7 ms·
The bridges are in the same location, but they are not the same bridge. One references location ('the bridge that crosses the river over there'), the other per
by adventured 13y ago
The bridges are in the same location, but they are not the same bridge.
One references location ('the bridge that crosses the river over there'), the other pertains to the physical composition that makes every thing unique (the bridge made of those specific fibers).
It'd be like claiming the different people that inhabit the same house over the span of 100 years are all the same people, because they're all humans. They're all people, and they all inhabited the house ('the people in that house'), but they in fact possess different unique identity.
- knome 13y agoThe person metaphor works if you consider the purpose instead of the individual. There has been a mayor of New York since the mid 1600s, though the individual fulfilling that role has changed regularly. Similarly, there has been a bridge on this stretch of gorge for some time, though the expanse must be replaced regularly.
- mc32 13y agoYes, but the 'bridge,' in this case, is more akin to the mayor not the mayorship. It's more like a house blown over in a hurricane. It gets rebuilt, but the land and foundation and some other infrastructure might be re-used --it's still not the 'old house' --it's the re-built house.
- crygin 13y agoThis is like the Platonic HN comment. Person hears about an interesting problem in another field (yeah, the ship of Theseus is actually interesting. That's why people still discuss it), asserts the solution after having thought about it for two minutes, then provides a useless analogy. Good work, you solved the problem! All those philosophers can quit their adjunct professorships and go bootstrap some social web companies now.
- Avshalom 13y ago...no, the point was that it wasn't a ship of theseus situation.
- JonnieCache 13y agohttp://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=1879 http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=1879
- reeses 13y agoIronically, the same people complain about the Microsoft-style interview questions that require lateral thinking. "How many gas stations are there in _your city_?" "How would you determine how much rain falls in Washington State in a day?"
- nitid_name 13y ago>It'd be like claiming the different people that inhabit the same house over the span of 100 years are all the same people, because they're all humans. They're all people, and they all inhabited the house ('the people in that house'), but they in fact possess different unique identity. If it was the same family or if they shared a few genetic markers that distinguished them from other peoples in the area... then you could say the same people had lived at ________ area.