5 ms·
All these "crypto.... scary!" things are right of course. But somehow tiresome. They're ripe for satire... something involving Chuck Norris being the only one
by davidw 13y ago
All these "crypto.... scary!" things are right of course. But somehow tiresome. They're ripe for satire... something involving Chuck Norris being the only one perfect enough to encrypt stuff, just as he's able to compress random data. 100%. With his biceps.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- obituary_latte 13y agohttp://www.schneierfacts.com/facts/623 http://www.schneierfacts.com/facts/623
- Shank 13y agoI would agree, but for something as important as cryptography, I would prefer people error on the side of too cautious or repetitive if it means less people making the same mistake twice. It's the same reason why I don't mind repeated HN submissions if it's a good enough delay - the discussion was clearly relevant the first time, and new people have joined the community since then and deserve an equal chance to talk about the subject with new perspective.
- zalambar 13y agoCaution is a good attitude to have when working on critical code with non-obvious modes of failure. However I agree with davidw; this "dont' touch it" or "we're not smart enough" attitude is tiresome. Couldn't we instead admit that this is a difficult problem which requires some engineering rigor to solve well and talk about how we can address such problems like professionals instead of hiding from them?
- tptacek 13y agoMost people don't actually want to do their own surgery. Even if you put a scalpel in someone's hands, and gave them all the anesthesia, they still wouldn't be tempted to remove someone's appendix after reading an eHow article about it. The same isn't true of crypto. People know both intellectually and viscerally that they shouldn't be doing their own surgeries. But they only have an intellectual understanding that crypto is unsafe. A big part of that is because the harm caused by crypto mistakes are often an externality to the developer.
- arthuredelstein 13y agoThat's fine, but we have an emergency right now and there aren't enough surgeons to go around. We need more competent crypto engineers ASAP.
- tptacek 13y agoOk then, here's a scalpel, go to town: http://www.schneier.com/book-applied.html http://www.schneier.com/book-applied.html
- gizmo686 13y agoA bigger part of it is that bad crypto looks alot like good crypto.
- marcosdumay 13y agoIt doesn't only need engineering rigour. Good crypto needs engineering rigour, honest colective work, and time to mature.
- tptacek 13y agoSerious question: why does this bother you so much? If we were talking instead about people operating their own pharmacies, or doing their own home electrical work, nobody would bat an eyelash.
- 23david 13y agoHome electrical work is a great example. Just pick up a $10 book at your local Home Depot and if you can read and follow the simple instructions and guidelines inside, you'll be able to do most simple electrical work. Some electricians may say that it's foolish to do your own electrical work unless you're a trained/certified electrician. Lots of people do most of their own electrical work without problems, and only hire expert electricians for the really risky or technical parts such as connecting to the utility companies or dealing with really high voltages.
- tptacek 13y ago"Simple electrical work" might equate to "wiring Nacl into an application". Designing a cryptosystem to replace Nacl in your application is more akin to climbing up the pole in your alley and working from there. But I'm particularly interested in David's response, because he raises this concern pretty regularly.
- im3w1l 13y agoIs there some kind of cryptography for idiots guide around? Something that explains how to use a high level cryptography library safely. A guide that recognizes that the reader is probably stupid enough to create a buffer overflow if he even goes near C++. A guide that assumes the reader will use rand to generate keys if able to and not reminded multiple times not to. A guide for people who have never heard about side channels. A guide that seriously cautions not to hand over the plaintext to Eve even if she asks nicely.
- tptacek 13y agoIf you use the right library --- Nacl or Keyczar, or call out to PGP --- you don't need to be an expert to build cryptography into your application. In all the stories you read about some generalist developer blowing their users' feet off with bad crypto, what you're reading about is someone reinventing these libraries with vanity crypto.