really clever theory. I can't wait to find out if it is true.
- cma 13y agoTweet it at Elon =) but yeah.. I'm just waiting on the flaw haha
- jlebrech 13y agowhat if it's not in a vacuum, and it's magnetic rings with a cylinder going through the rings.
- throwmeaway33 13y agoI remember doing the math in my undergraduate physics studies. Air molecules actually do not move very far when a vibration (ie. sounds) goes through them. Amazingly, high frequency sounds move air back and forth only a few angstroms. I can't find a link describing the calculation. This link talks about how the change in pressure is equivalent to "140 molecules for every million molecules" http://www.silcom.com/~aludwig/musicand.htm http://www.silcom.com/~aludwig/musicand.htm So there is no way you are going to create a bubble of vacuum!
- cma 13y agoNot trying to create a bubble of vacuum (though that was my old idea =).. then I realized what you lost gained by low density you paid for in high velocity). Also, the idea here isn't involving high frequency sound.
- geon 13y agoThe article talks about low frequency and high amplitude. The sound waves near a subwoofer definitely moves the air more than a few ångström... And you don't want low pressure, but high, so the air speed is low. Drag is proportional to the density, but proportional to the square of the speed.
- hotpockets 13y agoIn the long wavelength regime, frequency is proportional to 1/wavelength. In fact, frequency=speed/wavelength.
- beambot 13y agoI still believe the top contender is Jacques Mattheij's proposal of a pressurized tunnel: http://jacquesmattheij.com/elon-musk-and-the-hyperloop http://jacquesmattheij.com/elon-musk-and-the-hyperloop
- bencollier49 13y agoDidn't EM say it wasn't pressurised? Could be misdirection, mind.
- rorrr2 13y agoThat doesn't address all the nightmarish issues of traveling at 600-700 MPH through pressurized air. Riding the pressure peak at exactly the speed of sound makes a lot more sense.
- beambot 13y agoNot travelling through pressurized air.... travelling with the pressurized air. The idea behind the article I linked is that the entire system moves as a cohesive mass -- air, vehicles, and all.
- bjornsing 13y agoSeriously? Compared to that design evacuating the tunnel would make a lot of sense, as would going a lot slower than the speed of sound. Now when Elon says it's not an evacuated tunnel, and also (indirectly) that you'll be traveling more or less exactly at the speed of sound, I'm leaning quite heavily towards the OP.
- worldsayshi 13y agoWill not constantly travel at the speed of sound maintain a continuous sound bang that would break every window passed by the train?
- geon 13y agoThe design still requires a tunnel. It's not an open air track like a railroad.
- worldsayshi 13y agoAh, I realized this shortly after posting.
- jlgreco 13y agoIn case this is unclear to anyone; all transonic, supersonic, or hypersonic flight/movement causes a 'continuous' sonic boom. A Bell X-1 at Mach 1.06 causes a continuous sonic boom along it's path, as does a Mach 2 Concorde and a Mach 2.6 Browning 50 cal machine gun bullet. "Sonic booms" are not discrete events that occur when you cross the 'sound barrier' or continuous when you stay at it. They are continuous at it and past it, not stopping until your velocity drops down below it again. GIF that does a good job of explaining this: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e4/Dopplereffectsourcemovingrightatmach1.4.gif http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e4/Doppleref... That leading edge where all the circles are kind of meeting up? That is where the sonic boom is. It continuously sweeps across the landscape behind the source, as long as the source is moving faster than the speed of sound.
- worldsayshi 13y agoBut I take it that the magnitude of the boom will get less severe the faster you go beyond the speed of sound?
- randallsquared 13y agoMore severe, I'd expect, since you're compressing the air more as you travel faster.
- geon 13y agoI wonder i Elon really has a plan, or if he is just kickstarting everyones speculations to come up with an actual viable design.
- jlgreco 13y agoTo be honest that is what my money was originally on.. that or this just being some sort of self-constructed mythology for himself, sort of like free wirelessly transmitted power was for Tesla perhaps (though more 'intentionally' and less 'mistakenly/delusionally'). As time goes on he keeps getting more and more specific with his deadline for going public though. First it was "eventually", then it was "sometime after Tesla is profitable", then it was "sometime later this year", now we've actually got a date to look forward to. I now think that he actually is thinking of something.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoOr even if he does have a design planned, he might consider "creating other usable designs" as a deliberate side effect of stirring up speculation. He seems to be motivated by saving the world in general more than personally making a lot of money.
- smoyer 13y agoThe guy launches rockets and builds electric sports cars ... I tend to think he has a plan. Allowing the speculation to persist might improve that plan but I suspect it was viable on it's own (and perhaps the waiting period was simply to allow some small scale testing to occur).
- riledhel 13y agoI like the way he approaches problems and I think he has some plan to turn most of his ventures in some sort of vertical market.
- Lambdanaut 13y agoI had that thought too, but I do think he has a plan. I don't think he'd risk so much of his reputation by pulling a stunt like that.
- antninja 13y agoSomeone should build a prototype of such a tube and see if it's efficient. The mystery around Hyperloop generates a lot of ideas that should be tested. Railroad infrastructures are ageing, maybe some tuberoads can replace them.
- ddeck 13y agoAll this speculation reminds me of the hype surrounding the Segway launch. I recall it being being touted as a game-changer, a revolution in transportation that would change the way cities were built... [The Segway] will be to the car what the car was to the horse and buggy (Dean Kamen)[1] John Doerr, predicted Segway would rack up $1 billion in sales faster than any company in history [1] Let's hope the Hyperloop fares better. [1] http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/11.03/segway.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/11.03/segway.html
- Kurtz79 13y agoThe Segway hype was so generic it could have been anything: it didn't offer any concrete metric to justify it. A system allowing to travel LA to SF in 30 minutes, without the hassle involved with air travel, WOULD be revolutionary, regardless of how good or bad is the marketing department of its company.
- jessriedel 13y agoIf you believe Paul Graham (which in this case I do), the thing that killed the Segway was that you looked like a smug jerk on one. http://www.paulgraham.com/segway.html http://www.paulgraham.com/segway.html No one predicted this would be the problem, and indeed most people still haven't come to Graham's conclusion. In that sense, concrete metrics are irrelevant. The hyperloop is just as likely a priori to have some sort of similar fatal flaw. This is the problem with getting too excited about any new particular device; there's too much that can go wrong between zero and revolutionary.
- panacea 13y agoI truly think Google's Glass will suffer a similar fate... at least in it's present incarnation.
- ddeck 13y agoFunny you should mention glass. Doerr's firm is backing it too through the Glass Collective. Doerr has been equally bullish about Google Glass. Still, Glass is fast developing a stigma, and it’s not even on the market yet: It’s been called a “Segway for your face.” [1] [1] http://pandodaily.com/2013/05/23/john-doerr-doesnt-think-google-glass-is-like-the-segway/ http://pandodaily.com/2013/05/23/john-doerr-doesnt-think-goo...
- berntb 13y agoIf this works, I wonder about the logic of making it a SF-LA thing? At least, there should be another use case. Why not go from Silicon Valley to a mountain area where you've bought a large area of land, ready to build on? You could get investments from all over the tech industry, since it would lower living costs (and increase the maximum number) of the people that Silicon Valley can have (less infrastructure and living area "load"). Use the sales slogan "let's supersize the Silicon Valley!" for this new commuting solution.
- JPKab 13y agoHere's a crazy thought: Let's get outside the West Coast bubble here and think about this in a vastly more practical manner when it comes to population density and distance between urban cores. Every time I hear this project spoken of, I have to hear people who live in the Bay Area talking about "SF to LA in half an hour" I think what would be much more sensible would be "NY to Boston in 15 minutes" and then extending it to Philadelphia and DC. Where would the line go after it hit SF? Portland and Seattle? Denver? The populations of these places don't support the cost of the infrastructure. The east coast makes much more sense for this project.
- el_zorro 13y agoThis makes much more sense. Perhaps I am biased from my East Coast viewpoint, but these things have to be built for everyone, not just tech enthusiasts. The East Coast has many more destinations that could benefit from this. For me right now, it's an hour to Boston and five to NYC. Philadelphia is maybe seven, DC a little more. If the hyperloop performs as Musk says it will, it would be 40 minutes from Boston to DC - commuting distance. That would completely revolutionize this side of the country. I could work in NYC but enjoy all the comfort of New England.
- berntb 13y ago>>I could work in NYC but enjoy all the comfort of New England. The station cost will probably be high; it will be hard to have "side tracks". (No fan-out, you could say.) So if there is a station in e.g. NY/LA, the housing costs for the other end station(s) ought to rapidly close with the big-city end station. It is just a way of opening a larger area for commuting. So, there won't be that much comforts of New England. My point was that with a HL the areas with high people pressure could continue to grow (I selected Silicon Valley because HN is a California-centric place, for good and bad. I'm in Europe.)
- jjindev 13y agoI once sailed upwind from LA to SF over 5 days. I flew home in an hour. The flight gave me a long(!?) time to ponder the nature of time and transport. In that context, I don't really see a transformational improvement going from one 1 hour to 0.5 hours.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoSorry, let me clarify your statement: You spent 4 hours in the airport (or getting there, parking, getting sodomized by security) and 1 hour flying. Then another 30-60 minutes disembarking. So you spent around 6 hours in transit from SF to LA. 6 hours compared to 30 minutes (or more likely, 1.5 hours including the necessary boarding / unboarding) is a VAST difference.
- jjindev 13y agoWhy do you presume less "lobby time"? I'd think a train twice as fast as a plane would inspire at least as much security theater.
- DanBC 13y agoYou should try a cruise ship sometime. It's amazing how easy it is to get in and out of different countries. Even getting on the ship is pretty easy. I don't think there'll be much security theatre until a train gets blown up - most of the theatre so far seems to be reactive. "An idiot has explosives in his shoes. He is so incompetent that he tries to light it with a match" and now everyone has to take their shoes off.
- duaneb 13y agoA train doesn't typically have explosive fuel, which renders it a pretty poor weapon.
- ajuc 13y agoDon't underestimate kinetic energy of a train going 340 meters per second.
- Qantourisc 13y agoSound: a vacuum and a high pressure alternating ... Using wind would be far cheaper and better I think :-) I mean really really low sound frequencies are the same anyway. (As far as my physics go)
- w_t_payne 13y agoPresumably the pressure wave is maintained by a continuous array of big-ass subwoofers along the whole length of the tube - If this is the case, then keeping the noise pollution down will be a bit of a challenge - unless some sort of active-noise cancellation technology is used for the outside. Hmmm... This should not be too tricky, since you are generating the original signal yourself, but if one of the exterior noise-cancellation speakers breaks down - it's gonna be LOUD.
- benjamincburns 13y agoAn array of pulse jets! That's not very solar friendly, but it is very loud!
- hotpockets 13y agoPerhaps the frequencies are below the audible spectrum?
- redwood 13y agoThe whole idea of a wave guide is to trap the energy of the wave inside, so presumably a lot of it would not escape.
- joshontheweb 13y agoWouldn't these sound waves be below the human hearing threshold (20hz)?
- benjamincburns 13y agoI'm confused by this... If the air molecules are staying roughly still, but the density of the air surrounding the vehicle rises by a factor of n, isn't the vehicle colliding with n times as many particles as it would have otherwise? How is this more efficient? Is the velocity in the drag equation relative to the vehicle, or to a stationary frame of reference? Edit: Or is the point that the velocity of the air particles within the density peak is at its maximal forward-traveling rate before they start to loop back around and form their ellipse?
- icegreentea 13y agoThe velocity in the drag equation is relative to the vehicle.
- opminion 13y agoI can only hope that the Mythbusters are on this already.
- stcredzero 13y agoNot that I don't like the Mythbusters (I do like them) but the math and physics are already beyond them.
- gpsarakis 13y agoJust some info: Transonic/supersonic and near-speed-of-sound aerodynamics differ from traditional low velocity aerodynamics (I think the threshold is approximately 0.25Vs, so up to 1/4 of the speed of sound, I am a bit rusty on that). After that point you can't ignore compressibility phenomena, meaning that the density is no longer a constant, but also becomes a variable. You may be able to reduce drag by going very high in the atmosphere where the air is very thin (10^-6). Speed of sound also is an equation of the density and the temperature.
- jasallen 13y agoRelative to the frame of reference, it seems to me the sparse particles would be travelling closer to the speed of the craft than the dense particles. The "density front" travels at exactly the speed of sound, but it consists of nearly static particles (not static from the frame of reference, from the frame of reference they are moving backward at nearly the speed of sound), these static particles are the relevant V. The sparse particles just in front of the dense ones are accelerating to get more sparse. From the perspective of the reference frame, they are therefore moving 'backward' at slightly less than the speed of sound, making there relative velocity closer to that of the reference frame. So lower density and lower velocity. and that doesn't even account for additional compression which I don't even know enough to do armchair reasoning on. So, I'm the farthest thing from an expert, but this is why it doesn't seem to make sense to me.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- redwood 13y agoActually you just explained his idea, no? The difference between the dense particles just behind the craft with maximal drag and sparse particles just in front, means a pressure differential pushing the vehicle forward
- cma 13y agoStare at this thing for a while: http://www.acs.psu.edu/drussell/Demos/waves/Lwave-v8.gif http://www.acs.psu.edu/drussell/Demos/waves/Lwave-v8.gif In all seriousness though I'm going through your post to see if you've found a gaping problem =). I don't think there can be different density velocity ratios at any point of displacement in the wave's reference frame because the same net number of particles has to pass through each point or you start making a permanent buildup on one side or the other of that point, which you can't do because in the reference frame of the still air that point is moving at the speed of sound. A moving point passes by the same number of unique particles at the speed of sound as it would if it were going the speed of turtle (if you ignore thermal dispersion).
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agopictures of Machu Pichu are mostly irrelevant to the article. And cliched.
- PaulHoule 13y agowouldn't it be awfully loud? traffic noise is bad enough in California as it is. Would it be loud inside?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- acd 13y agoCan the hyperloop be combined with quantum levitation? To provide very low friction high speed travel? http://www.ted.com/talks/boaz_almog_levitates_a_superconductor.html http://www.ted.com/talks/boaz_almog_levitates_a_superconduct...
- Taek 13y agoI think the problem with that idea is you have to keep the superconductor very cold, which might be too expensive for large objects that need to levitate for 30 minutes.
- Taek 13y agoWhat I remember from physics class makes me think this isn't viable. If you have sound moving through the tube, you have energy pushing the sound. Either you have to keep the whole tube 'humming' or you have to send people off in a blast wave. With the humming idea, you might be able to create vacuums that travel around the tube at the speed of sound (sound works by changing the density of air, oscillating from high pressure to low pressure), and then you can move vehicles around the tube at the speed of sound with very little drag. So then you need some way to keep the vehicles floating, and you need to get them to the speed of sound in the first place (rail gun?). I'm going to pretend that we have a cheap way to do both of those things. So, how expensive would it be to keep 100s of miles of hyperloop humming with a sound powerful enough to create vacuums large enough to fit transportation units in? Even if you are only using cars large enough to hold 1 person and a suitcase, you are going to need a lot of energy powering the sound waves throughout the tube. You might be able to do some acoustics-like engineering to keep the sound loud at little energy cost, but I don't think that solar power above the tunnel is going to be enough. Using this model, Musk would need a handful of technological advances up his sleeve. So I think the big 'secret' that makes a hyperloop viable is not this one. Then again, with the Tesla and his space adventures, he has had to deal with at least a handful of difficult obstacles. So maybe he is expecting to develop multiple technologies to make this viable.
- cma 13y agoThe point of this approach was not to keep the whole tube humming (that would have almost as much friction loss as just circulating all the air in the whole loop), but rather just send waves in small bundles. If you read my post it has nothing to do with vacuums and instead somewhat counter-intuitively keeps the vehicle within the densest part of the sound wave the entire time.
- Aaronneyer 13y agoI'm starting to think Elon has absolutely nothing planned, and just wanted to see what everyone thought he was doing, to help bring about all these awesome ideas for high speed travel :)
- shoyer 13y agoThe author appears to have confused group velocity (the speed of the wave) with particle velocity (the speed of the air molecules). This is a very basic notion of how waves work -- the waves move, not the medium. In this case, the wave (and the vehicle) would be moving at the speed of sound, but the air particles they hit wouldn't. They're basically still stationary. There is no magical force to bring them up to the speed of sound before they hit the vehicle. Hence, the drag is not reduced. I'm a physicist, but by no means an expert on sound. There are more details on how sound actually works on this page: http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/waves/soundwav.htm http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/waves/soundwav.htm. A relevant quote: "v [the particle velocity] is much less than the phase [wave] velocity of sound" (note: phase and group velocity are equal for sound in air). Edit: This criticism is not right; see below.
- cma 13y agoYou read it wrong; at no point were any particles in the wave assumed to be going the speed of sound; that's why when you look from the vehicles reference you see a standing wave but at every point on it particles are still flowing towards the vehicle. The picture says it is in a sound-speed reference frame, but it probably confused you if you didn't read that. At no point is the air doing anything but apply drag to the vehicle's movement; there is just a sweet spot to minimize drag, but it isn't minimized to zero. Read through this thread a bit and you'll see me talking about the exact same difference of propagation of a disturbance vs displacement/velocity of individual particles...
- shoyer 13y agoOK, after looking at the diagram and re-reading the article you are right -- you did not in fact mix up group and particle velocity
- cma 13y agoIt is probably my fault cause I sort of wrote the post as I worked out the concept and that ended up muddying a lot of the writing. And I'm not a physicist so I'm sure I didn't quite state everything in a very traditional way...
- rfugger 13y agoSo the vehicle basically surfs a sound wave?
- nmeofthestate 13y agoThis seems like nonsense to me - any sound waves will be massively disrupted by the bloody great vehicle ploughing through the air, no?
- shoyer 13y agoThis is an intriguing proposal, but one that I think it ultimately flawed. Once a wave is strong enough for there be to appreciable density differences (NOT the usual case for sound waves), the usual wave equation for sound does not apply [1]. In the case of such "Very Strong Sound Waves", you have a non-linear wave equation and thus the shape of your wave is no longer fixed as it moves. Eventually, you end up with shock wave, where the front of your wave is a discontinuity. Why is this problematic? Well, once you have a shock wave (e.g., a wave crashing on the beach), the physics gets a lot more complicated. You are basically riding an explosion in a tube. At this point, it no longer safe to me to neglect factors like dissipation. Your shock wave is going to heat up the air and eventually fizzle out. If you want to keep it going, you'll need to be continually supplying tremendous amounts of energy at exactly the right time along your tube. You'll also have to be continually cooling or cycling the air to relieve the waste energy. To me, it seems a lot simpler and more reliable (not to mention safer) to simply evacuate your tube, which, I believe, is the original hyperloop idea. [1] http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/waves/soundwav.htm#H http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/waves/soundwav.htm#H
- cma 13y agoThat's a great link.. should help see how far this could be practically taken. When the wave is very strong the heat generated by compression isn't dissipated adiabatically the wave starts losing energy to waste heat; if you increase the wavelength you again move back to the adiabatic regime. How far can you take it? I don't know, I'd like to see some numbers and that's probably what I'd work on next if I keep looking into this.. probably won't until after Elon's announcement. For extreme cases of high-amplitude waves where the particle velocity itself is getting close to the speed of sound, I definitely don't know what all happens, but somewhere in the write-up or comments here I at least had going that far as a bound on how far you could push things before you didn't really even have sound waves anymore.
- aidenn0 13y ago"To me, it seems a lot simpler and more reliable (not to mention safer) to simply evacuate your tube, which, I believe, is the original hyperloop idea." Musk has said on the record that it's not an evacuated tube.
- marshray 13y agoI think the best you could do would be to stay near the trailing end of the pressure wave. This would be where the air was moving (slightly) in the same direction as your travel. You would also travel through the lowest density. But I suspect you'd always be better off by simply evacuating the tube as much as possible. Or possibly there is a medium other than air being considered, one in which the speed of sound was much lower at a given density. Perhaps interesting things could happen if the working fluid was a refrigerant and the sound wave was intense enough to induce a phase change cycle.
- gaze 13y agoCool. So how do I accelerate into this "bubble"