4 ms·
I find that hilarious. Particularly "While others would come to class without their homework done because they were reading about an interest of theirs, I neve
by Nursie 13y ago
I find that hilarious.
Particularly "While others would come to class without their homework done because they were reading about an interest of theirs, I never missed an assignment", "while others sat in class and doodled..." and "while others were creating music..."
This seems remarkably naive. The doodlers did not all become artists, many were just bored or uninterested. The ones missing assignments were probably not reading books that fascinated them, they were probably playing video games or smoking/drinking somewhere out of sight. The musicians probably did have more fun than you.
But none of these people had life any more figured out than you. And if you're the sort of person that can excel at anything they put their mind to, just because they want to, then the world is yours to do with as you please.
That doesn't make you a robot, it makes you a god.
- Dylan16807 13y agoPretty much anyone can excel at the level of dedication shown in the speech. The question is whether you can conjure up that dedication at will, to point at a chosen goal. If yes, god, if no, robot.
- Nursie 13y agoI suppose so. And the realisation that it is (or at least could be) you that controls that choice is probably what this is really about. --edit-- actually I'm not 100% sure everyone can excel at anything even with that level of dedication, and I am 100% sure that not everyone has it in them to give that level of dedication to anything.
- shubb 13y agoMy reading of the speech (full here[1]), was the opposite of your conclusion. She makes the case that people are naturally passionate about (different) things, and should be free to follow that passion. She makes the case that many jobs could be automated out of existence, if the objective was to free people from the need to work, rather than to perpetuate a status quo that keeps them tired and passive. These are fairly common thoughts, on the new left. I know that in the 1970s in the UK, it was expected labor intensive manufacturing jobs would be replaced by automation, and the government had conferences to decide what to do, to give people purpose without work. As it turned out, the jobs were destroyed, by outsourcing in the 1980s, and a great bulk of service jobs that were unnecessary just a few years before were created to take up the slack. Western economies are hugely over-weighted towards the service sector, but think - in a country where 40% of jobs are industrial, how do they get by with such a low proportion of servants? Does it not follow that those jobs are unnecessary? Isn't it immoral to force people do do them? Shouldn't we recalibrate society so they don't have to? So they can spend more time creating, launching startups, live longer due to earlier retirement? Personally, I'm on the fence on this one. I get a lot of purpose and enjoyment from my job, and not having one takes a huge toll on the unemployed. I find it hard to understand why unemployed friends don't just create jobs for themselves, to provide the self respect they so desperately want. Maybe people need a system that creates jobs for them so they can have a purposeful life. But anyway, the ability conjure up dedication towards a chosen goal? Certainly that would make you a productive god, a robot even, but not (according to the author) a fully realized human. That would require passion. [1]http://americaviaerica.blogspot.com.au/p/speech.html http://americaviaerica.blogspot.com.au/p/speech.html
- decasteve 13y agoWhen everything is standardized and trained with specificity, as our school system is, we are turning people into automatons. The trouble with automatons is they get automated. We have been moving, for the past 50 years, into an era where there is still a staggering amount of work that needs to be done but there is no singular defined "job" to employ a person from their early 20s until their mid-60s retirement.
- VLM 13y agoThis is the classic "education" vs "training" argument. For a variety of weird political/cultural/doublespeak reasons we're not allowed to discuss the difference, they're supposed to be synonyms. However, an education lasts a lifetime and gives meaning to life and a lifetime of interesting things to think about, and ways to think. Job training is just a meal ticket. You can guess which philosophies applied in pre-industrial vs modern K-12 .edu and which applied in pre-tuition bubble and post-tuition bubble university .edu in the USA. There is quite an impedance bump going from HS senior to Univ Freshman because of this conversion from pure training automaton setting to at least still partially an educational setting.
- Dylan16807 13y agoWhat's the difference between passion and true dedication? I would have said there wasn't one.
- shubb 13y agoI meant that dedication is when you make yourself do something in order to achieve a goal, while passion is doing that thing for it's own sake. That's what I think the girl meant. Which is the opposite of what the GP was talking about. Clearly, doing anything significant requires dedication - you aren't going to enjoy every moment. And people become passionate about whatever they do. Or they have passion for the goal they are dedicated to. The contradiction is artificial. But I can see that, if the speaker felt like her life was full of dedication, without passion, she'd feel very unfulfilled.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoAnd if you're the sort of person that can excel at anything they put their mind to, just because they want to, then the world is yours to do with as you please. That doesn't make you a robot, it makes you a god. There is no such "sort of person". Which is fine, because that person is a strawman of yours: that graduation speech is about people who can excel at anything others put their mind to. Being the best at following orders is like the top price from the consolation price shelf of skills. As Plutarch said, the mind is a fire to be kindled, not a vessel to be filled, and if you can't distinguish the interesting from the idiotic assignments, and fulfill them all with equal dog-like obedience, that's not very smart, and to think otherwise would be just as naive. If you don't, then that's not your graduation speech. There is nothing wrong with learning for tests instead of coming up with your own challenges, or with learning instead of being lazy, or a mixture of both. There isn't even anything wrong with fulfilling the expectations of others even, as long as you know why you're doing it. If you don't, if you fulfill them just because they're there, not even to relieve your boredom but to because others expect you to, then you ARE on a conveyor belt without even knowing why and how you got there, rationalizations nonwithstanding. Do you think people who blindly follow orders grow on trees, or are aware of the fact that's essentially all they're doing? Because I'd say no to both.
- Dylan16807 13y ago>There is no such "sort of person". Well that's a depressing thought. That the world is nobody's oyster, and it's only because nobody cares enough about what they choose. (Unless you're arguing that devoted work doesn't lead to excelling, in which case I think you're crazy or using completely different definitions than me.)
- PavlovsCat 13y agoThere is no person who can do literally anything just "because their put their mind to it", and the world is nobodies oyster because it's not an oyster. Also, because it has other people in it. "Love and knowledge, so far as they were possible, led upward toward the heavens. But always pity brought me back to earth. Echoes of cries of pain reverberate in my heart. Children in famine, victims tortured by oppressors, helpless old people a burden to their sons, and the whole world of loneliness, poverty, and pain make a mockery of what human life should be. I long to alleviate this evil, but I cannot, and I too suffer." --- Bertrand Russell, "Autobiography" Unless you're arguing that devoted work doesn't lead to excelling I'm not arguing it doesn't, why wouldn't it. I just don't see how that makes anyone a god, whatever that's even supposed to mean other than "epic" or "awesome" or other nonsense. No, that's simply being a human. Heck, it even applies to plants. As I just said, it's not about YOU putting your mind about something, it's about someone ELSE putting your mind to something. That this crucial distinction keeps getting missed is kinda creepy :/
- ronaldx 13y ago>The doodlers did not all become artists, many were just bored or uninterested. In fact, the doodlers were likely attending to the lecture, e.g. http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1882127,00.html http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1882127,00.ht...
- Nursie 13y agoNot sure why you were downvoted. You may well be right, as a lifelong fidgeter myself, it helps me concentrate.
- darkmighty 13y agoThis is not so much motivating, as in saying doodlers actually doodle to absorb content without letting the mind wander. I don't attend to classes for absorbing content (books are fine for that), I do to think deeply about the subject as it's exposed and interact with the teacher with questions, making the exposition richer. This just confirms the doodler stereotype.
- alexvr 13y agoI disagree. While the majority of smart kids at school do follow the traditional route, doing their work, conforming to the system (sometimes because it's easy for them, and they may as well take advantage of their brains to get a decent job, and sometimes because they're simply blind), there are always a number of exceptions. You have exceptionally-bright kids who don't know what to do with their lives and slack in school because they're bored and lazy, but you also have exceptionally bright, almost enlightened kids who are extremely passionate about learning, but find themselves disgusted by the mindless conformism required to excel in such an institution. Not every person who can excel wants to excel at something so pointless.
- zachlatta 13y agoMind if I quote that sometime? You explained my thoughts on the issues of education exactly.
- alexvr 13y agoGo for it :)
- Nursie 13y agoI don't mean to be dismissive of the exceptions, I just wanted to say that the pursuits of the other students that she suddenly finds so worthy are not necessarily so. And I tend not to think that many people at all have life figured out very well at that age. Revelations are to be expected :)