36 ms·
That's really, really sad. And the worst part is, it's surely conscious on nobody's part. There have even been studies showing this effect. What's even sadder
by crazygringo 13y ago
That's really, really sad.
And the worst part is, it's surely conscious on nobody's part. There have even been studies showing this effect.
What's even sadder is that there's no obvious or easy way to fix it.
- cliveowen 13y agoThere is a simple way to fix it. Namely providing a means to submit your resume that anonymizes name, gender, age and anything that could bias the reviewer's assessment. The best HR departments already do that, at least that's the hope.
- potatolicious 13y agoHR departments are legal shields - they will prevent bias against a protected class because that's a source of lawsuits. Unfortunately there are many ways in which a person may be unfairly discriminated when looking for a job, than there are protected classes in the law.
- mathattack 13y agoIt's easy enough to fix for screening for gender, but it's much harder to fix the screening for age, because people like to see a sequence of activities. At the very least, work experience years comes across. When people leave off graduation dates, that throws up a red flag too. The harder part is how do you turn off the bias once the interviews start? This was an issue with many orchestras - they ultimately made the auditions physically blind. http://www.uh.edu/~adkugler/Goldin&Rouse.pdf http://www.uh.edu/~adkugler/Goldin&Rouse.pdf
- whiterabbit2 13y agoFor tech companies it shouldn't be a problem to interview candidates blindly. Give some questions as written tests and coding assignments. If talking is necessary, there is software changing voice pitch. Skype has a plugin like that. Just interview a candidate sitting in another room, streaming what they write and use the same voice settings for all candidates. My impression that nobody uses written tests because companies want to keep bias, not to eliminate it.
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoThe problem with that is similar to "online dating". Sure you can learn a lot about a person without ever seeing or hearing them... but you don't really know a person until you have spent a portion of time actually interacting with them. If you are hiring a person to be part of a team, you need that person to gel with the team at least on some level. I don't think you could get an accurate representation of that if you can't hear that person's true voice, see their mannerisms, etc. I've been in situations where our team was down to two candidates that had various strengths/weaknesses but for the most part were equally qualified. Either one of them was just as likely as the other to be able to perform the work we needed someone to do. Is it wrong to go with the person that we felt would fit into the team the best?
- mathattack 13y agoExactly. You can anonymously sort for IQ, but not for EQ. And the IQ parts can be gamed. (I know of someone who "cheated" their way into Microsoft)
- tehwalrus 13y agoThere was a proposal going around the Lib Dems in the UK at one point[1] to make it illegal to have names on CVs; because they describe gender, and sometimes race, too. The proposal went on to say that that people should apply for jobs using their National Insurance number (like a social security number, but basically just used as a UID with the tax office - I don't know what else a SSN does, but it seems to be more important than that.) This would mean that candidates selected for the first round of interviews would be chosen 'blind', even in small companies, which would limit this sort of subconscious discrimination. I'd love to see this sort of idea resurrected; the article is an excellent advert as to why. [1] before we got into a coalition with male Tories who think they got into oxbridge on merit...
- TeMPOraL 13y agoIt won't work everywhere; e.g. SSN equivalent in Poland has sex encoded as one of the digits (determined by whether it's even or odd).
- WalterSear 13y agoIf the bias is subconcious, moving to this would still have an effect.
- nostrademons 13y agoPeople are remarkably good at picking up on subtle signals that correlate well with their existing biases. Instead of "It seems like a women" they'll subconsciously think "It seems like an even."
- WalterSear 13y agoIt wouldn't be perfect, but most of the effect would be removed.
- larrys 13y ago"SSN equivalent in Poland has sex encoded" That gets supplied when sending a resume?
- noloqy 13y agoWhat's next? All the interviews have to take place in a dark room so that the interviewer can't see the color of the interviewee's skin?
- nollidge 13y agoNo, that's not next.
- 6cxs2hd6 13y agoTuring Test interviews.
- cpeterso 13y agoIRC interviews
- Someone 13y agoEven that is not 100% watertight: http://www.hackerfactor.com/GenderGuesser.php http://www.hackerfactor.com/GenderGuesser.php
- whiterabbit2 13y agoI tried my own comments from this page. The majority gives me around 70-85% male (I'm a feminine female). But adding one comment which was talking "childcare" and such gave me "only" a weak male (saying it might indicate European). It's so stereotypical. Interesting also how it divides people into males, females and Europeans (the "weak" versions).
- zxcdw 13y agoWhere do I sign up?
- rozap 13y agoChinese room interviews.
- 13y ago
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> anything that could bias the reviewer's assessment Well, you could argue that list of skills, education and work experience could bias the assessment as well. There's no clear-cut line here that separates relevant from irrelevant. Sometimes even gender is relevant. For example clerks in grocery stores are mostly women and there are bunch of good business reasons for that (even if they are based on stupid social biases, those biases still are real and business value can be extracted from them). Also, once a shop commits to a particular gender choice, it might be inclined to stick to it exclusively. For instance, I heard a first-hand story from a local grocery store about why exactly it avoids hiring men (especially attractive ones) for clerks - because it leads to relationships forming between co-workers, which usually end with people left jealous and/or angry at each other. I can't really blame that shop for this choice, it is a rational one. I'm not responsible for hiring decisions right now, but if I were then one thing I wouldn't want to be anonymized are names. I do believe in the concept of maintaining blacklists against well known cheaters, spammers and other evil doers, and anonymizing names makes you unable to discriminate people by level-of-assholiness ;).
- epochwolf 13y ago> I can't really blame that shop for this choice, it is a rational one. Allow me. It's illegal for an employer to discriminate against applicants based on gender when it doesn't serve a direct business purpose. (Actors, Models, Priests, etc.) While I can sympathize and understand their reasons, I can not condone their solution.
- gohrt 13y agoAnd this is why Abercrombie&Fitch has no cashiers, only "models". You can't legislate away reality...
- saraid216 13y agoThis is one of the two-way street issues. There is real business value to be extracted from exploiting the existing sexism in society, agreed, but in doing so, it also reinforces that existing sexism. It's a vicious cycle of mutually supporting behavior. That is a problem. Denying said value is not necessarily the best solution, but some solution is necessary.
- drpgq 13y agoI moved to Germany to work from Canada after finishing grad school and was amazed to find applicants put pictures on resumes there. Ironically later we made an attractiveness estimator and I suggested we use it to screen somebody applying for a secretary position (I was only joking and actually more pointing out the ridiculousness of having photos on resumes).
- orff 13y ago... and not only pictures. it is standard to include your birthday and nationality in your CV in Germany. And sometimes, the early career applicants adds the employers of their PARENTS in their CVs !!!
- guard-of-terra 13y agoMaybe it's actually because people are less afraid of discrimination there? So they don't have to play it safe.
- claudius 13y agoSure, why not? Birthday might not be absolutely relevant, but allows to judge your success at school/uni/education much more easily, nationality is relevant to decide whether they would have to go through trouble to get you employed (if non-European), and the employers/jobs of your parents usually correlate strongly with your own qualifications, at least on a quantitative level. Whether you like the fact that a surprisingly large number of university student has academics for parents, it is still there, and if you want an intelligent person, it might act as a decent filter to look for intelligent parents, especially is said person does not have much experience otherwise yet.
- drpgq 13y agoWow never heard the parents' employers. It's worse than I thought.
- jrarredondo 13y agoAt some point you do have the phone screen though.
- lukevdp 13y agoWouldn't that just make the discrimination (conscious or unconscious) happen later? Sooner or later they will find out the gender of the applicant.
- wizzard 13y agoI believe Monster.com allows you to do this; there is an option to hide your contact info and only allow recruiters to contact you through the site. This is ostensibly to allow you to apply for new jobs without being discovered by your current job. I would imagine many job sites provide this feature.
- lumens 13y agoUnfortunately, the vast majority of HR departments (even the 'best') aren't doing this at all. My company, Mighty Spring (https://www.mightyspring.com https://www.mightyspring.com), is doing exactly this on a larger scale: we're a marketplace that connects people and employers, but the employers see anonymized versions of each candidate's data/career history. They request to interview candidates on the platform based on these anonymous profiles. Should the candidate accept, we reveal contact information to both parties and help schedule the interview. While we're still fairly early stage, we're aiming to expose bias at different points in the hiring process using this approach, and at the very least help employers understand their own biases. Acceptance is the first step to a solution, no?
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoIt would be great to see this more. It could provide some interesting data. I would be interested to hear if anonymized resumes closed the gender gap for getting an interview or not. It could also expose a possible bias if the gender gap closed for getting a first interview but then the gap simply shifted up one level when it came to the second step of the process (ie, disproportionately more men move on to a second interview). Although, it might actually be harder to show a bias at that level since a lot of the interview process has to do with how well the person sells themselves, articulates their answers, presents themselves physically (ie, dressed appropriately), etc. These things also happen to be very subjective so it is kind of difficult to prove there was a bias. Which is also why it is equally difficult to prove there was not a bias. (Did you not get hired because of your gender? Or just because you didn't interview well?) I have no doubt that people get turned down based on unimportant "qualifications" like gender, race, age, etc. And that is wrong. But I also have no doubt that some people who felt they were turned down for one of those reason actually just wasn't qualified or blew the interview and don't think to look internally before they look around them.
- bitops 13y ago> What's even sadder is that there's no obvious or easy way to fix it. There is no easy way to fix it, but there is a way to fix it. I won't go so far as to say that it's obvious to many people. The way to do it? Work to change men's attitudes and biases towards women. It can definitely be done, but it takes hard work and cultural change. I would recommend the book "The Macho Paradox" by Jackson Katz for anyone interested in the topic of gender discrimination. Jackson writes well, he's a man, and he brings a mans perspective to the issues. There is no demonization or undue blame assigned to men in the book. It's a powerful read.
- thenomad 13y agoThanks, I've been looking for reading on this topic. (Self-Made Man by Norah Vincent is also excellent - one woman's experiences disguised as a man. Sounds potentially lightweight or biased, is neither.)
- takluyver 13y agoHowever, those biases come in part from our experience. People subconsciously assume that a woman won't make a good engineer (for example), because when they picture the engineers that they've met, the overwhelming majority are male. So to change those attitudes, one of the things you need is to make the numbers more balanced.
- speeder 13y agoWhy you need to change MEN attitudes? Most HR departments are staffed by women for example, they would be the ones that saw a "Mr." in the resume.
- nmcfarl 13y agoOf course you need men to change their attitudes - the majority of people at the top of the food chain are male, and they’re the ones that make the hiring decisions. But you are right - it’s not an exclusively male problem, and woman are perfectly capable of discriminating against other women, and do, frequently, and often unconsciously. In the end society as a whole needs to change how it views women, and how it acts upon those views.
- hack_edu 13y agoWant to see this in action? Create near-identical profiles on any job site frequented by recruiters, one profile male and another female. Your male account, fictional or not, will get a measurable amount more attention and see more outreach.
- nawitus 13y agoThe studies I've seen actually demonstrate that women get called for interviews slightly more often than men. (The studies were not in software engineering, so different industries certainly are different).
- tekalon 13y agoI've heard more personal experiments (be it by gender or ethnicity) leaning more towards white/male names getting more interviews and jobs than ethnic/female names.
- hack_edu 13y agoIt would be especially interesting to compare by gender the amount of interest, frequency of landing an interview, and rate of success of landing an interview. I'd be very curious to see if biases shift depending on the phase of hiring process.
- OGC 13y ago"The studies were not in software engineering" Worthless comment then, carry on.
- Peroni 13y agoAs far as the Tech industry in the UK is concerned, the polar opposite couldn't be more true.
- reinhardt 13y agoI somehow suspect that the opposite would be true for, say, preschool teachers or nurses.
- yaddayadda 13y ago
- pseut 13y agoThere could be conscious discrimination against the resume once the "married with kids" line is added; I wouldn't be so quick to assume that surely nobody is doing it. Honestly (and this is embarrassing to admit), I'd probably think much differently about a female job applicant who had that line on her resume than a male applicant. In particular, I wouldn't necessarily expect that line to imply anything about a male candidate's commitment to the work/job, but just write it off as a misguided attempt to look "well rounded." So, shit, I'm worse than I thought.
- Amadou 13y agoThe bias goes like this: If a man is married with kids - then he's got more commitment to work because he's got the responsibility of a family depending on his income. If a woman is married with kids - the she's got less commitment to work because she's got the responsibility for the well-being of a family depending on her attention.
- pseut 13y agoIt's not just that, but more about why the applicant thinks that "married with kids" is important information on his or her resume. Why does he or she want to broadcast that fact (especially given that, in the US at least, it's illegal to ask a job applicant if he or she is married and has kids because of the possibility of exactly this discrimination)? But, of course, if the applicant is qualified I should try to figure out why in the job interview, not by projecting some made up story on the resume.
- Spooky23 13y agoI drop that sometimes as a invitation to discriminate when I don't know alot about the organization. If you're going to be giving me dirty looks for working less than 50 hours, have an unspoken mandatory happy hour attendance policy, 24x7 oncall, etc, I don't want to waste the time of both parties by interviewing with you.
- pessimizer 13y agoIt's conscious on a lot of people's parts. I've also heard "no women, no sexual harassment suits" enough from people in tech to assume that there are a lot of bigots not dumb enough to admit it out loud. I could be going too far, though. Maybe the kind of dumb lockerroom overshare bluster amongst the employees and managers of sexually harassing companies and departments lends itself to admitting incriminating things like that to other men with a wink wink nudge nudge.
- anotherbadlogin 13y agoThe perceived lower value of women in the workplace comes from the fact that they can suddenly announce that they're pregnant; they're allowed, by law, to take a leave of absence to have a kid and put the company in a lurch. This is especially harmful to small businesses. We all know this, so why dance around the subject? What we have here is hypocrisy. Society tells women that they're equals, but then tells them that they're cows to be extended special dispensation to churn out offspring. We have plenty of people on the planet, and we don't need more. Having children is a choice, and we shouldn't all be expected to pander to those who make it. What's the solution here?
- belorn 13y agoI would not call it bigotry, but rather stupidity. They are not the first people ever thinking the idea of separating female and men, or suggested that some benefits can be achieved that way. Schools like to separate girls from boys, and points towards improved and safer environment. Conferences like to create women only sections, in the idea (with some irony) that it would improve gender equality, and like schools, make a better environment for teaching out technology. I call it stupid because it fail some basic common sense. A mixed classroom, work space, or conference room is better because it increase cooperation, make society better, and switch the focus on the individual skill level rather than their sex. Schools have almost gone through this stage and fully gone over to mixed classrooms. The work space is learning the same lesson, but slower. As to conferences, I can only assume that they are looking at the workplace and fail to connect the dots.
- anaptdemise 13y ago
- ajdecon 13y ago> And the worst part is, it's surely conscious on nobody's part. There have even been studies showing this effect. There are studies showing that the unconscious effect exists. But it's definitely conscious at times. I know a few people in HR in Silicon Valley, and here are a few things they've heard from actual hiring managers: "You don't have any kids? Great, we can work you harder!" "If he had to reschedule the phone interview because his kid is sick, I don't want to move forward hiring him. He obviously has his priorities wrong." "I don't know, she's at just about the age most women get pregnant. Don't we have a guy we could interview?" :-(
- LockeWatts 13y agoThose seem like caricatures of what an HR person would say, rather than what was actually said. I work at a company notorious for poor work\life balance, and nobody has ever said to me 'we can work <person> harder' in any context. They say things like 'We value people who are commited to growing the company. If a candidate shows us he's willing to go the extra mile to finish the project he's working on, that's a definite positive indicator."
- ajdecon 13y agoIronically, the "we can work you harder" one was the one that I actually saw the email for. :) The others, I admit, may have been paraphrased.
- LockeWatts 13y agoFair enough. Some company you've been at had a bad HR and recruiting department...
- Tichy 13y agoI've heard that companies like men with wives and kids, because wives will drive them to work harder. Can't afford to lose your job if you have to support a family either.
- loginalready 13y agoIt's really really sad that once again denial is the top comment on HN with the truth starting us in the face. How on earth is this kind of discrimination not conscious, when the only difference in a written resume is the assumption that the person is female?
- JulianMorrison 13y agoThere absolutely is an easy, obvious way to fix it. It's just something that gives men the screaming meemies. Quotas. Don't give me guff about "the best person for the job". You've been picking the best man for the job.
- Scaevolus 13y agoWould the quotas be proportional to the applicant pool's huge gender gaps? Only ~20% of CS graduates are women.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoIf it were me, I'd set a strict, cast-iron, no excuses 50% for the first, say, 50 years. After that things might have calmed down a bit. Demand will drive supply, if needs be. Lack of demand has certainly driven it down.
- jlgreco 13y agoWith dramatically higher demand for women programmers, would it be permissible to pay women far more than men? How would this affect gender relations in the workplace? Assuming that currently 20% of programmers are women, would 60% of the current programmer population (or 75% of current male programmers) have to go unemployed until more women had entered the workforce? Following from my first question: if we think paying men and women differently is a-okay, what would this 25/75 split do to the salary of male programmers? How would this affect gender relations in the workplace? Would these same quotas apply to universities as well? How would the market react to universities making cuts in graduation rates to accommodate occasional fluctuations in the woman student population? What kind of grace periods and permitted lag would be allowed? If I fired a woman, would I have to fire a man to make up for it that same day? That same week? That same month? Would I just have to refill that position with another woman? What if I decided to eliminate that role entirely? I am not convinced that you have put thought into your proposal. It makes for a good sound bite and I don't doubt that your intentions are noble, but it is not a good idea.
- jrarredondo 13y agoI don't know if this is obvious, or if it applies to all kinds of jobs. Something I do is give all candidates an assignment: here is a problem, solve it, and let's discuss it over Skype/Webex/etc. The best solution typically wins. There is no way to fake talent when an actual job-related problem needs to be solved and then a solution sold to a team of folks. There are issues with this approach too: somebody else could help the candidate, the presentation style, etc. Picking the right problem to solve is important, as is deciding ahead of time what is the criteria for selection.
- nostrademons 13y agoThe way to fix it is to start a software company and then hire all the overlooked overqualified women on the job market. When people are being stupid like this, it's a market inefficiency; it means that the market price for a woman will be lower than for an equivalently-qualified man. As an entrepreneur, your job is to exploit that market inefficiency and in the process drive wages up to parity.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- acjohnson55 13y agoThat's fine to first approximation, but doesn't hold up in the real world, where women have the deck stacked against them in the tech world at every turn. If men are being preferentially chosen over women, then that damages the ability of women to be competitive at the next level.
- gohrt 13y agoThe fix for that is to work from the bottom up, not by intentionally ruining a bsiness by hiring less effective people at the time. Note that "women aren't represented in the executive levels" isn't a significant issue, not for the vast majority of women or men. Very few people are executives, and it's not important to 95% of the population what the gender of the executives is. The majority of women have more in common with the majority of men that are non-executives, than they do with the few women that are executives.
- roguecoder 13y agoEasy fix: have one person remove names from resumes, and a second person evaluate them. Or, if that's too much work, just use affirmative action.
- acjohnson55 13y agoThere are some pretty obvious ways to fix it. A basic step would be people actually owning up to their own biases. At the very least, then people could better detect their unconscious biases and override them with objectivity. I don't think that would be enough, but we'd be far better off if we could get to that point.
- pjmlp 13y agoFully agree. Some of the best developers and managers I had the luck to work with were women.
- DominikR 13y agoOne thing that can be done to improve the situation is to require candidates to NOT include gender, age, family status etc. in their resume. Some companies like Google do this (link: http://www.google.com/jobs/students/joining/ http://www.google.com/jobs/students/joining/)
- pinaceae 13y agoand their first name too? Lisa... and then there are languages, like Nordics and Slavic, where the last name reveals your gender - Sigmundsdottir (daughter of Sigmund), Politkowskaja (f) vs. Politkowski (m), etc.
- DominikR 13y agoDon't be negative, all I am saying is that there are things that can be done to improve the situation, and there are many companies out there that are actively trying. I wouldn't know that Sigmundsdottir would be revealing the gender, and many other wouldn't either. (I'm not saying that it can't be improved even further) Edit: I have a slavic last name that doesn't reveal my gender (on the balkans, last names are the same for both male/female)