5 ms·
You're spot on, the argument is completely invalid. It's the same premise used when people claim you have no right to voice your opinion about an election if yo
by adventured 13y ago
You're spot on, the argument is completely invalid. It's the same premise used when people claim you have no right to voice your opinion about an election if you don't vote.
It's an argument form of attempting to intimidate the reader, and very lowbrow intellectually.
It's a pretty comically police state'y attitude to say that anyone's right to complain is ever revoked under any circumstances. The author apparently is immune to being aware of his own hypocrisy.
- specialist 13y agoAbstaining != apathy. If you vote "none of the above", or spoil your ballot, you have my respect. Heck, if you sit it out and chill, that's cool too. But if you can't be bothered to participate, or worse discourage others with cynicism (Trey Parker, Matt Stone), and then complain, I have nothing but contempt for you. That said, running one's own email server is nothing like voting.
- eli 13y agoJello Biafra once proposed a system where every ballot has a "None of the Above" and if that option wins, you do the election over with all new candidates.
- icebraining 13y agoHere in Portugal we can just submit a blank ballot, and it gets counted separately from the spoiled ballots. Seems easier than adding a new option to every ballot.
- eli 13y agoSure, you can do that in most American elections too, but do the blank ballots have any effect besides registering your discontent in a tally. (For what it's worth, I think that if you don't like anyone on the ballot, you're much better off encouraging better people to run or running for office yourself.)
- specialist 13y agoGreat idea. Good for election integrity too. "Under votes", common down ticket, allows someone to helpfully making a choice for you. Those down ticket races like sheriff, auditor, judge are pretty high stakes, often decided by just a few votes.
- stephengillie 13y agoElections aren't cheap. Who pays for the redo?
- vacri 13y agoThey're also not cheap to campaign for - politicians will want to avoid do-overs.