2 ms·
"which could counteract many of the negative trends we face today (obesity, lack of social community, etc.)" I had an odd serious of thoughts about your inclus
by jimbokun 18y ago
"which could counteract many of the negative trends we face today (obesity, lack of social community, etc.)"
I had an odd serious of thoughts about your inclusion of "obesity." First, I thought of how you must be alluding to the fact that without cars, people will walk more and burn more calories. Then I thought of the study showing that almost all of the increase in obesity can be attributed to Americans eating more food over the past decades, not to exercising less.
Then I wondered about how being able to throw all of your groceries in the trunk and drive them home could lead to eating more than having to carry all your food from the neighborhood store to your house.
Which is interesting, but I still managed to gain weight in Brooklyn from knowing where all the best bakeries were (I got to the point of picking different bakeries for different kinds of cookies and pastries), despite not owning a car. :)
- dkarl 18y agoI'll give you three more reasons why going carless will help people lose weight. 1. For people who are overweight, the huffing and puffing (and in summer, the heat and sweat) would kill their appetite for a while. Plus, nobody wants to eat a heavy meal if they immediately have to walk five minutes to the metro station, possibly spend fifteen minutes standing up at the station and on the train, and then walk ten minutes home. 2. For people who are overweight, the extra effort and side effects would be a constant reminder that they're fat. Nobody wants to hold up their friends on the street or be sweaty and gross on a day when nobody else is. It's easy to eat when you can avoid thinking about the downsides, but if you're still embarrassed by pausing on the stairs at the metro station that morning and stinking up the office when you arrived, you'll have a fresh reminder of why you should pass up the free donuts in the break room. 3. Psychology. I've lost a lot of weight "through exercise" because I overeat less when I exercise. Many people who exercise regularly find that they feel miserable, and eat more, when they stop exercising for some reason (injury, time, whatever.) I feel kind of like an exercise addict -- I know I'll feel down and gain weight if I don't do it. I suspect this exercise addiction is inborn in a lot of people, not created by exposure (like addiction to crack, for example) and is therefore more of a basic human need than an addiction. Adding twenty minutes of walking to everybody's day would boost the mood of all the unwitting exercise addicts and reduce their compulsion to eat.
- randallsquared 18y agoMany people who exercise regularly find that they feel miserable, and eat more Yes, I'm like this. Oh, actually you meant the reverse. :) However, I do want to eat more when I'm regularly exercising, even though apparently that's not the approved response. One reason it's difficult to keep exercising regularly is that I know that even when I get to the point where what I'm now doing is easy and I don't feel miserable doing it, I'll have to push things until I do feel miserable or I won't be getting the benefit of exercise! There's no end to it; the task is never actually done; you have to continue to make yourself miserable 3-4 times a week, forever. That's very discouraging.
- dkarl 18y agoOh no, you'll continue to get the health benefits even if you let your performance plateau. You only have to push yourself if you want to keep improving your performance, and if that's your mentality, you will start to get weird satisfaction out of the misery, which compensates for the... misery aspect of the misery.