13 ms·
"I'd very much like to know what led Mr Obama to change his mind" He didn't change his mind. He lied to get elected. His team knew exactly what message to hit,
by adventured 13y ago
"I'd very much like to know what led Mr Obama to change his mind"
He didn't change his mind. He lied to get elected. His team knew exactly what message to hit, riding the wave of anti-Republican / anti-George W. Bush sentiment, to win the election. Obama is a politician above all else, and a scoundrel; but then I repeat myself [hat tip Mr Twain].
Normal people get confused by how a politician's brain works. Typically a person holds a set of beliefs, and attempts to follow those whenever they reasonably can. They have a code of morality, knowingly chosen or absorbed by default, and they try to be good, most of the time. Politicians do not function that way professionally. Work life Obama is not private life Obama. A voter sees what they think is a normal person when they vote; there's nothing normal about the business life of a politician. The really talented ones hold every belief simultaneously, and switch when it's required. With the only restriction being the party ideology; and the only variable within that being the strictness of adherence (it's the same game of ideological flexibility, just played within the party's limits).
In this day and age, to aspire to the Presidency, you're either a psychotic power luster capable of any lies and misdeeds necessary to win the office, or you're an ideologue willing to fall on the sword. The former usually wins.
- diminoten 13y agoThat's nice fiction, but it's entirely unfalsifiable, making it a completely ineffective as a theory.
- wissler 13y agoThe theory that it should be falsifiable in order to be valid, is not falsifiable.
- logical42 13y agoPerhaps it's not a theory. Perhaps it's an axiom.
- maggit 13y agoI'd say it's a paradigm. For whatever that's worth ;)
- vog 13y agoWhat your call "theory that it should be falsifiable" is in fact the very base of science. And this principle (among others) served us quite well for the last few hundred years, leading to progress, understanding, knowledge, inventions and innovations. Of course you can apply lower standards, such as "having some good-sounding arguments is all you nedd", but then the results become quickly worse.
- wissler 13y agoJust because you are told that something is the "base of science", doesn't make it the base of science. Also, read Newton's Rules of reasoning for a better example of a philosophy that's successfully been at the base of science.
- vog 13y agoI was referring to Richard Feyman (not Newton, but still a great influential physicist). Unfortunately, I can't reproduce his exact words from my mind.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe discussion of validity when replying to someone referring to effectiveness is deceptive.
- wissler 13y agoTheories are concerned with truth. That true theories are also effective is a side-effect. I.e., you are a very confused person.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe comment that you were replying to was about effectiveness. You replied with an intentional equivocation between effectiveness and validity. i.e. neither of us are confused, but you are being dishonest.
- wissler 13y agoAs I just pointed out, whether a theory is effective or not is irrelevant, the question is whether it is true or not. So I reinterpreted the original point so it actually made sense, and rightly so. You are not only confused about that, but you're also incredibly arrogant (in that you think you discern dishonest motives with such sparse evidence).
- diminoten 13y agoIt's not a theory, it's part of the successfully utilized scientific method. If you'd like the credentials for the scientific method as used over the past 150+ years, let me know. Might even be a fun article to write.
- fractallyte 13y agoHas anyone invented/discovered a system where this can't happen? There's that famous phrase (Churchill): 'It has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried'. But this is more subtle: it's about lying, and ultimately, corruption. Is this a solved problem in hard political science? I know of various solutions explored in science fiction, notably by Robert Heinlein, Arthur Clarke, Eric Frank Russell, Christopher Anvil, et al. There's game theory, where cooperation 'breeds' more cooperation, in a world of defectors. But, it seems to me, corruption is now the biggest problem facing humanity. If we can fix that, it'll cascade down through everything else: climate change, energy sources, ecological destruction, sexism, etc...
- jdc 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition
- codev 13y agoSortition has a lot going for it and certainly encourages participation far beyond our current democratic engagement. I'd like to see it start to appear on a small scale, beyond Juries, in modern democratic states. There's an interesting EconTalk discussing the Ancient Greek economy where Russ Roberts asks his guest: "We certainly romanticize Greece as this great democracy; but it wasn't much like the United States, tell us about it" But after Josiah Ober describes Athenian democracy it ends up sounding like what we call modern democracy is a very poor imitation. http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/08/ober_on_the_anc.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/08/ober_on_the_anc.htm...
- ultramundane828 13y agoThank you for this. Just last week I thought of this, but didn't know there was a name for it, or that it had been used before. I think people are turned off by the idea of some random "crazy" running things, but that's exactly what I think would provide checks and balances to a government (namely, that the "crazies" don't reach a consensus as easily as the corrupt). And on another level, our laws would have to be understandable! What would that be like? Would I actually know why I am being arrested?
- SkyMarshal 13y agoThis is more your anger speaking than any real direct experience, unless you've worked Obama or other Presidents.
- honzzz 13y ago>>> In this day and age, to aspire to the Presidency, you're either a psychotic power luster capable of any lies and misdeeds necessary to win the office... Just a little clarification - I am pretty sure you make the same mistake that apparently many people do and confuse 'psychotic' and 'psychopathic'. Those are very different things and what you describe seems to be psychopathic (characterized by psychopathy or antisocial personality disorder - lies, manipulation, lack of remorse etc.) behaviour - this behaviour is not typical for psychotic people. Psychotic person is someone who suffers from psychosis - for example schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Psychotic people have really difficult life and it is partially because of the social stigma attached to psychoses - we should not make it worse by associating psychoses with morally despicable behaviour typical for psychopaths.
- adventured 13y agoI certainly do understand there are very important differences between, for example: psychotic, psychopathic, schizophrenic, sociopath, and so on. I'm not a doctor, and won't pretend to be one. Even in the mental health industry these definitions are constantly evolving and have been for a long time. I just needed to get the point across, and for that purpose I knew the word psychotic would do the trick. Most people understand in general terms what you mean when you use that term: they think cold blooded, someone without the ability to empathize, cold and calculating, willing to hurt people to reach their objectives, etc. Sociopathic would have been a better choice: "a personality disorder characterized by amorality and lack of affect; capable of violent acts without guilt feelings"
- honzzz 13y ago>>> I knew the word psychotic would do the trick. Most people understand in general terms what you mean when you use that term: they think cold blooded, someone without the ability to empathize, cold and calculating, willing to hurt people to reach their objectives, etc. No, that's psychopathic, not psychotic. You are right that definitions are constantly evolving... but this is not the case. Psychopathic/psychotic are not even close (except the fact that they sound similarly) - they are totally different things and when you associate that term with characteristics typical for psychopath you are seriously misleading. I understand that you are not a doctor - if you don't know what the term means that's ok, please just don't use it. To make it hopefully easier to understand why this is so important: imagine that you suffer from severe depression caused by bipolar disorder (which is psychosis, therefore you are psychotic). You might be at the verge of committing suicide and you need help... and than you notice that some people confuse the term psychotic with psychopathic - they think you are a psychopath and they expect inability to empathise, willingness to hurt people etc. - get it? You don't label cancer patients as psychopaths and you should not do it with other illnesses like schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. That's the point - those are illnesses, being a psychopath is not.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gcv 13y agoThe truth about Obama's views has always been right there in his Senate voting record. When he bothered to attend, he consistently voted to do things like extend the Patriot Act.