13 ms·
High-fructose corn syrup prompts considerably more weight gain than sugar (2010)
- buddylw 13y agoI don't understand the mechanism here. I thought sucrase, the enzyme that breaks down sucrose (table sugar) into 1 fructose and 1 glucose (same as HFCS), acted almost immediately -- at least on the timescale of nutrient absorption. Is it just short circuiting our sense of satiety? Maybe the raw fructose makes things sweeter and stimulates reward centers better? I wonder where honey falls in all this since it has higher fructose than the most common 55% fructose HFCS blends. We seem to know so little about all of this, but I think it's safe to say that both sugar and HFCS are bad in quantities that the common american is accustomed. I find it's best to just avoid sweet foods all together, but if forced to choose I would take HFCS over artificial sweeteners any day of the week. Our bodies have been dealing with glucose and fructose for a very long time -- even on evolutionary time scales. The same can't be said for Sucralos, aspartame, or Acesulfame potassium. Everything in the world is either overtly or subtly poisonous; the only question is, at what dose?
- MostAwesomeDude 13y agoYou sound like you are a paid shill. I know that you aren't, which disappoints me further, because I'd like to think that people are capable of educating themselves instead of spreading misinformation. On your first paragraph, pondering whether sucrose breaks down into fructose and glucose immediately: No, it doesn't. HFCS makes sugars available to the bloodstream sooner, causing larger swings in overall blood sugar levels. Additionally, this study covers rats which were given strict diets; the idea that HFCS made them fatter because they ate more food is not borne out based on the experiment's premises. Second paragraph: Irrelevant. Honey is not being discussed here. Additionally, you contradict yourself by noting (correctly) that HFCS is not half-and-half fructose and glucose, like sucrose. Third paragraph: Inverted appeal to authority. You dismiss the information that science makes available, and then put your own opinion up for offering as if it is informed and accurate. You further confuse the issue by putting a well-accepted opinion (the diets of the USA are overly rich in sugars) next to a dismissal of this study. Fourth paragraph: A delightful strawman, substituting artificial sweeteners for table sugar. Fifth: More ignorance of the general study of nutrition, with a sweeping statement that is obviously true and yet completely uninformative. Please go read the article before commenting further.
- sami36 13y agoYours has to be the most dickish comment on a comment I've ever read on HN. Congratulations. What is it that you've added to the conversation again ? Nothing.
- stcredzero 13y agoAs far as I can tell, everything he says is grounded in fact or is at least cogently supported. I intend to follow some of his pointers and read more. On the other hand, your comment is strangely and unintentionally self referential.
- vidarh 13y agoThe problem was that the comment starts out with that comment about being a paid shill, and then goes on to treat the comment it replies to as if it was a series of firm claims made to mislead, when it starts out with a bunch of questions, and draws some very limited conclusions on the belief that we know too little. MostAwesomeDude could have started out answering the questions on the assumption they are honestly meant, without the attitude, and it would have come across a lot better.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoMy that was uncivil.
- vidarh 13y agoWhy exactly do you believe it is warranted to reply in this tone? To me, regardless of the issue being discussed, this comment reflects extremely poorly on you.
- jjoonathan 13y agoFirst of all, I tend to agree with the sibling posts accusing you of failing to maintain scholarly decorum. The "paid shill" remark was uncalled for, even if I tend to agree with your criticisms (at least, all but the most crucial one). > pondering whether sucrose breaks down into fructose and glucose immediately: No, it doesn't. Can you substantiate this further (say, with an in-vivo sucrose half-life)? I don't have journal access at the moment, so the best I could find was this study: http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/content/59/1/413.extract http://ajplegacy.physiology.org/content/59/1/413.extract which seems to support what you claim (only 90% inversion after 6.5 hours in rabbits), but I'd still like to see something more modern and preferably in humans. > Additionally, this study covers rats which were given strict diets Strict diets? It seems to me like they had unmeasured and uncontrolled access to chow and sugar solution ("controlled" only on the basis of availability time)! I tend to agree with the grandparent post that the observed results could be caused by the relative sweetness of HFCS driving the rats to continue consuming HFCS past the point where they would have stopped consuming sucrose solution. Since humans tend to consume drinks in fixed quantities (8oz, 16oz) not entirely chosen on the bases of satiety, I question the relevance of this study to human health. > you contradict yourself by noting (correctly) that HFCS is not half-and-half fructose and glucose You quibble. I'll take it back iff you substantiate the implicit claim (which occurs under the assumption that you weren't quibbling) that the 5% or 7% difference in sugar concentrations creates a disproportionate effect on energy output or weight gain.
- egypturnash 13y agoWhen I want sweet foods I just seek out things made with sugar rather than HFCS. If all I can find is HFCS or artificial sweeteners, I have to wait. And have some water, most likely. I haven't done any experiments. I've just noted that (a) imported Mexican Coke really does taste like I remember Coke tasting in my 1970s childhood, and (b) I drink less when I have a soda made with sugar because it satisfies my sweet tooth instead of just tickling it and reminding me that sweet things taste good, maybe I'll go get another one of the HFCS sodas I just drank.
- ck2 13y agoStop giving out corn welfare to corporations and problem solved. It's the ONLY reason why it's so heavily used. Corn syrup and ethanol - two massively damaging products of a completely corrupt system that everyone refuses to change because of massive profits off taxpayers.
- mistercow 13y agoIt should be specified that what you say is true of ethanol in the US. In places like Brazil where they grow lots of sugar cane, it's a different story. And in theory, if ethanol were widely adopted as a fuel source in the US, we could potentially move to production using GM algae or something similar that would actually be efficient.
- nhebb 13y agoEthanol plays havoc with small engines. A couple of years ago I forgot to make sure the tank was empty and the fuel lines were cleared before winter. In the spring I had to take it to a lawn mower repair shop and plop down $50 just to clean out the gummed-up lines. It's even worse - and more expensive - for boat motors.
- Scaevolus 13y agoHistorically, there have been large sugar tariffs shielding the domestic sugar industry. There have been some recent changes, like raised tariff-free limits or NAFTA allowing free imports from Mexico, but the market is still used to corn syrup being the most economical choice.
- stephengillie 13y agoAnother control on this is the Overall Allotment Quantity of sugar, which is the USDA-regulated quantity of sugar which can be sold in any year. If you have too much sugar to sell, you'll have to store it or dump it. This is to keep sugar's price high. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_Allotment_Quantity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overall_Allotment_Quantity
- 13y ago
- grannyg00se 13y ago"The rats in the Princeton study became obese by drinking high-fructose corn syrup, but not by drinking sucrose. The critical differences in appetite, metabolism and gene expression that underlie this phenomenon are yet to be discovered" The whole thing is one big correlation confirmation. I was hoping to find something substantial that would explain the underlying cause.
- tomphoolery 13y agoI'm no expert on this, but it seems like they were studying the problem in the wrong way. Instead of considering HFCS as a food, and measuring how it works on your body, why not consider HFCS as a drug, and measure how it works on your brain? I think the HFCS->obesity issue has a lot more to do with the way sugar affects our brains. I think HFCS is detrimental to human survival because it has encouraged us to get all of our happiness from food, leading to overeating and eating to "feel better" (it never happens) in some portions of the population. Thus, we are at this obesity issue, which is really a happiness issue. From my own personal experience: When you believe in yourself and you want to change, obesity becomes less and less of a problem because you are motivated to work out, eat better and generally take care of yourself. But the fact remains that you once ingested a drug to feel happy which also made you fat. Now you are eating food the way you're supposed to and not really getting that happiness that was once supplied by the sugary foods you were eating. You must use other drugs, like meditation or even alcohol/marijuana, to supplant this "completeness" feeling that you are missing from the lack of sugary foods. Eventually, your body will give up the tolerance to sugary foods and you'll find yourself drinking sodas and eating dessert much less than you used to. Now, the general level of HFCS in all of our foods is no longer affecting your body weight and the way you feel about yourself. I don't want to sound like a commercial here, but in the last 2-3 years I've been very much aware of my sugar-rich diet and began to slowly wean myself off of the addiction, and I can happily say that I've gone from a size 40 to a size 36 waist and lost over 20 pounds in the last year alone by simply being aware of how sugar affects your mind AND body, getting more exercise, and eating smaller portions of healthier food.
- matwood 13y ago
- wdewind 13y ago> A Princeton University research team has demonstrated that all sweeteners are not equal when it comes to weight gain: Rats with access to high-fructose corn syrup gained significantly more weight than those with access to table sugar, even when their overall caloric intake was the same. I have my suspicions about HFCS, but what's not clear from the way this was written, and I suspect is the kicker here, is the access to line. Is it the same calorically balanced diet PLUS sucrose water or HFCS water, or is it the same calorically balanced diet INCLUDING sucrose water or HFCS water. The difference between the two of those is massive, and I would bet it's the former not the latter.
- mattzito 13y agoI would just like to point out that the photo in the article is the most staged "watch science happen!" photo I've seen in a long time.
- ryeguy 13y agoIs there actually a published, peer-reviewed study available from this? This just seems like an in-progress summary. Additionally, as another poster commented, this is still correlative, not causative. HFCS might be indirectly responsible for weight problems, but that's only because of its prominence, low price, and calorie dense-ness. Not some voodoo reason as this article states and as many believe. Try this: http://examine.com/faq/is-hfcs-high-fructose-corn-syrup-worse-than-sugar.html http://examine.com/faq/is-hfcs-high-fructose-corn-syrup-wors... The experiment's conclusions don't make sense either. There are dozens and dozens of studies showing ONLY net calorie intake is what is responsible for weight gain or weight loss, not the contents of what they eat: http://examine.com/faq/what-should-i-eat-for-weight-loss.html http://examine.com/faq/what-should-i-eat-for-weight-loss.htm... So for the study to refute the conclusions we have arrived at today would be quite the breakthrough. Not to mention the whole part where it violates the laws of thermodynamics. Can anyone link to a study (not an article) showing HFCS causing more weight gain in a calorie-controlled study that accounts for water weight and (preferably) doesn't have the people count their own calories?
- schoper 13y agoYour rapport with the great Goog is weak. The study: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0091305710000614 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0091305710... Reply by the Corn Refiners Association: http://www.corn.org/princeton-hfcs-study-errors.html http://www.corn.org/princeton-hfcs-study-errors.html Thermodynamics question: They were holding energy inputs constant in the system. Stored energy was not constant. What third variable could have been responsible for the difference? Rhymes with input.
- ryeguy 13y agoYour second link is broken. The study's conclusions are misleading. The total intake from food and the sweetened water were not matched for calories. The only thing matched for calories was the amount of sweetened water; rats were allowed to eat as much food as they want. They then drew all of these conclusions that aren't directly related to HFCS, but related to the fact that the rats were overeating. It's still an interesting conclusion, but really the only thing they concluded was that rats consuming HFCS ate more food than rats consuming sugar. All of the other negative effects cannot be pinned on HFCS.
- panic 13y agoYou can find the original paper at http://www.foodpolitics.com/wp-content/uploads/HFCS_Rats_10.pdf http://www.foodpolitics.com/wp-content/uploads/HFCS_Rats_10..... The statistics are a bit confusing to me, but it looks like they only find a significant difference for males over 8 weeks, not females over 7 months. The "significant" difference for males seems pretty small given that the rats started out weighing between 300 and 375 grams. And the conclusion doesn't mention sucrose at all: In summary, rats maintained on a diet rich in HFCS for 6 or 7 months show abnormal weight gain, increased circulating TG and augmented fat deposition. All of these factors indicate obesity. Thus, over-consumption of HFCS could very well be a major factor in the “obesity epidemic,” which correlates with the upsurge in the use of HFCS. Does anyone know if these results have been replicated anywhere?
- magicalist 13y agoYou weren't the only one they confused. John Timmer at Ars Technica did an excellent writeup[1] about the study and the somewhat questionable aspects of their conclusions. I would quote the relevant bits, but it's basically the entire article pointing out possible (and unaddressed) issues with the study: "Although some of the results are suggestive, given the somewhat confusing and, in some cases, contradictory nature of the result, it would seem to be appropriate to interpret them with caution, and go back and start a larger population of rats on a study with a more consistent design. The authors haven't gone that route..." [1] http://arstechnica.com/science/2010/03/does-high-fructose-corn-syrup-make-you-fatter/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2010/03/does-high-fructose-co...
- jwmerrill 13y agoThe short study and the long study apparently disagree about whether 12hr or 24hr access to HFCS results in more weight gain. The 8 wk study shows 12hr HFCS leading to much larger weight gain than any of the other groups, and 24hr access not being significantly different from sucrose or chow alone. But then reading the 8 wk number off the weight chart from the 6 month study shows 24hr access being ahead of 12hr access. You asked if these results have been replicated anywhere--it seems like the beginning of their long study didn't even replicate their short study. This makes me seriously skeptical about the differences they report between HFCS and sucrose. The only conclusion I would feel very comfortable drawing from this data is that giving rats access to sugar water for 6 months makes them fatter (Fig. 1). Finer distinctions than that seem unwarranted.
- ianqueue 13y agoNot to mention it's GMO corn being used! You might as well poke holes in the lining of your stomach.
- reeses 13y agoIf we take selective breeding, inbreeding, and hybridization into account, corn (maize) is one of the most genetically manipulated foods on the planet. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/science/25creature.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/science/25creature.html?_r...
- driverdan 13y ago[citation needed]
- ianqueue 13y agoFunny how I get -2 because people are to lazy to look things up on their own... I've also noticed people feel threatened when you talk about their food. [http://www.unionccs.net/images/library/file/Agricultura_y_alimentacion/Health_Risks_GMOs.pdf http://www.unionccs.net/images/library/file/Agricultura_y_al...] [http://geneticroulettemovie.com/ http://geneticroulettemovie.com/] There are a lot more... Wake up people, they care about making money not your health!
- phy6 13y agoWe did a little human testing on our fraternal twin infants. The slightly smaller of the two was fed formula which had HFCS as an ingredient, the other was fed formula not containing HFCS as the sweetener. Our smaller son quickly gained more weight and started to outweigh his brother by a pound. The (initially) smaller twin still outweighs his brother. They are now ~21 lbs and 19 lbs respectively @11mo
- driverdan 13y agoAnecdote. There could have been other differences between the formulas, the children could have varied in weight naturally, or there could be other factors you didn't control for.
- lbcadden3 13y agoHigh-fructose corn syrup and ethanol, with increasing push back against farm subsidies due to tax payers and trade agreements, these are the loopholes used. I was recently diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, the single biggest change I have made is avoiding products with hfcs, going very well and lost 30 pounds.
- pkulak 13y agoWow, this blows my mind just a little bit. Especially since I've been wrong about this for so long even though this study has been out for years. I always thought that table sugar and HFCS were the same. 50/50 glucose to fructose (about). But then there's this: "...as a result of the manufacturing process for high-fructose corn syrup, the fructose molecules in the sweetener are free and unbound, ready for absorption and utilization. In contrast, every fructose molecule in sucrose that comes from cane sugar or beet sugar is bound to a corresponding glucose molecule and must go through an extra metabolic step before it can be utilized." So with HFCS you're just free-basing fructose? Amazing. Maybe I have to stop making fun of this trend toward "NO HFCS! PURE CAN SUGAR!" that I've been writing off as nonsense until now...
- Terretta 13y agoEncourage your supermarket to carry Pepsi Throwback alongside their real Pepsi.
- Khelavaster 13y agoWhere's the rampant fact-checking and criticism of major dietary studies I usually see on HN? Could this have anything to do with bias against high-fructose corn syrup, which is chemically almost identical to honey? The LA Times reported on the study in depth, and there are some serious deficiencies. > "After eight weeks, three groups of rats weighed essentially the same – the chow-only rats (462 grams on average), the 24-hour HFCS rats (470 grams) and the sugar-water rats (477 grams). But the rats that were able to drink the HFCS solution for 12 hours each day weighed in at an average of 502 grams, a difference that was deemed statistically significant." > "Complicating things further, the researchers cite a related study of female rats that found no difference in weight gain between animals that consumed HFCS or sugar over an eight-week period." >"the researchers found that rats allowed to drink the HFCS solution gained more weight over six months than rats with no access to a sweetened beverage. The difference was dramatic: rats with 24-hour access to HFCS gained 27% more weight than the rats stuck with chow only. But the researchers didn’t include a third group of rats with access to sugar, so it’s impossible to say whether HFCS was worse than regular sugar."* >"The researchers remedied this problem in a third experiment involving female rats. Over a seven-month period, rats that were able to drink sugar water for 12 hours a day gained 183% of their body weight – the exact same amountas rats who could drink HFCS solution for 12 hours a day. However, female rats with 24-hour access to HFCS boosted their body weight by 200%. It’s not clear why high-fructose corn syrup was more fattening over an eight-week period when it was available for 12 hours of the day (but not 24), yet the opposite was true when the experiment lasted for seven months." This is what happens when reporters don't understand what they're writing about. *"(Why didn’t they test the long-term effects of sugar? The researchers said it wasn’t necessary because sugar consumption didn’t affect body weight in their first experiment. True, but neither did HFCS when made available for 24 hours a day, and they did test that.)" http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/booster_shots/2010/03/high-fructose-corn-syrup-hfcs-sugar-princeton-study.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/booster_shots/2010/03/high-f...
- jacques_chester 13y agoSmart people like to know deep truths and secret histories. HFCS is a perfect fit, because it sets up an interesting systemic cause for obesity. The problem with the HCFS-caused-population-obesity hypothesis is that it's immediately falsified by the rest of the developed world. Only the USA has HFCS in its food supply in any quantity because only the USA has corn politics. But in spite of the absence of HFCS in the food supply of Britain and Australia, for example, we are following the same trajectory as the USA. BMI is a lagging indicator of calories consumer per capita per year. And the exact food mix doesn't seem to matter. This is the kind of thing you would expect when combining basic physics with large sample sizes. However, finding out that what you learnt in grade 3 (eat too much --> get fat) is still true is boring and lends no social status for being the leader on a new idea.
- swamp40 13y agoI can't believe the smartest people on the planet here are arguing about this. HFCS is cheaper than sugar because of the tariffs, but it is an equivalent substitute. No better, no worse. Americans are getting fatter these days because the food industry (McDonald's as well as prepackaged foods) can make desirable, filling foods for a dollar or two. If they needed to use sugar instead of HFCS, it would be about 10 cents more per dollar - big deal. People like corn dogs and cake - it tastes good. So businesses have mass produced it enough to make it affordable to everyone. The potatoes and beans of yesterday are cheap as well, but nobody wants them. That's why people are gaining weight. Absolutely nothing to do with HFCS vs sugar - the food designers can use either one with the same effect.
- paul_f 13y agoIt is carbohydrates and "low fat" diets making people obese. The only think unhealthy in a bacon cheeseburger is the bun. Until we can kill this "low fat" nonsense, people will continue to get fatter.
- corresation 13y agoThe low-fat/high-fat argument is entirely dominated by pseudo-science. Eat less. Be more active. Period.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nnutter 13y agoI haven't looked yet but I would like to see experiments that look at how varying amounts of HFCS cause extra weight. It could be that even a small amount (over time or not) damages something and then causes weight gain or it could just be that they have more accessible calories. I'd also like to see an experiment about the reversibility of the weight loss. If you get them fat on HFCS and then switch to regular sucrose do they end up looking like the rats that had sucrose the whole time.
- cpncrunch 13y agoActually, all this proves is that some people on HN are idiots who can't be bothered to read the actual study. Remove the last two words of your title and your post would be technically correct (i.e the same title as the news article). Male rats fed HFCS did have more weight gain than rats fed only chow. However there was no difference between rats fed HFCS and rats fed sucrose over the long-term. Please actually read the study and look at Table 1.
- geekam 13y agoI have always hated the campaign by CRA for HFCS like this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQ-ByUx552s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQ-ByUx552s
- mchusma 13y agoI try to beat on this drum whenever I see people jump to conclusions, in studies, on the media, or on Hacker News, based off one study. The possibility for one study to be screwed up is so enormously high nobody should ever take one at face value. To date, most studies that review the concept of "some foods make you fatter than others" vs "calories in vs calories out" consistently weigh in favor of "calories in vs calories out". I always find www.sciencebasedmedicine.org to be a great resource for this. Also, the podcast Skeptics Guide to the Universe is really fun, and they talk about things like this all the time.