10 ms·
Dwarf Fortress in 2013
- boneheadmed 13y agoI've been reading articles about this fascinating game for several days now, but haven't had the guts to invest the time into it given its steep learning curve. Kudos to these guys for doing exactly what they want to do and (yet) still making a living by coding.
- thejosh 13y agoIt's best to stay away until you have a chunk of time, because it sucks you in so much..
- sage_joch 13y agoEver since I read the NY Times article posted here a couple years ago (see below), I have had a similar response. I love reading about Dwarf Fortress, but I'm hesitant to actually try it. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/24/magazine/the-brilliance-of-dwarf-fortress.html?pagewanted=all* http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/24/magazine/the-brilliance-of...
- exDM69 13y agoYou guys should just try the game. There have been a few articles that highlight the difficulty of the game but that is only in comparison to modern console games targeted at soda guzzling teens with a one second attention span. You can grok the basics of the game in an hour or so by following a beginner tutorial. During your first few hours you will fail your first few fortresses. After your first session, you should have a grasp of things and the next time you should be able to just pick up the game and get back to it. I think the time suck aspect of this game is exaggerated a lot. You can pause and save the game at any point and get back to it later. There's one thing that some of the tutorials and introductions don't make clear: you control the fortress, not the individual dwarfs.
- axefrog 13y ago"There have been a few articles that highlight the difficulty of the game but that is only in comparison to modern console games targeted at soda guzzling teens with a one second attention span" No. Your assertion is that the only likely improvement to the UI would be a simple gamepad-mashing interface. DF is difficult even compared to programs with a complicated UI and games with a "normal" steep learning curve. Not wanting to battle through an insane UI does not equate one to a "soda guzzling teen".
- fleshgolem 13y agoCompletely agree. Dwarf Therapist kinda shows how you can improve the UI without dumbing the game in itself down
- boomlinde 13y agoNo, his assertion wasn't that the only likely improvement to the UI would be a simple gamepad-mashing interface. And nowhere was is implied that not wanting to battle through an insane UI does not equate one to a "soda guzzling teen".
- smacktoward 13y agoSeriously. I play and love the grand strategy games Paradox Interactive makes (Crusader Kings, Europa Universalis, Victoria, etc.), and those are some pretty complicated, hard-to-get-into games. And yet even I look at Dwarf Fortress and think "man, that's impossible."
- James_Duval 13y agoWell - you CAN order your dwarves around. It's just ludicrously complex. You can also manipulate world-gen so you have an easier time of it (making the game essentially Harvest Moon with occasional killer fish), but where's the fun in that?
- StevenRayOrr 13y agoAs someone who played far too much emulator Harvest Moon, I think you are selling short the prospect of such a game + occasional killer fish.
- imdsm 13y agoYou guys should try it. Get the LazyNewbPack, that is a windows bundle which comes with a few utils, tilesets etc. Check out the wiki (http://dwarffortresswiki.org/ http://dwarffortresswiki.org/), it's the best website on the internet. If you're still stuck, visit the df subreddit and ask for help, the people there are pretty awesome (http://www.reddit.com/r/dwarffortress http://www.reddit.com/r/dwarffortress). It takes some getting into, but once you're in, you're in.
- cpeterso 13y agoIf you are just curious about the game, there are many "Let's Play Dwarf Fortress" videos on YouTube. Expert players talk through the game features and progression.
- sgrove 13y agoAny recommendations for non-players looking to get sucked into whatever it is that makes it so intriguing?
- exDM69 13y agoUnfortunately, I don't think that Dwarf Fortress is a game that is enjoyable if you just look at someone else playing it. There's too much little stuff going on in the screen to figure out what the big stuff is and the pace of the game can be slow. There are a few good video tutorials, though. Just try the game. edit: there are some tools you can use to visualize your dungeons and what is going on there. There might be nice videos of some 3d-renderings of fortresses that might be nice to give you an idea of the game.
- cobrophy 13y agoI like Captain Duck who has a bunch of tutorials and Lets Plays along with a soothing Dutch accent. http://www.youtube.com/user/captnduck http://www.youtube.com/user/captnduck To get a great flavour of dwarf fortress in a longer written form. You can't go wrong with boatmurdered, which is a game where each player took a year (I think) of playing the fortress and then handed on to the next player to pick up the pieces and carry on. http://lparchive.org/Dwarf-Fortress-Boatmurdered/ http://lparchive.org/Dwarf-Fortress-Boatmurdered/
- jayrobin 13y agoTim Denee's two infographic/comics on his [1]Bronzemurder and [2]Oilfurnace fortresses were what finally convinced me to take the plunge. I knew basically nothing of the game, so found a random [3]step-by-step tutorial and actually did pretty well until I accidentally killed the mayor, several other nobles and half my standing army at the grand opening of the new great drawbridge due to a...Minor malfunction. The biggest three tips I can give are: A. get a texture pack. I'm sure many people love the ASCII, but actually seeing dwarf and goblin icons removed one more thing for me to learn at the beginning. B. download Dwarf Therapist. It's a great external UI for managing the roles of your dwarves. C. don't be afraid to fail, because you will. Often. [1]http://bronzemurder.timdenee.com/ http://bronzemurder.timdenee.com/ [2]http://oilfurnace.timdenee.com/ http://oilfurnace.timdenee.com/ [3]http://afteractionreporter.com/2009/02/09/the-complete-and-utter-newby-tutorial-for-dwarf-fortress-part-1-wtf/ http://afteractionreporter.com/2009/02/09/the-complete-and-u... (warning, may be out of date!)
- _pmf_ 13y ago> but haven't had the guts to invest the time into it given its steep learning curve And by steep, you mean vertical.
- qznc 13y agoActually, flat. A learning curve usually is time on x-axis and knowledge-percentage on y-axis. If knowledge-percentage only slowly increases the curve is flat. A nearly vertical curve means you learn fast. This is a little bit like educating people about kerning [0]. For another example, a "quantum leap" is basically the smallest possible leap you can do. [0] http://xkcd.com/1015/ http://xkcd.com/1015/
- samstave 13y agoOr if by vertical he means running face first into a wall... Upvotes for both though...
- otikik 13y agoIt's a wall with electrified spikes on top. And armed guards instructed to shoot on sight. And rabid dogs. And behind the wall there are other walls. I tried to start the game 5 times. The first 3 I could not even start a game. The 4th one I followed a tutorial and was able to start, and nothing else. The fifth time, I found Captnduck's excellent video tutorials ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=koZUS2h-Yzc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=koZUS2h-Yzc ), and I was finally able to break into the game. Then they added a whole layer of complexity to the military (with a lot of new UI quirks) and I just stopped playing.
- epaga 13y agoI always assumed the "learning curve" is the curve required to make progress in the game, i.e. the x-axis is "progress in the game" and the y-axis is "knowledge-percentage".
- prawks 13y agoMost learning curves I've seen actually imply the reverse, with time on the y-axis and knowledge on the x-axis. In that case, a learning curve is a sort of visual hill with a steepness indicating difficulty of progression.
- ecdavis 13y agoIt's actually a lot more accessible than it seems. For anyone interested in learning to play DF, I highly recommend YouTube user 51ppycup's "Dwarf Fortress for Dummies" series - he gets the basics across really well and you'll be striking the earth in no time. Dwarf Fortress for Dummies 2012: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLD1A3FE72C0DCAC66 http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLD1A3FE72C0DCAC66
- tluyben2 13y agoDo you know of any recent non-video tutorials. Personally I really don't find them very easy to follow. Pausing and trying to jump back and forward is thoroughly annoying. Besides laziness I'm not sure why people make video tutorials at all for anything technical but that might be just me. Text with screenshots is miles ahead. Again, IMHO. Making video tutorials, especially unrehearsed and unedited with tons of Uhhmm eh, and now then... <lost train of thought> are just lazy versus text + screenshots. These ones were ok, but they were too slow in places and too fast in other places; I had a hard time learning much from them without continuously reverting back to the wiki to figure out what I really can or should do.
- INTPenis 13y agoI'm biased as a long time player but with a graphics tile set I don't think the graphics are any worse than your average DOS or console game from the early 90s. The only problem is the input system but anyone who has mastered Unix can easily master DF.
- jmduke 13y agoIf the history of Dwarf Fortress interests you, I recommend you check out the history of roguelike games (probably the nerdiest of all my passions.) Dungeon Crawl: Stone Soup, for example, is a beautiful illustration of applying open source software development tenets to a massive game, as dozens of contributors have continuously evolved and enhanced it over time (and its massively fun to boot.)
- ricree 13y agoSpeaking of the history of roguelikes, I've been pretty impressed by Nicolas Casalini, aka Darkgod. I'm not sure exactly how long he's been involved in the scene, but he's been developing since at least Pernband back in the late 90s. His Tome2, in the early part of the last decade, was arguably the pinnacle of old-school band style roguelikes (as opposed to the hack style popularized by nethack, or more modern, user-friendly ones that have been cropping up the past couple years). The current Tales of Maj'Eyal is one of the most polished, engaging roguelikes I've come across.
- alex_c 13y agoFor anyone unfamiliar with Dwarf Fortress and wondering what all the fuss is about, I recommend the classic 'Boatmurdered' chronicles: http://lparchive.org/Dwarf-Fortress-Boatmurdered/ http://lparchive.org/Dwarf-Fortress-Boatmurdered/ It's a fairly long read, but as always when Dwarf Fortress is involved, it's well worth the effort.
- fleshgolem 13y agoIt's also hilariously outdated, to the point that the game had a whole dimension less than it does now. Still a great read though
- morsch 13y agoI loved reading Boatmurdered many months ago; is there anything of similar quality that reflects the current state of affairs in DF?
- StevenRayOrr 13y agoSadly, no. While there are numerous different attempts at LPs and stories within DF, nothing manages to both capture the game itself while being laugh out loud funny. It really is one of those rarely replicated gems. Edit: Although I will say that Tim Denee's attempts come closest (see jayrobin's comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5983250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5983250).
- cm2012 13y agoThere is a Hall of Legends on the forums. I recommend Nist Akath for humor and excitement. His fighting dwarves become unbelievable.
- Fargren 13y agoBravemule (http://www.bravemule.com http://www.bravemule.com) is a great read, and it's a lot more current that Boatmurdered.
- barbs 13y ago
- axefrog 13y ago"It's not like people see our $50,000 a year and think 'Hey, I want a piece of that pie.' They'd much rather look towards things like Minecraft, where there are hundreds of millions of dollars." The brothers have this massive, massive blindspot regarding the importance of the UI. That $50,000 cap they perceive is barely scratching the surface of what would be possible for them if they made the damn thing a bit more accessible to the average person. It's great that their small niche base loves ASCII art and doesn't mind fumbling their way through a hostile interface in order to play the game, but that is the primary reason the game stays confined within a tiny niche corner of the gaming market. They have the real possibility that if they did that seed work, even just on exposing an API into the game, as opposed to venturing into a full-on UI overhaul, that enough new people would be introduced to the game that they could hire a third developer to focus specifically on the API and UI aspects of the game, leaving them free to keep working on the bits they love.
- kaoD 13y agoIt's not the ASCII interface. I love ASCII art, and they managed to pull a high information density. You have graphic tile sets too. Although fan-made, these have a great quality. The problem is the inconsistent input system. The same task uses different shortcuts in each menu, which makes it hard to remember. Even selecting rectangular regions of the world is done in a particular way depending on what you are doing. Inconsistency is awful for users.
- imdsm 13y agoBut the thing is, you get over that. Would I trade some of the depth of features for a better interface? No. Would I make the combat arcade-like in return for a better interface? No. I play the game for the fact that it is infinitely replayable. I play it so much that the menu is now ingrained into my very being. If the interface was to change, it would confuse me. It would take a lot of getting use to. It could work out better in the future, but right now, it at least works. Everyone who plays it has different parts they like and dislike. Personally, I'd love it to have a nice API, so I didn't have to go through DFHack for every util I want to write. I'd pick that over a new UI. Sure, it's inconsistent, but the inconsistency is consistent. I'll take that.
- boneheadmed 13y agoI like in this particular article, how the interviewer delves into how it is possible to sustain interest in coding a single game for so long (and potentially for decades). Anyone who has coded games as a single dev probably knows how bogged down you get as the game becomes more complex. Generating graphics yourself is a huge time suck which they have neatly avoided. What's intriguing is that the game design appears to be flexible enough to spend time coding mineralogy and then jumping to say horticulture while still being manageable. It would be interesting to know more about the design to see why it is so extensible.
- gwern 13y ago> "We've just had our mitts on this one for a long time without passing it along," he says, "but that's not going to be a forever thing, obviously. It's only going to stay afloat as long as people keep it afloat, right?" > "I think the game has actually gotten easier compared to what it was in 2006," Adams reasons. "It's not really the mechanics that matter so much, since a lot of the mechanics in DF are under the table. A lot of the updates don't matter either -- I mean, I spent a month on beekeeping, but you're not confronted with beekeeping, and you don't need to learn how to do it, but if you want to make wax crafts and honey, then it's an avenue you can explore." Perhaps it's the language weenie in me, but I can't help but think they're doing this wrong. If you're going to work on something for 30 years (with the Moore's law that implies), wouldn't it make a heck of a lot of sense to use the highest-level language you can, start building up DSLs for specific things like crafts, and other strategies so you don't spend a month hacking on a sprawling C++ codebase just to add in beekeeping?
- idoescomputers 13y agoI literally just got into this game. It's amazing. Was it different in previous years?