11 ms·
The Jobless Rate for Poor Black Teen Dropouts is 95%
- ukoto 13y agoJobs are racist.
- npc 13y agoNo, just the people who decide who gets them: http://www.nber.org/papers/w9873 http://www.nber.org/papers/w9873
- bmmayer1 13y agoDidn't Steve Levitt prove this wrong?
- npc 13y agoI don't know, did he? Here's some more if that didn't convince you (courtesy of Tim Wise: http://www.timwise.org/2010/07/black-powers-gonna-git-you-sucka-right-wing-paranoia-and-the-rhetoric-of-modern-racism/ http://www.timwise.org/2010/07/black-powers-gonna-git-you-su...) http://www.princeton.edu/~pager/race_at_work.pdf http://www.princeton.edu/~pager/race_at_work.pdf http://www.eeo1.com/1999_NR/Title.pdf http://www.eeo1.com/1999_NR/Title.pdf http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/01/us/01race.html?_r=2 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/01/us/01race.html?_r=2
- coldtea 13y agoIf you are an economist (a field is already more an ideology / spin machine than science -- the science part in it is basically math), and you are more into entertainment (e.g making the NYT best selling list of shallow books) than science, then you can "prove" a lot of things, without actually proving anything. Start with a few unexamined wrong assumptions, select the data that fit your conclusion, dress them up with anecdotes and prose, and there you go!
- kansface 13y agoThis may be the case, but what should the job prospects for teenagers who just dropped out of high school be ideally?
- runawaybottle 13y agoA minimum wage job?
- jlgreco 13y agoAn unconditional basic income is probably a better way to go than a guaranteed minimum wage job. (Of course you could set the basic income at whatever a minimum wage job would provide.)
- kansface 13y agoOffering money to drop out of high school would cause the drop out rate to increase further. Besides, I get the feeling that most high school drop outs aren't really looking for work. This is a hard problem to solve.
- jlgreco 13y agoThe money would be unconditional, not in exchange for dropping out of high school. You may as well say that soup kitchens are offering soup to drop out of high school and are causing the drop out rate to increase further.
- kansface 13y agoAh, so anyone say 14 or older gets X/year? Any thoughts on what X would be. I assume this would supplant welfare to some degree?
- jlgreco 13y agoYes, though most proposals start at 18 I believe. It has some advantages over more traditional welfare systems. For instance it could be implemented with far less bureaucracy and would help improve labor mobility in the middle class by decreasing the friction of changing jobs and moving to different areas with better jobs (improving labor mobility would benefit the economy at large).
- bmmayer1 13y agoMinimum wage law.
- jlgreco 13y agoPerhaps the labor law exceptions for farming jobs explain some of the geographic discrepancy. When I was a teenager for a time I was (legally) employed below standard minimum wage working as a farm laborer.
- bmmayer1 13y agoInteresting point. Also, black youths overwhelmingly live in urban areas where labor laws are more strictly enforced.
- jussij 13y agoIf minimum wage law was such a determining factor why is it countries with a higher minimum wages than the USA have lower (including youth) unemployment rates. I'll give you my take on this. What creates employment is consumption and people earning next to nothing don’t consume. So if you cut the minimum wage all you'll end up doing is reduce the overall consumption, which in turn will drive up unemployment. The truth might in fact be the reason the USA economy is so stuffed is because the minimum wage has not gone up in decades leading to greatly reduced levels of consumption.
- bmmayer1 13y agoThe countries with the highest minimum wages are the democratic socialist states of Europe which all have much higher youth unemployment rates than here. One of the lowest youth unemployment rates in Europe is Germany, which has no minimum wage law.
- jussij 13y agoHere in Australia we have a minimum wage twice that of the USA and our unemplyment is 5.6 percent.
- jlgreco 13y agoSo all those factors, when you combine them and take a young black high school dropout, low-income male, you're talking 5 percent employment. Paul Solman: 5 percent? Andrew Sum: Yes. Paul Solman: 95 percent unemployment rate? Andrew Sum: Jobless. Not all of them would be classified as [unemployed], but they're not working. In other words, you could just say, "I gave up looking for work," which a lot of them do, but only 5 percent are working. Yes, 5 percent. Another factor is geography. Last year, in the summer in [Washington,] D.C., only 15 percent of the kids worked; California, only 20 percent; Arizona and large parts of the south, 20 percent. Yet in Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Iowa, Nebraska, you had 50 percent to 55 percent of those kids working. This part is unclear to me. Is the "those kids" in the last section (about the geographic factor) still referring to the "young black highschool dropouts", or to a more general group again?
- recuter 13y agoThere are fewer young black people in Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, Iowa, Nebraska which happen to have higher youth employment rates. So that partially accounts for it. But still, 95 percent..
- jlgreco 13y agoYeah, black youth unemployment rates in those states won't have much influence since the black population in those states is much smaller. However if black youth unemployment rates in those states is better than the national rates (it is unclear if the article is claiming this or not), then it is probably worth looking into what these states are doing that makes this the case.
- ritchiea 13y agoCompetition is much higher in urban areas. There are more black families in urban areas and thus there are more black dropouts while simultaneously urban areas have become hip destinations for college graduates. I know 20-somethings in NYC with liberal arts and art degrees that still work in retail or food services. And even many of my friends who no longer perform jobs like that did for several months to over a year while they sought out other work. I don't think this is as much of a phenomenon in Montana, the Dakotas and Iowa because they don't have a high rate of 20-somethings entering the workforce from other parts of the country.
- mjfl 13y agoWhat jobs are you going to give them? Cashiers these days have Bachelors degrees in Communications. It's the inflation in the system. America is not producing as many factories as it used to, manual labor jobs in construction are hard enough to get. If you drop out, it's going to be tough to get a job.
- ne0codex 13y agoExactly. Shouldn't this be used as incentive for parents and families within those communities to promote school attendance and encourage academic performance?
- icelancer 13y agoOr shouldn't it be used to promote alternative methods of education that are accepted by many employers? STEM fields by and large are the most friendly towards alternative (or complete lack of) education. A well-manicured GitHub, a decent resume, and not looking like an idiot in an interview trumps most college degrees for mid-level developer jobs that aren't Facebook/Google/etc.
- phaus 13y agoIf you have a good resume but no degree, that almost certainly means you have job experience. Of course actual experience trumps a college degree, that's why its so hard for new graduates to get a job. I know things are going well on the west coast, but around the DC/MD/VA area most companies are asking for 3-5 years of 40 hour/week experience, a TS clearance with a polygraph, and a B.S. in Computer Science for entry level jobs. They are called entry-level positions simply because they plan on paying you 40-50k even with the ridiculous requirements.
- frankydp 13y agoThat employment environment around DC is insane. The time-tables that the government operates on would prevent almost any jobless applicant from chasing a job. When I got out of the Marine Corps year before last, I of course applied for many government contracting jobs within my field. Of the 30-40 jobs I applied for that specifically required my unique skill set, I received request for interviews from 25. I applied for these jobs in September, and received the first follow up contact from the employers in July of the following year. Keeping in mind that I have 10 years experience in a very specialized field with a TS/POLY, and extremely high demand for my skill set. Not sure what I am trying to point out except that government job creation would takes years to actually affect change on unemployment numbers. On a side note, I did find a job with a startup, but that was because of a chance encounter while trolling the right bars every night for 3 weeks looking for that chance. Smiles and handshakes always trump resumes.
- quaunaut 13y agoHonest question: Have we, as a society, looked into possibly supplying people with short-term loans, with a guaranteed open position for someone at a place in more rural parts of America? Originally, I was born in Fresno, CA. We didn't have the most healthy job rate when times were good, let alone once the recession hit. I spent five years looking for a job- and didn't find one until I got the help of a friend online in Claremore, Oklahoma, who let me move in. In a month I was working at an auto parts store, even though I knew jack shit about cars. I was making enough that I could've survived with that job. I'd be poor, I couldn't go to college, but I could survive. I was lucky enough that I had a nice computer I'd gotten from when there was a windfall in the family, and I'd taught myself to program enough Python and Django to get a webdev job remotely. But even if I hadn't, I could've survived on this. Getting me out there cost a grand total of perhaps ~$1500, at most, and that'd get me my first month's rent. Tack on another $1000 and I'd have 3 months rent total and enough leftover to get a cheap bed. Is this economically feasible? Would it even provide good economic value? People are needed in these rural areas, but I just don't know if it'd provide enough economic reward to actually be worth it to the country.
- rorrr2 13y agoYou had a computer, and it took you five years to find A job? I find that hard to believe.
- sjtgraham 13y agoShit Hacker News says
- deadairspace 13y agoSadly they stopped tweeting in April. https://twitter.com/shit_hn_says https://twitter.com/shit_hn_says
- jmillikin 13y agohttps://plus.google.com/117962930156930191118/posts https://plus.google.com/117962930156930191118/posts
- readme 13y agoThe 5% who actually have jobs are probably programmers.
- jedanbik 13y agoAre you just saying that, or are you just saying that?
- incision 13y agoAs I've mentioned on HN before, I dropped out of high school and found my into a job in technology by way of a GED, public libraries and work as a landscaper, in the DC area coincidentally. Everything mentioned in this article rings to true me. The transition traditional low-end jobs to middle-aged people and closed-circle of internships and job programs in particular. That said, the first step towards mitigating this would seem obvious - stay in school. Unfortunately, anecdotal experience says the particularly bad situation for young black teens starts with a general de-valuing of education and victim mentality at home.
- bilbo0s 13y agoWell... We shouldn't engage in wishful thinking either. Even if they graduate high school, the unemployment rate that awaits them is still pretty dismal. I believe the employment/population ratio for young black males "increased" to 33% for high school graduates... Only the Bureau of Labor Statistics doesn't count incarcerated people in that ratio. So if you throw in that 1 in 9 young black males who are incarcerated, (I know it's higher, but 1 in 9 is the rate for high school graduates), you can see pretty clearly that even with a high school diploma they barely crack a 20% employment/population ratio. And that's actually being pretty generous with the numbers. Of course, 20% - 25% is a better chance than 5%, so it's TECHNICALLY better to have a high school diploma... But since the unemployment rate for whites with no high school diploma hoovers around 12%... it's actually MUCH better just to be white, than it is to graduate high school. For blacks, especially males, I think the only way education really helps them in a material fashion, is if they can manage to graduate college.
- incision 13y ago>We shouldn't engage in wishful thinking either. Of course not. That's why I refer to staying in school as a "first step" as opposed to a solution. >But since the unemployment rate for whites with no high school diploma hoovers around 12%... it's actually MUCH better just to be white, than it is to graduate high school. I'd expect it's even better to be born rich and well-connected. Equality and the distribution of wealth and influence are important topics, but they're the last thing anyone who's actively struggling should be concerned with. >For blacks, especially males, I think the only way education really helps them in a material fashion, is if they can manage to graduate college. Both the statistics you provided and my experience disagree with this notion.
- WhoIsSatoshi 13y agoI see a lot of peripheral discussion - But what do you think about the article? As an investor, I see the proposed solution as very interesting. I feel as though there is no reason that the funding effort cannot be entirely crowdsourced for a company trying to raise funds.
- peripheralFix 13y agoI have a pointed question for you: As an investor, how many of these dropouts would you like to hire at one of your startups tomorrow morning? I don't really understand which solution you're pointing out as a candidate for crowdsourcing. Microloans are as much of a solution as pawn shops, to be brutally honest.
- hooande 13y agoThis seems like another argument for Basic Income. A lot of young, jobless people (males especially) isn't only a moral problem, but it's a sociological problem. The young jobless commit more crimes, are more likely to join gangs and are generally more of a drain on society. Giving them an income would remove the social pressure to constantly look for jobs that aren't actually there. People could focus on internships and other productive activities without having to resort to selling drugs to make a living. Short of full on Basic Income, we could at least continue a much larger version of the government teen jobs program mentioned in the article. Money given to low income youth tends to find it's way back into the economy quickly. Much of the money from a government jobs program would be spent at the mall or walmart, some of which would end up in the hands of vendors and suppliers, which could get spent on apps and web services run by hn users. In short, poor people don't save a lot. Some percentage of our tax money will come back to us. Capitalism is a great system, but it isn't perfect. The best predictor of future income is parental income. Direct action is the best way to break the cycle.
- Jayschwa 13y ago> This seems like another argument for Basic Income. Or another argument against minimum wage. Minimum wage gets increased as cost-of-living goes up (albeit with a large lag). That's good if you're the household bread-winner trying to live off a minimum wage job. It's bad if you're a kid looking for some spending money. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
- dllthomas 13y ago> > This seems like another argument for Basic Income. > Or another argument against minimum wage. How about both?
- MartinCron 13y agoAbsolutely, BI would make minimum wage obsolete, allowing for a much more flexible labor market without people on the edge of starvation.
- 13y ago
- nhebb 13y ago> The sad thing is that since the nation began to add jobs in 2009, we've created about 5.2 million additional jobs for America's workers. Teenagers in the aggregate received none of them. Not one. This is the kind of Washington, DC b.s. that gets regurgitated in the news. If you look at the U6 unemployment rate, the net impact has been a huge upturn in total unemployment: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/U6RATE http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/U6RATE
- ErikAugust 13y ago"High school students working today work at less than a 50 percent rate to what they did back in 2000. Like in our state here in Massachusetts, 45 percent of our high school students worked in 2000. Last year it was 15 percent: 45 to 15 percent." I had a couple jobs - as a high schooler in Massachusetts in 2000. I learned a lot of job/life skills from those jobs...
- Jayschwa 13y agoDitto. I learned that I didn't want to scrub toilets for the rest of my life!
- ErikAugust 13y agoHa, yes - I learned that as well, among other things.
- bluedino 13y agoWhere are the young black kids in tech? Blacks of any age are sorely under-represented in tech. So are Latinos, although not quite as bad. It's a very white (and Asian/Indian) world we live in. I'm so glad to see things like Black Girls Code. These kids need mentors that aren't sports stars, or music stars. Oddly enough, music is one industry I always remember running into a lot of black people in - Macs and ProTools used in music production.
- w1ntermute 13y ago> Oddly enough, music is one industry I always remember running into a lot of black people in - Macs and ProTools used in music production. That's not odd at all. Blacks are hugely overrepresented in the music industry (as well as the pro sports industry). You gotta love how American society is always collectively wringing its hands about how there aren't enough black people in STEM, but nobody mentions how underrepresented Asians are in the entertainment and pro sports industries.
- MartinCron 13y agoThe entertainment and pro sports industries are so small that they hardly matter in terms of actual employment.
- agilebyte 13y agoThey matter because they represent a big win for a select few and people feeling they do not have many choices will discount the "few" and invest all their eggs into those two baskets and most often than not fail.
- vacri 13y agoBlacks are something like 12% of the US population, so around 35 million people. Pro football has around 80 men on the roster (more than any other sport), and 32 teams (again, on the high side), so you're looking at less than 3000 athletes employed by that one sport. Even if all the athletes were black, which they're not, that number is less than one in a thousand of the total population. 'There are jobs for blacks in pro sports' is a complete canard that needs to be abandoned.