8 ms·
Has anyone else become seriously depressed over all this? I mean the TSA was one thing, they are still horrible but I never fly or take a bus or train, I just
by ck2 13y ago
Has anyone else become seriously depressed over all this?
I mean the TSA was one thing, they are still horrible but I never fly or take a bus or train, I just hate the idea of them existing.
But since the NSA exposure, I just feel seriously depressed about the state of who is running this country and the "just try to stop us" thug mentality. It's a weight on my mind constantly this past month.
- mehmehshoe 13y agoWhat is even more depressing is this: http://www.buzzfeed.com/rosiegray/exclusive-documents-illuminate-ecuadors-spying-practices http://www.buzzfeed.com/rosiegray/exclusive-documents-illumi... I wonder who gave buzzfeed secret documents to make Ecuador look bad? Sigh.. The good part of the story was Ecuador's response.
- mpyne 13y ago"The people who provided BuzzFeed with these documents say that they attempted to leak them to WikiLeaks three days ago, but were unsuccessful. WikiLeaks spokesman Kristinn Hrafnsson called this claim “false” and said “No one in our team recognises having been approached with such material as you describe.”" Anyone want to try again with the line that WikiLeaks isn't simply opposed to the U.S. Government, but wrongdoing from governments around the world? Well WikiLeaks, here's your chance to "leak" it for real now that BuzzFeed has co-opted you.
- Volpe 13y agoMaybe goto http://wikileaks.org/ http://wikileaks.org/ There is more than US only leaks... Guess that wouldn't fit your narrative though, so maybe don't go.
- mpyne 13y agoWell I went. Didn't see anything about the Ecuador leaks though. Should I wait another few months maybe? I did see Syria Files though, and was even briefly excited, but I see that WikiLeaks was able to work in a dig at the whole West in the synopsis alone so now I'm sad again.
- Volpe 13y agoAre you saying that the files don't implicate 'western' companies/government? You are passing judgement on wikileaks becasue they don't have a leak... But I thought wikileaks was just an option for leaked documents, they don't proactively hunt leaks... Am I wrong on that?
- mpyne 13y agoThe persons who leaked to BuzzFeed tried to go to WikiLeaks three days before. WikiLeaks says they have no record of that so maybe the leakers simply couldn't figure out how to properly submit. But the story's been out for like 2-3 days now apparently, certainly would be useful for WikiLeaks to archive surveillance state abuses by Western democracies, no?
- Volpe 13y ago... I'm sorry, I really don't understand your position. Wikileaks isn't an archiving system, it's a way to publish leaks... If Wikileaks is proven to be rejecting leaks (which is unproven allegations at the moment) then I could understand your point. But you are literally just believing some random on the internet, which could well be an effort by the US to discredit Wikileaks and Ecuador at the same time (purely speculation). What wikileaks do is not complicated, you can always create an alternative. They'd probably support your efforts.
- Uchikoma 13y agoCould someone fill me in on Buzzfeed? Their menu says LOL Win OMG Cute Trashy Fail WTF? What's Hot.
- tokenizer 13y agoJoin an anarchist or communist group in your local area.
- mpyne 13y agoHow does that help get us closer to our Constitutional rights again? The Fourth Amendment (with its strong emphasis on the right of a person to be secure in their own home i.e. property) is contradictory to the idea of communal ownership of all property. As far as ownership of business property, you could form a co-op or other employee-owned company structure today if you wished.... but the government won't force you to structure your business that way, either.
- gasull 13y agoI don't know what kind of communism the OP refers to, but some kinds of communism defend the idea of personal property but are against private property. Although I agree: How does joining a Communist or Anarchist group help? We need a broader movement. This isn't even a leftist thing (or only leftist).
- mpyne 13y agoAs soon as you permit property ownership you introduce a whole slate of ills with nary an end though. Even personal property alone leads to greed and envy, which lead to suffering and eventually violence. Communism is not magic in this regard, nor is it the proper solution. There will always be a bully out to take your lunch money, at least with capitalism and representative democracy we're able to acknowledge that and try to rein in that aspect of human nature.
- flyinRyan 13y ago>at least with capitalism and representative democracy we're able to acknowledge that and try to rein in that aspect of human nature. Citation needed. You'd need to find a group who lived completely outside of capitalism their entire lives and yet still exhibit these bad behaviors. And as it happens, lots of such examples exist. They don't bolster your assertion though.
- eli 13y agoIf it makes you feel any better, most indications are that President Obama (very modestly) scaled back these programs. In other words, it's not that it's getting worse, it's just that we didn't know how bad it was before.
- ck2 13y agoI just want him to leave now. I won't feel relief until I see that helicopter flying him away on that last day. It's one thing when there is a clear idiot like Bush but when someone as educated and thoughtful as Obama supports this and lies to the people with word-play (making it legal instead of ending it) it just makes me sick. Even worse, is watching all the liberals support and defend this and try to paint Snowden as someone selfish. Only commentator I can watch these days is Chris Hayes, he "gets it" because he is a progressive and not just blindly liberal.
- eightyone 13y agoMaybe it's always been this way and I am just realizing it, but MSNBC has went to hell. Like you said, Chris Hayes is one of the only progressives on mainstream TV to actually standup for Snowden. Rachel Maddow, Lawrence O'Donnel, they're nothing but Obama apologists. I hope that Chris maintains good ratings because television really needs him. I've been watching way more independent sources now such as Democracy Now! with Amy Goodman. Really great program and they have a podcast. Edit: For those who haven't seen his program, here's Chris Hayes at his best. (From today, June 27th, 2013) http://www.mediaite.com/tv/chris-hayes-absolutely-nails-hypocrisy-on-snowden-leaks-versus-leaks-that-advance-govt-agenda/ http://www.mediaite.com/tv/chris-hayes-absolutely-nails-hypo...
- revscat 13y agoThis is not a partisan issue. Bush started it, Obama continued it and amplified it. The next President will very likely do the same. The problem is with the bureaucracy, and that is almost wholly unaffected by who sits in the White House.
- eli 13y agoI understand what you're saying, but do you honestly think a President McCain or Hillary or Rubio or Christie would be better?
- lukifer 13y agoYou're not alone. What's been seriously depressing is the relatively weak public outrage. It's hard to say whether the One-Way Panopticon is a product of democracy's failure, or of its success.
- sneak 13y agoFortunately, we don't need public outrage. For once, we will be saved by the fact that our government is practically owned by large corporations: The PRISM participants, specifically Microsoft/Skype, Google, Apple, and Facebook, have more customers outside of the US than they do inside of the US. This "we only surveil foreign entities without a warrant" (despite being a lie) is more than sufficient to put a bullet in the head of the US internet industry, or at least its significant competitive advantage in the global market. Google is leading the charge, but don't expect the others to be quiet about it, either— we're actually talking about direct effects on revenue here. Many in Europe are already calling for penalties for violating EU privacy laws (many/most/all of these companies use the Double Irish tax minimization strategy, subjecting them to EU law at some point in the chain). Some municipalities and governments have already prohibited the use of e.g. Google Apps on security grounds. You can't throw one of the largest industries in the US under the bus in the global market and not expect them to spend as much as they need to to protect their business models.
- pvnick 13y agoJoin us on July 4th for a nationwide demonstration! http://restorethe4th.net http://restorethe4th.net
- ck2 13y agoYeah protests - just like with civil rights, it only took 50 years to end Jim Crow laws which were incredibly outrageous and it looks like it's going to be 50 years since Stonewall before gay people can finally be treated like human beings and marry across (most) states. So in 50 years they will suddenly agree that maybe the TSA and the NSA are a step too far.
- pvnick 13y agoWhen protests don't work in democratic nations it's because defeatist attitudes keep people home. You know what they say, if you don't try then you've already lost. As it stands right now this may be our best shot. Y'know... that and sitting around bitching about it on the internet.
- shaggyfrog 13y agoThis sounds like a red herring to me. Why did you just stop at 50 years? Why not go all the way back to the first recorded instance of slavery? That would make your argument even stronger. Fact is that the reversal of anti-GBLT laws accelerated immensely in the last few years -- maybe even just the last decade. We're not talking 50-year scales for major societal changes anymore.
- gee_totes 13y agoYou're cherry picking social movements here. Take a look at how fast the 26th Amendment (mandating the US voting age to 18) was passed in response to the Vietnam War.
- anigbrowl 13y agoNow you're just wallowing.
- yread 13y ago
- MattyRad 13y agoI feel the same. Mostly because I feel helpless about it. How are we supposed to bring about real, lasting change? How can we trust a government that views the Constitution as an inconvenience instead of our most important legal document? One that they swore to uphold. I'm trying to come up with an effective way to help solve this problem, but everything, including encryption, has serious issues. The only truly effective thing I can think of is to start using Bitcoin, because the government has no power if it can't tax, but Bitcoin is a whole new area of FUD.
- mpyne 13y agoThe government can tax Bitcoin too. If somehow the USD went to shit they could even make you pay it in BTC, unless you felt you were able to hide your identity, but we have people paid only in cash play that game already without serious detriment to government power.
- MattyRad 13y agoCould you elaborate on how the government would be able to tax Bitcoin? As I understand, since the government can't see your n number of wallets, all of which are probably anonymous, they would have no idea how much tax you owe.
- mcguire 13y agoAs you to fill out a form declaring how much you earned, determine that you are falsifying that form based on information provided by your transactions' counter-parties, then put you in prison. See Al Capone. Is this a trick question?
- ck2 13y agoHave you seen the joke meme where they label Obama "you were the chosen one" - sadly it's not a joke to me. It really, really feels that way. I had no illusions he was perfect. I despised the marketing pitch of "change". But I didn't expect this. I mean even the right would have to admit they are a little surprised.
- andrewljohnson 13y agoI haven't become depressed, but I've become angry, and thoughtful. I often have new software ideas, and my more recent ideas have turned to ways to organize voters to democratically overthrow the corrupt incumbents. Basically, I imagine a political party, defined by the software it runs on. The first incarnation of the software (website) focuses on organizing party members (users) to win elections, but it then gets iterated to include tools for distributed, direct democracy (i.e. the site will let the party members cast votes on what the elected leader votes on, but I also imagine most people proxy their power to others, which is a feature of the site). The website first needs to get a few local leaders elected... city council, uncontested state positions, maybe a state senator if the v1.0 launch goes well. We need to both recruit people to run for office, then build the software to help them get elected, then build tools to allow transparent governance with direct oversite from the people. It's hard to imagine capturing national congressional seats or the presidency on the first go, but I think that applying iterative processes to the formation of a political party and its infrastructure is one possible way to overcome the existing machine.
- droidist2 13y agoVery interesting. I've also had similar ambitions. I found this essay inspiring (although pretty long): http://www.holisticpolitics.org/NewParty/NewPartyManual.php http://www.holisticpolitics.org/NewParty/NewPartyManual.php It basically outlines strategies for how a new political party can realistically gain traction. As you allude to, an important factor is focusing on elections that can be won rather than just running to make a statement. Perhaps it's possible to write software to analyze past election results, polling, etc. to find races where a third party has a chance and would be the best to allocate resources to, kind of like a Moneyball of politics.
- canvia 13y agoSomeone should hire Nate Silver to do that kind of analysis.
- robbiep 13y agoIf you weren't already aware you will probably be interested to read about the 5 star party, a new Italian political party that is concerned with direct democracy http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Star_Movement http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Star_Movement
- drivebyacct2 13y agoYes. It finally hit me today. I've been bitching about this stuff for years but it kind of overwhelmed how absolutely abmismaly little I trust my government. Combine that with, seemingly intelligent people running around here downplaying the severity of the problem based on some outdated anecdotes... and I just sigh inside. As far as I'm concerned, we full on passed my threshold for "hair on fire". I just don't know what in the ever loving fuck to do about it.
- smokeyj 13y agoWhen I hear endless defeatist propaganda I can't help but wonder if it's state sponsored. This should be great news! The truth is finally seeing it's day.
- orokusaki 13y agoUnfortunately, our owners have 'Big Data', and they're getting a lot more of it very soon. In other words, they're aware of tipping points, and the Rubicon, across which our owners put their sway at risk, will never be crossed, so while I agree wholeheartedly with you, I really do fear that all this Internet dissent will never lead to anything more than an interesting read.
- prawn 13y agoAnd whichever party is in power, you will have the same situation IMO. Electing one or the other will change virtually nothing WRT this. In a game of world domination, sadly the "foibles" of the masses don't really matter. Whatever keeps the country at the top of the heap trumps all. Maybe life in a mid-tier, first world country that doesn't get caught up in all this is a good idea? e.g., somewhere in Scandanavia. (Ignore Assange case, talking about world conquest, etc.)
- melling 13y agoNope. No depression here. I'm a little bummed that all people do is whine all day on HN about this. There should be a place to intelligently discuss what's needed for national security, etc, but this isn't the place. People seem to have a hard time trying to understand why the most powerful country in the world might want to try to influence other countries, or try to monitor foreign and domestic terrorists by mining data on the Internet, phone calls, etc. I think even small countries will try to do the same thing. Yes, I also understand that some people don't want to build products, start companies, discuss cool technology, self improvement, science, etc. Maybe politics is your thing but this isn't the place to spend hours on end. Finally, if you really do want to change something, it's going to take a lot of work. Signing a White House petition is just a waste of time. The endless Internet chatter isn't going to accomplish anything. It may require that you build something to increase government transparency, a better political chat forum, a political graph to better target government, or something a little more clever. It could be a crowd sourced project. Can we there 1,000 people here that want to contribute. I'll even pitch in.
- steveklabnik 13y agoI do think you're right that it's important to _act_ and not talk, but I don't think dismissing talk altogether is productive. I don't think that HN is the appropriate avenue for social change either, but social sites are sort of the contemporary equivalent of the town square, which is where social change _used_ to come from. In order to organize political action, talk needs to occur, and it needs to happen in a place that is public so as to attract passers-by.
- melling 13y agoYes, the Internet is a very public and it's a great place to discuss the issue. http://www.reddit.com/search?q=NSA http://www.reddit.com/search?q=NSA I'm not trying to dismiss the discussion, in general. HN really isn't a good site to debate issues. Besides, I don't think people want to debate. Seems like they're just blowing off steam.
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoDon't be depressed. Angry? Sure. But not depressed. We're living in the last decades/centuries of a doomed empire. Our leaders have shot themselves in the ass and are now too stupid and stubborn to admit it or figure it out on their own. The system they have created will not work. It will lean toward tyranny, and corruption, and there will be a long, boring, dull fizzle as it all grinds down. But trade is still good. Technology rocks. Robots should dramatically change the lives of every first-world human, as will auto-drive cars. There's a long way to fall, and I don't see any huge explosions. (Although I would recommend a good backup power supply) It's the last days of Rome. Sure, the barbarians are at the gates, the government is hosed, and in places the people are rioting. But out in the country, on a farm, away from the spotlight, it's possible to lead a quiet and successful life with a family. The question is whether you want to make a difference or lead that quiet life. I'm not sure you can have both.
- zwtaylor 13y agoWe're living in the last decades/centuries of a doomed empire... The system they have created will not work. It will lean toward tyranny, and corruption, and there will be a long, boring, dull fizzle as it all grinds down. This reminds me of Venkatesh Rao's idea of 'Hackstability'. Part of this concept describes how the antiquated and inefficient institutions of present could be maintained indefinitely through the continuous application of hacks and jury-rigging. This is proposed as an alternative to oft-entertained future trajectories like an apocalyptic cataclysm or technological singularity. Rao envisions our present system hobbling along for another century or so, growing incrementally more kludgey with each passing day, but persevering nonetheless. Mr. Rao describes it far more lucidly than I, if you've never read his work you ought to check it out. http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2012/04/18/hacking-the-non-disposable-planet/ http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2012/04/18/hacking-the-non-disposa...
- wybo 13y agoWrote a paper on exactly such a website: http://wybowiersma.net/pub/essays/Wiersma,Wybo,A_global_advisory_parliament_integrated_with_the_social_web.pdf http://wybowiersma.net/pub/essays/Wiersma,Wybo,A_global_advi...
- aneth4 13y agoWhy would you never take a bus, plane, or train? While the argument that privacy doesn't matter if you have nothing to hide is dangerous to make policy, certainly if you have nothing to hide, then there is nothing to gain by remaining so "depressed" in your life. Very personally, I don't care if the NSA or anyone else, besides perhaps certain exes, knows about my travel patterns. I do care that the NSA can and wants to know, but I don't care that they actually know. There is no reason to restrict your travel other than as a protest, which I think is an extremely ineffective method of pushing for change and a ridiculous personal sacrifice for what is probably a counterproductive result. You don't have to make yourself miserable to push for human and privacy rights. By restricting your travel, you are submitting to a system of oppression, not fighting it.
- __--__ 13y ago> certainly if you have nothing to hide I feel similarly to ck2 on this and the blase "oh, YOU don't have anything to worry about, DO YOU?" attitude I see everywhere is pissing me off. A lot of my political opinions are politically incorrect, but you won't catch me discussing anything specifically online. Tweeting unpopular ideas has been known to land you on the no-fly list, or worse. In that respect, you don't have to go out of your way to make yourself miserable. Every tweet or post is a reminder that this is the one that could make it impossible to leave the country.