9 ms·
He's not a 'stateless person'. His passport has been revoked, but he remains a US citizen.
by jgrahamc 13y ago
He's not a 'stateless person'. His passport has been revoked, but he remains a US citizen.
- corin_ 13y agoI wonder whether that choice of phrase was a genuine mistake, an exaggeration based on emotion, or a calculated lie. I like to think it was the middle one.
- famousactress 13y agoI don't buy that. So far we've seen nothing but pitch perfect and intentional language choices from him. I still can't believe how remarkably well thought out and savvy all of his answers to the AMA thing were. I suspect he'd argue he's stateless because his citizenship in the US has been compromised, that he wouldn't be afforded the ability to be treated fairly like a citizen, hence the asylum requests.
- corin_ 13y agoIt's not really a valid argument, though. Even if there was a complete certainty that returning to the US would see him tortured and eventually executed, that still wouldn't change the fact that he is still a US citizen (unless he chooses not to be). That's why I'm hoping, all-be-it doubtfully, that it was innocent exaggeration rather than a lie - not that it really makes a huge difference I guess.
- famousactress 13y agoDoesn't leaving, refusing to return, and requesting asylum effectively fall under the "choosing not to be" category?
- corin_ 13y agoBy that logic I'm effectively banned from Africa, as I don't plan on going there. He said they "evoked my passport, leaving my stateless" not that he was effectively stateless due to his own decisions.
- darkchasma 13y agoUsually, I respect and appreciate your comments, but this suffers from being overtly pedantic, and clearly missing the forrest for the trees.
- tcoppi 13y agoIt is pretty much the backbone of his argument in the letter, so I don't think it is overly pedantic.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- michaelhoffman 13y agoEqually he has not been given the penalty of "exile." There is nothing the U.S. would like more than to have Snowden return to U.S. soil. This stretching of the truth does not engender trust.
- runjake 13y agoYou're parting hairs and completely missed Snowden's point: that the US government has slickly put him in limbo. He either turns himself in or ends up like the guy in the Tom Hanks movie, Terminal.
- michaelhoffman 13y agoStretching the truth is wholly unnecessary to making such a point. Need I argue that the ends do not justify the means?
- lhnz 13y agoYour argument stems from an inability to check what "exile" is... "Exile means to be away from one's home (i.e. city, state or country), while either being explicitly refused permission to return and/or being threatened with imprisonment or death upon return." [0] Hopefully that clears things up... [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile
- tome 13y agoMy understanding is that the imprisonment/death would be a penalty for breaking the terms of the exile, which is something quite different.
- lhnz 13y agoFair enough, but at this point it's pretty close to exile without being a perfect example... Still: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5974040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5974040 I think effectively it is a bad situation which has been created for him by the United States government. They are definitely manipulating his citizenship for their purposes whether you like the wording or not.
- knowknowledge 13y agoWhat does it even mean for a passport to be revoked?
- marshray 13y agoIt means that it is made not valid by the issuing country.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoI'm wondering about this question myself. It's not as if the facts of your identity change because a country revokes a document. Is it just a policy issue, that there are no countries that allow entry without showing a passport? It certifies his identity, not his rights. I'm not sure how you can suddenly claim it's not valid, without claiming that the original certification was found to be incorrect.
- dreamfactory 13y agoIt sounds like the old Russian system where you couldn't leave the country without a passport (and it was made very hard to get one).
- obviouslygreen 13y agoTrue, but "my passport has been revoked" is not nearly self-promoting or dramatic enough for Snowden. Also, being a citizen of any nation doesn't mean a lot when returning to your country of citizenship means a (possibly one-way) ticket to some place that's not home and comes with the concept of "solitary confinement," among others. Not that self-promotion or drama are necessarily bad things in his position. Both are most certainly things he's using to keep himself on the minds of as many people as possible for as long as he can.
- jlgreco 13y agoThe state in question may feel that he still "belongs" to them in some fashion, but it seems pretty likely to me that he does not believe that state is "his" anymore. He is under no obligation to make concessions to them by adopting terminology which they control.
- mindcrime 13y agoThat's a question of perspective, isn't it? The USA may "claim" Snowden, but Snowden may not "claim" the USA. From his point of view, it may be entirely reasonable to use the term stateless.
- jlgreco 13y agoWell said; better than I could say it. In any modern just society being a "citizen" is an agreement between two parties. Governments no longer own their subjects.
- lhnz 13y agoYes, those two words are probably not precise enough to describe the situation. However if you read the context, what is being said is pretty much true: they are using citizenship as a weapon in order to deny him the human right to seek asylum. "The Obama administration has now adopted the strategy of using citizenship as a weapon. Although I am convicted of nothing, it has unilaterally revoked my passport, leaving me a stateless person. Without any judicial order, the administration now seeks to stop me exercising a basic right. A right that belongs to everybody. The right to seek asylum." Pay too much attention to individual words and you fail to understand the big picture...
- throwaway9848 13y agoHe _broke the law_ and is a fugitive from justice. He wouldn't be a hero if he wasn't risking consequences, and it should have been obvious from the start that he was going to be apprehended by the US eventually. EDIT: Also, the concept of "a human right to seek asylum" is meaningless. Asylum is a two-party arrangement. Is that a legal obligation for all nations to _grant_ asylum to seekers, regardless of circumstances?
- lhnz 13y agoYes, he did break the law but it is absurd for you to use the word 'justice'. Justice: The quality of being fair and reasonable. He's not running away from something which is 'fair or reasonable', his human rights are in grave danger. He is a fugitive from injustice. I do not care whether he is a hero or not, but I do care about whether it was a right thing to do and whether he is treated as a human should be treated. These are principles worth upholding.
- mpyne 13y ago> He's not running away from something which is 'fair or reasonable', his human rights are in grave danger. How so? I mean this sincerely. What do you think will happen to him when he is arrested? There's no brig to throw him in, as he's a civilian. Snowden was very concerned about the lack of judicial oversight in what he saw with PRISM, so why would he assume that very same judicial system would mark him for special treatment when people like Hanssen, the Walker gang, and even Aaron Hernandez have not received such? If Snowden really felt beforehand that the civilian justice system was so completely inequitable it seems weird that he'd have been so insistent on its involvement elsewhere.
- syjer 13y agodoesn't he fall in the "de facto" stateless person as defined by the unhcr http://www.refworld.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/rwmain?docid=4ca1ae002 http://www.refworld.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/rwmain?docid=4ca1a... ? (just asking, IANAL, so maybe some technicalities elude me)
- bmelton 13y agoFor what it's worth, the department of state correspondent Matthew Lee in CSPAN interviews were using "stateless" to describe Snowden as well, and days before he released this release. If Snowden is mistaken in using this terminology, he isn't the only one.