15 ms·
Basic income vs. Capitalism
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoI wonder what we'd all pay to have garbage hauled away if we didn't have a ready supply of ex-convicts for whom this was one of the higher paying jobs available to them?
- davmre 13y agoGarbage pickup is one of the many jobs that will probably be obseleted by self-driving trucks. So, at least in the medium-term future, we'll likely pay less than we currently do.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoRight, and I could make a living manufacturing those machines if it weren't for slave labor.
- pfisch 13y agoGarbage men make between 20-40k a year. That is not a lot but hardly qualifies as slave labor. If only you could create machines that put all of those people out of a job the world would be a much better place.... http://work.chron.com/national-average-income-garbageman-6642.html http://work.chron.com/national-average-income-garbageman-664...
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoWould you do it for 40k?
- pfisch 13y agoNo but that is not relevant at all. I have a lot of skills and education that open a lot of doors for me. Many people do not have the same kind of options.
- drblast 13y agoThat's a really good question. There are all manner of dirty jobs that people only do because they have no other option except starve or steal. How that differs qualitatively from slavery is beyond me, but I do get the feeling that we aren't paying the "real price" for these services simply because we have plenty of ex-cons in the U.S. and seem happy to keep making more. But aside from that issue, I think a basic income is the only truly fair way to operate a fiat currency. We know a few things for sure, and one of them seems to be that a small amount of inflation is good for an economy. One way to inflate is to print money, and the way we do distribute "new money" in the form of debt is essentially a regressive tax. Much fairer would be to give everyone the same amount in cash form. This system would be so simple it would prevent a lot of the abuses and favoritism of the current system. Imagine if the inflation rate were fixed; say a 2-3% increase in money supply each year, guaranteed, distributed equally among all citizens. It's really hard to game a system like that. And that's probably also why it's not being seriously discussed in political circles. What's the advantage to politicians? Forget "capitalists," this kind of thing is the worst nightmare for everyone who is currently a winner in the current system. If I were to propose to devalue EVERYONE's wealth by 2-3% a year so that I can distribute an equal amount to everyone, I could expect a huge fight from anyone with any accumulated wealth. But as for me, I can't think of a more fair and humane way to operate a system of money.
- dllthomas 13y agoInflation isn't based solely on M0.
- mtrimpe 13y agoFor what it's worth; this comment should be at the top of this story.
- nickik 13y agoPeople would still do those dirty jobs, those jobs would just have to over a higher overall payout then just BI. Services that are largly based on low skilled laber would probebly be more expensive. > But aside from that issue, I think a basic income is the only truly fair way to operate a fiat currency. We know a few things for sure, and one of them seems to be that a small amount of inflation is good for an economy. It is not clear that a small amount of inflation is good for the economy. Also alternative montary transiation mechanism are not really unfair in any meaningful way. Also inflation is driven by expected montary growth, if the central bank has a credible target the would have to do very little or nothing to reach that goal. You can not fiance any goverment programm by montary expention. Exept when you increase the speed of expantion but thats a bad idea. Also giving money directly to people as a montary mechanism has a huge flaw, if you overshoot your targed you can not go back easly. The Central Bank buys and sells bonds/stocks instead of dropping money from airplanes because the must have a way to get money out of the system again. You could of course do that by equally taking from everybody bank account but that is not something goverment should have the power to do. Also having 2/3% inflation does absolutly not mean that everybodys wealth is now 2/3% less. I would really, really suggest to to first understand some montary theory befor you come up with your own montary system, its harder then you might think.
- hooande 13y agoIn reality garbage men make more money than any basic income would pay. The misconception is that a BI would cause no one to work because they were too busy driving ferrais and eating cuisine with their government money. But we're talking about a basic income here. Any job that pays more than the minimum will make someone seem wealthy when compared to the average person. Any one with a job, even a janitor, would have more money to throw around than most people. Ex-cons in particular will be in a much better situation as far as we're concerned. There's no constant stress of being expected to find a job in a society that doesn't want to hire them. More importantly, there's less incentive to steal from one of us if criminals have an easy backup plan. People won't have to fake disability or become welfare mothers either, saving society a lot of money. There are always unintended consequences, but 100% of them aren't bad. A BI will save a lot of money just by eliminating some of the perverse incentives of the current system. It won't necessarily destroy the work incentive either. As the OP pointed out, we'd get a situation where the only people who apply for a job are people who really want them. A government income doesn't destroy natural talent, interest or ability. We could end up putting ourselves into a situation where jobs are things people enjoy moreso than we do today.
- _delirium 13y agoOne only need look at Germany to refute the strange claim that a basic income would cause nobody to work. It is basically impossible to fall out of the lowest bracket of the German welfare system (~€350/mo for a childless single person, higher if you have kids), and yet Germany has high labor-force participation. There is probably some level of income at which it would be true. If Germans got €5,000/mo, labor-force participation might be lower. But that is not what people are advocating.
- steveklabnik 13y agoI will say that 'vs' isn't strictly needed here; no reason the means of production can't be privately owned while BI is implemented. Now, that would put a bit of hurt into the reserve army of labor, as the article mentions...
- blake8086 13y agoI suspect that basic income is a stable equilibrium given a "one person, one vote"-type of democratic system. It's in each person's best interests to vote for more wealth redistribution if they're below the average, and there will always be more people below the average than above. Further, it's in each politician's interest to both promise and deliver such a thing, as it helps them win first and following elections.
- stdbrouw 13y agoBut it's also very easy to convince virtually anyone that they're a part of the hardworking middle class that's keeping this country afloat, as opposed to those leeches that would use their basic income to hang around and do nothing.
- runawaybottle 13y agoWhat middle class? The fact that we're discussing an across the board baseline income is indicative of the state of the "middleclass". What a disaster, hate to be so melodramatic. Those leeches are the least of our worries.
- cinquemb 13y agoWhen the word "leeches" is directed toward people at the "bottom", it makes me wonder what people think of when money is created out of thin air, lended to banks at ZIRP and who then lend to people at anything but, who then use such money (or credit) to buy goods (created by their peers) that people at the helm of such institutions like banks can also buy…
- hkmurakami 13y agonot to mention industries whose profits are generated solely on the basis of tariffs and subsidies (various areas of industrial farming: corn, sugar, etc)
- straight_talk 13y ago
- brownbat 13y ago> capitalists, who want a large labour supply... Even Friedman argued for the NIT, noting it was less paternalistic than food stamps or other benefits to simply let the poor allocate their money however they see fit (and simple transfers would likely lead to lower administrative costs). But this implicit line that there's a secret cabal of "capitalists" all persuaded by some idea that they never publicly proselytize, but all coordinate action in order to pursue... it sounds a bit conspiratorial. Cribbing lines from marxist economic theory, it's going to alienate half your audience or more, and immediately make the argument deeply partisan, when it needn't be. I mean, believe that line or not, but I think the argument is stronger without falling down the rabbit hole of pretending to know what "the capitalists" are up to.
- yk 13y ago> But this implicit line that there's a secret cabal of "capitalists" all persuaded by some idea that they never publicly proselytize, [...] The way the Marxist argument for class interest works, is that there does not need to be a secret cabal. To discuss this in the context of basic income (BI): Some capitalists, that is some owners of capital, depend on cheap unskilled labor. Each of them concludes independently, that a BI is against his own interests, since it would reduce the incentive to take unpleasant jobs and force them to pay their workers more. Or more generally, some people have similar interests, not because they conspire, but because they are in a similar socio-economic situation. And this socio-economic situation generates class interests. ( Marx then goes on to argue, that the capitalist class can more easily leverage its interests, and therefore the workers need class conscious to counter this leverage.)
- derleth 13y ago> Marx then goes on to argue, that the capitalist class can more easily leverage its interests, and therefore the workers need class conscious to counter this leverage. And anyone who disagrees with Marx on hearing his ideas is suffering from False Consciousness and needs to be Re-Educated, perhaps in a Camp somewhere.
- 13y ago
- od2m 13y agoSo sick of non-economists advocating economic policy which they don't understand. Welfare programs of any type are only viable when the ratio of payers to payee's is high. They're desirable at this level. However, entitling every citizen to money which for he does not have to work for exposes the government to UNLIMITED liability as humans are free to create more humans at any time they choose. We cannot expand the GDP any time we would like, in fact paying people not to work removes the excess value of their labor from the GDP (assuming there was a job for them). When you total up Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid debts the United States is completely broke. Something on the order of 100 trillion dollars of future liabilities. We can't even afford our modest socialism we have now. TLDR? The numbers don't work.
- fleitz 13y ago'basic income' or 'negative income tax' is an idea supported by Milton Friedman, who is generally regarded as a knowledgable economist of the Chicago school and a critic of many aspects of the Keynesian welfare state. You may know Milton Friedman from such economic ideas as 'fiat currency' which has been the dominant monetary policy globally for the last 40 years. Since non-economists should not be critiquing economic policy according to you, may I ask what your credentials are in this field? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_income_tax
- nickik 13y agoNIT and BI are to diffrent things but with simular spirit. Make it rule based, simple to administer and most importently keep to the principle, if you work you get more money.
- argonaut 13y agoUhh.... fiat currency is not monetary policy. You meant monetarism, which has most certainly not been the dominant monetary policy for the last 40 years. It's been influential, yes. There have been periods of time in which it has been in vogue, yes, but you certainly cannot call it the dominant monetary policy globally for the last 40 years..
- mwc 13y agoThe New Zealand Treasury has conducted a preliminary assessment of a guaranteed minimum income (GMI) in New Zealand[1]. It's worth a read. It's conclusions were broadly: * To be cost neutral, it would require a significant increase in taxation rates (to a flat tax of ~45% - 50%). * Although the Gini coefficient is improved, those who currently receive government support would likely receive less under a GMI scheme, which may have the effect of distributing more money away from those most in need. A brief discussion of the "broad ranging" effects on efficiency and economic growth is also included. [1] http://igps.victoria.ac.nz/WelfareWorkingGroup/Downloads/Working%20papers/Treasury-A-Guaranteed-Minimum-Income-for-New-Zealand%20.PDF http://igps.victoria.ac.nz/WelfareWorkingGroup/Downloads/Wor...
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoHmmm. I am beginning to believe any author who writes essays with the word "capitalism" in it neither understands capitalism or is able to work with the concept in the abstract. Usually it's just regurgitated Marxist leftovers. And let's see what we have: "A BI breaks with a fundamental principle of the welfare state. This, wrote Beveridge in 1942, is "to make and keep men fit for service.*" One function of the welfare state is to ensure that capital gets a big supply of labour, by making eligibity for unemployment benefit conditional upon seeking work. BI, however, breaks this principle.In its pure form, it allows folk to laze on the beach all day." Okey dokey now. The welfare state is a product of the voters, not the result of one particular report in the 1940s in the United Kingdom. I can quite assure you that the voters were not interested in "providing labour to capital". They were interested in being compassionate to their fellow man, just as they were in the States. The welfare state is a lot bigger than wartime England. If anything, the modern welfare nation has its roots in the late Victorian period, as large groups of people realized that they were being significantly mistreated by the system. This is an important point, because if you miss it you miss the rest of it. The social safety net, as most voters understand it, is to provide a lift up to those in need, and some sort of permanent assistance to those who are incapable of leaving their present circumstances. This means that any welfare state has as its primary mission the determination of the difference between those who are temporarily downtrodden and those who will not work, either because of physical or attitudinal reasons. Voters feel differently about these different groups of people. Therefore the policies towards them are different. "capitalists, who want a large labour supply" -- no, capitalists want to trade stuff. Sometimes, like in the 1800s, this required a large labour supply busy as beavers in the sweat shop making widgets. Sometimes nowadays it might involve really expensive robots and 5 laborers. Or 3 web programmers and some space on AWS. These old ideas of capital and labor are dead. Please let them rest in peace without digging them up so often. Minimum wages and basic income policies all do the same thing -- raise the floor at which most folks can enter into productive trade with others. This raises prices and increases unemployment. These kinds of ideas sound great. Who wouldn't want $25 per hour wages and guaranteed income for all? But all you'd end up with is $15 hamburgers and $34 gasoline. You don't do anything but raise the table stakes for people, like certain homeless, just don't want to participate in society. It increases poverty and suffering. Counter-intuitively, it does not make things better. People need to pay special attention to those ideas which produce an emotional gut-feeling of "hell yeah! Why haven't we done that?" There's usually a really good reason that does not involve economic theories from the 1890s.
- rogerthis 13y agoAFAIK, the biggest experiment in Basic Income is happening in Brazil. Come and ask us in 2030 how it did go. Today, all I can say is it serves the politicians in power to keep their power. People who receive state BI seldom vote different, afraid of losing the benefit.
- emiliobumachar 13y agoWhat's happening in Brazil is not BI because it's not for everyone. Recipients have to prove they are poor enough (at least state that they are)
- gw 13y agoMurray Rothbard called this "probably the single most disasterous economic idea ever invented". He spoke on this topic during a speech on Milton Friedman. It's worth a listen. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AenYS193mSI&t=10m34s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AenYS193mSI&t=10m34s
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mikeyouse 13y agoI'm all for differing viewpoints, but prospective watchers should know that Murray Rothbard considered Adam Smith an anti-capitalist proto-Marxist. He also had some very 'interesting' views on women's liberation, race, homosexuality, slavery, etc. etc.
- gw 13y agoReally an odd way to show you are for differing viewpoints, to inoculate "prospective watchers" by opening the floodgates to a host of disparate subjects that have nothing to do with the topic at hand, all the while winking and nudging that he is a bigot regarding said subjects.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gw 13y agoSo you understand my critique, and then proceed to bring up yet more unrelated subjects, referencing individuals at random who have nothing in common with the one we're discussing. I don't think you really understand my critique.
- pg 13y agoYou know, guys, I don't think you're likely to reach any sort of consensus or learn anything from one another. So you may as well stop now.
- michaelochurch 13y agoHere's how I see the BI debate. The argument made against it is that it would generate a class of parasites at the bottom of society. We, right now, have a permanent parasite class at the top of society and that's worse. They can treat labor like shit because labor has no other option, and this surplus generated by desperation makes those at the top extraordinarily rich. BI is the only solution I can come up with that makes sure labor is respected. However, any BI program should be tied to per capita GDP. Thus, if it actually does have a negative effect on society (which I doubt it will) the payments drop and reverse that effect.
- johnohara 13y agoLast week Breitbart threw a number of 144,000,000 as the current number of working adults in the United States. It sounded about right. Let's use 150,000,000 instead and pay them a basic income of $20,800 per yr ($400 per wk, $10 per hr). That's $3.120T with a "T", just south of scheduled 2013 U.S. federal expenditures of $3.803T -- with a $900B deficit. A BI would double federal expenditures. Honestly, how likely is it for a guaranteed basic income to pass both houses of Congress and be signed by the POTUS in the next 5, 10, or 25 years?
- MartinCron 13y agoWouldn't basic income replace many of the means-tested assistance programs? There's cost savings not being accounted for.
- rattray 13y agoThat's a pretty unfair straw man. One of the most oft-cited "points" of BI is the savings related to cutting tax breaks and social programs. I'm not well-versed with the numbers, but I've heard these are pretty high. In addition, "higher taxes for those with above-middle-class incomes" to balance out the expenditure is an almost universally quoted corollary of BI. Citing the cost of BI without the obviously necessary offsets isn't constructive.
- Millennium 13y agoNot double, actually, because part of the point of a basic income is to replace much of what we currently think of as welfare. For example, Social Security as we know it could simply vanish, its function completely replaced by the basic income. In theory, salaries for government employees of all types could also be reduced by an amount equal to the basic income, leading to no change in take-home pay but saving money within the programs which employ them. Nevertheless, as you point out, it would necessarily represent a massive expansion in federal spending: on the order of 50% or more.
- pyoung 13y agoAn alternative implementation, mentioned elsewhere in the thread, would be a negative income tax (NIT). This would work by establishing a 'baseline' wage, and if someone is below that baseline, they are subject to a negative tax (i.e. they receive money from the government). This would probably be a much cheaper method of establishing a BI, as only those with low or no wages would receive the benefit, but would also allow for massive reductions in welfare programs. Something to consider.
- kephra 13y agoI'm a programmer. My job is to free people from work, for more then 35 years. An unconditional/basic/universal income or negative tax would allow those people to enjoy the freedom I provided for them, while unemployment is a shame in current system. Its interesting to notice that those who promote a basic income here in Germany are hardcore liberals/libertarians, while conservatives, socialists, unions, communists here still follow the puritanic thinking that "Arbeit macht Frei".
- rokhayakebe 13y agoYour job was never intended to free people from work. It was simply to do what people did, faster, more accurately, and many times over. If your code was slower and more expensive than someone doing the work manually, you would doing another job. I think.
- kephra 13y agoMy current focus is on machine learning for industrial application. 15 years ago my main focus was the paperless office. And before that common office automation. Its true, that not every coder is freeing people from work. But in average we destroy stupid jobs, and replace them with smart machines. Those jobs will never come back. The only kind of work that will be left are social work, that is currently badly payed. The result is that there will less demand for work, the wages will sink to the botton, nobody would be able to buy things, and capitalism will destroy itself. The only way to avoid a communist slave state is an universal income.
- kenster07 13y agoThis is just describes another transitional point in human history. In any given year, we can produce the same output with less labor. As this effect compounds, take this pattern to its extreme -- producing all the output the world could ever need with virtually no human labor. In such a scenario, what is the meaning of a wage? What does it mean for a person to produce "value?" How would humanity, whose genome has been shaped under the chisel of scarcity, adapt to a system where such a thing did not exist? In this thought experiment, I believe it becomes evident that the laws of economics, as we understand them, are NOT timeless. Modern economics has gone on a tangent, creating a system of analysis and theory that only works for this microcosm in our existence. It is only as our economy approaches the scenario described above that the true laws of human economics can become evident.
- userulluipeste 13y agoNot every part of human labor/involvement will be totally replaced (if your imagination needs a hint, think about the oldest occupation if the world). There are services that rely on human interaction and as the world evolves the demand for such specific social-involved activities will continuously diversify itself. I also think that the access to the limited resources (think of space if nothing else) will always maintain in a way or another a scarcity-based system.
- kenster07 13y agoYou never know. I think the frailty of the human ego is more likely to manufacture scarcity than anything else.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoWhy doesn't this article discuss the repercussions of such a plan? These ideas of "helping everyone and feeling good" fail to understand human behavior. Basic income would reek havoc on the real estate market as people (of the trashy uncivilized variety) would try to move into nice neighborhoods with their new funds that they didn't work for and earn and "fuck up the neighborhood" basically.(This already occurs with section 8 housing) Another consequence is that rent and housing would rise substantially. The price of a home isn't just determined by the value of the home itself but by the highest price the local market can afford to pay. People who are not in real estate don't understand this. The flawed assumption to this plan is that all or most poor people are poor because they just haven't been given enough chances or nice things. This emotional ideology usually belongs to young collage students who have never worked with the public and seen the real asshole-ery and primitive baboon-ism of humanity and believe everyone is a nice person. Or adults who grew up in their parent's nice neighborhood miles away from reality. I know you're going to think I'm the biggest most evil asshole in the world but after working with the public (everyone in my family does) NOT a cool startup in a collage town I have to tell you the truth: Quite a few poor people (not all of course) are poor for a reason. Sitting down and talking with them will usually give away these reasons immediately. They don't bring value, they can't hold jobs because they have poor impulse control, they're short term decision makers, they don't want to educate or better themselves, they're hyper-sexual, were born with a lower IQ, they can't commit to jobs they do have, they smoke pot like crazy. Basically they don't have nice things for a reason. And every time you try to give them nice things they ruin them and don't appreciate them. I used to be one of those "help everyone and make the world happy and good feelings and gosh I just wish we could all hold hands". I have completely left that ideology as it's a fantasy. A lie. These smart intellectual folks with ideas on how to help the poor completely forget to include the above mentioned human problems. All they see is numbers and an equation and they want to balance it all out on the table. But it never works like that in real life. I know during this recession a lot of people who deserve nice things have had them taken away, but any attempts to correct this through government, welfare, and basic income is just going to go in the wrong hands. There are devastating repercussions for paying people to do nothing or giving people something they haven't earned. Let's stop chasing pipe-dreams because they "sound nice". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruitt%E2%80%93Igoe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruitt%E2%80%93Igoe
- EGreg 13y agoActually BI is gradually coming in the form of social safety nets for everyone. Once we disrupt college education with courses anyone can study at home at their own pace from the best professors, lots more people will be able to educate themselves for the new economy. That said, there will be a growing unemployed class, and many are are already perpetually on government subsidized programs such as housing, etc. The question of whether this is worse than a negative tax is unclear. What IS clear is that capitalists will want people to remain consumers, even as they automate everything. So redistributing money to them by taxing the machines is inevitable. The real question for me is, what will happen to all the restless, disaffected people whose services are no longer required, and whose blogs are rarely read? Especially men. http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=97 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=97