3 ms·
'"It is thus perfectly possible that God might influence the creation in subtle ways that are unrecognisable to scientific observation. In this way, modern scie
by jimbokun 18y ago
'"It is thus perfectly possible that God might influence the creation in subtle ways that are unrecognisable to scientific observation. In this way, modern science opens the door to divine action without the need for law-breaking miracles," says Collins.'
If they don't break the laws, then...they're not miracles, are they? The whole point of a miracle is that the normal laws governing the universe most of the time are suspended. If there is a God who created the natural laws of the universe, surely he is also capable of suspending the rules when he finds it worthwhile to do so?
It seems Collins is trying to impress his atheist science friends with this idea, and it is back firing. Inherent in the religious point of view, I think, is the idea that there are limits to the knowledge that can be obtained through observation and experiment, but can be revealed to us by a God outside of nature, at least to the extent we are capable of understanding.
For the more mundane truths about our world, I agree with this:
"But for all its faults, science is probably the best and most honest tool we've got for finding out practical truths about how the natural world operates."
- billybob 18y ago<blockquote>If they don't break the laws, then...they're not miracles, are they?... If there is a God who created the natural laws of the universe, surely he is also capable of suspending the rules when he finds it worthwhile to do so?</blockquote> Agreed. The idea that God could tinker with quantum physics without our knowing is interesting, but parting the Red Sea would still require a suspension of nature's laws. And as a Christian, I don't see any logical problem with that. A God who created the universe from nothing would be no more bound by its laws than a writer is bound by the rules of poetry. It's understandable that scientists balk at supernatural explanations - they fall outside of the scientific method of investigation. It's the same reason that "God created that evidence" won't help you in court; it's an assertion that can't be proved or disproved and therefore must be disregarded. A scientist would attempt to explain miracles by natural, observable causes, because that is the method of science. But - interestingly - the supernatural explanation could still be the true one. If God exists, He may not care to sit on our examination table.
- vegai 18y ago"If there is a God who created the natural laws of the universe, surely he is also capable of suspending the rules when he finds it worthwhile to do so?" Why do you suppose this? Perhaps it trapped itself in.
- jimbokun 18y agoI guess I should be more explicit that the God I had in mind is the Christian God, in the sense that creation and creator are distinct. It is true that there are other conceptions of God as integrated into the creation in some form or another.