4 ms·
While I agree with keeping a healthy skepticism of Google, I have a bit of difficulty with this wording: > I think people often forget Google's purpose in the
by vanderZwan 13y ago
While I agree with keeping a healthy skepticism of Google, I have a bit of difficulty with this wording:
> I think people often forget Google's purpose in the world
The fact that Google makes money through showing ads doesn't mean it's their purpose.
- tptacek 13y agoI think it's fair to argue that a company's purpose is best illustrated by its revenue streams. Reasonable people can disagree depending on the circumstances.
- alexsb92 13y agoIn some cases, a company could transcend its initial purpose, but still keep it around as a/the revenue stream as a means to the new end. Not many/any new and further out there Google initiatives have made it to wide scale public adoption, so it's yet unclear whether Google would be such a company, but it could very well turn out to be one.
- sageikosa 13y agoIf it's a publicly traded company, it has a fiduciary responsibility to make money for its investors; so I'd have to agree with you. It's purpose is to make money. It might spend money to buy goodwill to earn loyalty, but at the end of the business day, its a business.
- dspeyer 13y agoGoogle's corporate charter was specifically written to avoid that. And shareholders have no meaningful voting rights, so they can't override it there either.
- pbhjpbhj 13y ago>If it's a publicly traded company, it has a fiduciary responsibility to make money for its investors // Where is this codified?
- sageikosa 13y agoIt doesn't have to be "codified" to be fiduciary. The trust relationship between any investor and the investment enterprise is that the enterprise will be able to generate a return on the investment. If it doesn't assume this, it generally will be deemed a non-profit.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoIf it's not codified then it's more likely an expectation than a responsibility. Of course investors expect a return, that's what the term "investor" entails. Non-pecuniary returns can satisfy the responsibilities of an enterprise. It appeared that a legal obligation was being suggested. What sort of obligation was being suggested and how is that obligation derived and enforced?
- tyre 13y agoNot necessarily the case. Github's revenue stream is through private repositories (both hosted on github.com and self-hosted enterprise), but I don't think you could reasonably assert that Github's purpose is to make a profit off of keeping code private. Their actions, in fact, suggest precisely the opposite.
- regularfry 13y agoTo play devil's advocate, what is Apple's "purpose"? How often has it changed?
- epo 13y agoTheir shareholders would beg to differ.