5 ms·
I have a personal experience with the harm that ubiquitous recording of location data can bring, even when you don't do anything wrong. When I was in college,
by cortesoft 13y ago
I have a personal experience with the harm that ubiquitous recording of location data can bring, even when you don't do anything wrong.
When I was in college, I was called to the police station and accused of breaking a glass door in the dorms. I knew NOTHING about this. I told the police I knew nothing about the event, but they continued to press me. They asked me details about where I was that night (many weeks prior), and I had difficulty remembering where I had been. To make matters worse, I originally thought the day in question was another day, so I ended up giving information about my location that was incorrect. If the police decided they didn't like me, they could have easily pressed charges for lying, even though I thought I was telling the truth. Luckily, they eventually believed me and I was let go.
How is this related to license plate readers? Well, the only reason they suspected I was the person who broke the door was because my ID card had been swiped at around the same time the door was broken. Simply because I was present near the time and location of a crime committed weeks prior, I was accused of a crime and nearly accidentally perjured myself. (Don't worry; I know now to never talk to the police!)
If we start tracking everyone's movements, this sort of thing will happen more and more often. You will EVENTUALLY have driven by a place where a crime was committed. You may be called to account for your being nearby, even weeks or months later. When the police ask you why you were there, will you remember? Will your answers satisfy them? Will your general unease at being questioned make you appear suspicious? Will you fumble, and say things that contradict yourself, making you appear even more suspicious?
- Daishiman 13y agoAt the point when they started asking about stuff you didn't know about I would have invoked my right to a lawyer.
- cortesoft 13y agoYes... as I said, I know much better now. Of course, invoking my right to a lawyer may have prolonged my experience. Whether the increased risk of being in trouble by talking was greater than the increased time to resolve the incident if I requested a lawyer would have been a tough call to make.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoNot to mention the whole "oh, you're asking for a lawyer, an innocent person would just talk to us, you must be our guy" bit.
- quantumpotato_ 13y agoWhich doesn't go so well in court. Oh wait.. forceful decryption of private keys..
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWell, supposedly TrueCrypt has plausible deniability, but I don't know if that's ever actually been tested in practice.
- cortesoft 13y agoIt would be impossible to know if it has ever been utilized in practice.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWell, technically, yes. However, if we had a court case where the prosecutor thought the defendant had a key for some encrypted data, and they claimed that they didn't, and they weren't thrown in jail for "refusing to divulge a key to the data that we totally know they have", then I might call that a theoretical win for the plausible deniability "defense".
- cortesoft 13y agoThe way the truecrypt hidden volume works, the defendant WOULD give up the key (it would just be the key for the REGULAR encrypted volume, not the hidden one) The prosecution would get the key, use it to decrypt the drive, see a bunch of files, and assume the defendant had complied and given them the correct key. What they wouldn't know is that there is also a SECOND encrypted volume inside the one they decrypted. There is actually no way for them to know if there is this second volume or not. http://www.truecrypt.org/docs/hidden-volume http://www.truecrypt.org/docs/hidden-volume If there were any news reports on it, the reports would just say "Defendant X gives up encryption key; no incriminating data found"
- uptown 13y ago...which now means you need to spend money to protect yourself against a situation where you've done nothing wrong.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoA lawyer might be provided pro bono -- but I completely agree with the point you're trying to make.
- wavefunction 13y agoPublic defenders are overworked and often unable to mount a sufficient defense.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoOh, I'm well aware.
- coldtea 13y agoPlus is some cases (and countries) they treat you worse, and take advantage of loop holes to delay you seeing a lawyer as much as they can, even like several days or so.
- dredmorbius 13y agoInvoking your right to remain silent is sufficient. Telling the police to direct further inquiries to an attorney doesn't actually necessitate retaining one until they make additional inquiries. One way to view this is upping the ante. You've made clear that you know your rights, and that they're not going to be able to use you as an easy source. Of course, if they call your bluff, it's helpful to be able to produce said attorney.
- victorf 13y agoI had a similar thing happen, I was the last person on security footage before someone discovered vandalism. You wouldn't have been guilty of perjury, maybe obstruction of justice. But I think your overall point is good, they will use data against you even though you were innocent and answering questions with good intentions.
- codex 13y agoThe same issue already exists in more limited form with fingerprints. Often random prints are found near the scene of a crime. That's not proof, however--just cause for questioning. If the police didn't question potential suspects they wouldn't be very good at their job, but I'm sorry it freaked you out.
- chrischen 13y agoErr... actually, what happened to you happened because of faulty and inadequate surveillance. Had they had cameras in the places watching 24/7, they would have seen you DIDN'T do it. It was only because they didn't have surveillance that they had to rely on partial data. If you think about it, had surveillance been even less, and they relied on a random witness who said they saw a guy in a hoodie, and you happen to own a hoodie, you could actually be vindicated by better surveillance. In other words, the truly innocent will always benefit more from such a system than those who are actually guilty. But this assumes the use of surveillance is benevolent. Your example is not actually a good example of why surveillance is bad. It is in fact an example of how it can help. Where surveillance might be bad is in the potential for abuse. It can cause misunderstandings, but even better surveillance resolves that.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoI have a personal rule that I am forming, where if the approach to improve something, is to use that something in greater quantities, it is probably a bad thing. e.g. brute force, vendor specific stack, XML, C++, classes, templates, advertising and surveillance. Have you ever had the misfortune of watching reality TV? You do realise the power of selective editing. Sufficiently motivated camera operators can 'destroy evidence' with no paper trail. So no, I really don't think more surveillance would necessarily give a better result. Who would be so crooked as to do such a thing? Faculty to get insurance claim/avoid insurance claim, overloaded cop who just wants to get to 'done' or a promotion.
- davidw 13y agoFrom http://nokogiri.org/ http://nokogiri.org/ : "XML is like violence - if it doesn’t solve your problems, you are not using enough of it."
- chrischen 13y agoI'm not saying more surveillance == better. I'm saying more surveillance would resolve that guy's specific problem, therefore his example is false.