11 ms·
There may be an argument for life in prison, or even execution, for people that are so dangerous that they should never be allowed in the society again. But eit
by mtgx 13y ago
There may be an argument for life in prison, or even execution, for people that are so dangerous that they should never be allowed in the society again. But either give life, or put a cap on prison sentences at say 25 years, total, like it's in many other countries.
This idea of "adding" sentences is ridiculous, and my guess is it's only (ab)used as a way to force people into agreeing to declare themselves guilty, and the prosecutors going "easy on them" and only asking for 30 years in prison, instead of 100, if they win.
That's not justice and people should be opposing this. I think it was on The Daily Show where a guest talked about a documentary called Gideon's Army where they're talking exactly about this issue, and how prosecutors are forcing 90% of the people arrested to admit guilt this way, before they even get a trial. So 90% go to prison without a trial!
It also must be very convenient that the US law is so complex now, and has gotten to the point where everyone can be incriminated with something, so basically the prosecutors can threaten just about anyone with at least a charge or two, if they want to. They must be BS charges, but lucky for them they manage to convince those people to agree with a "lesser punishment" before there even is a trial. I'm sure the private prison system and their lobbying plays a big role in this, too. It's self sustaining corrupt system.
- Svip 13y agoDoesn't the US constitution prohibit cruel and unusual punishments?
- kevingadd 13y agoSure, but have fun spending 10-15 years tied up in court cases and appeals to try and prove it.
- AmVess 13y agoPunishments can be either cruel or unusual. They just cannot be both.
- knowtheory 13y agoWould you like to explain further how you think that cruelty and unusualness are mutually exclusive, either in general or in the eyes of the law?
- AmVess 13y agoAsk the SCOTUS. It was their interpretation.
- Kliment 13y agoThe way I understand the comment is that a punishment has been deemed legal if it is cruel XOR unusual, but not both.
- btilly 13y agoI personally thought it was an obvious point of logic. The ban in the 8th amendment is on "cruel and unusual punishments". Therefore punishments that are cruel or unusual, but not both, are not banned. For example it would be hard to argue that excessive prison time is at all unusual in this country. So no matter how cruel it may be, it passes muster. Conversely Shena Hardin was given the unusual punishment of having to stand on a particular sidewalk wearing a sign that said, "Only an idiot would drive on the sidewalk to avoid a school bus." (She was, in fact, said idiot.) The punishment was unusual, but not cruel. It therefore passed constitutional muster. However being kept in an overly crowded prison without appropriate medical care qualifies as both cruel and unusual punishment and is therefore unconstitutional. (As a variety of courts have had to repeatedly point out to California. Personally I'd love to see the fraction of the prison population that is over the design capacity of prisons in California become the portion of the year that key officials should have to spend inside of said prisons. I'm sure that we'd see Jerry Brown stop dragging his feet on the issue fairly promptly...)
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoThe 8th Amendment is based on Cesare Beccaria's On Crimes And Punishments and the term "cruel and unusual" specifically means the punishment should be proportionate to the crime.
- Svip 13y agoHow about pulling people's nails out? Isn't that both?
- timdev2 13y agoEvidently, only if you fail to do it regularly.
- jlgreco 13y agoSo we could bring back the stocks if we just make sure to use them a lot? Seems like bullshit. Cruel punishment does not become okay if you do it frequently.
- majelix 13y agoCute, but I[0] don't think the law is that straightforward to interpret. At least according to Wikipedia[1], "cruel and unusual punishment" is a legal phrase all into it's own, regardless our lay interpretation of the individual words. In Furman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238 (1972), Justice Brennan wrote, "There are, then, four principles by which we may determine whether a particular punishment is 'cruel and unusual'." * The "essential predicate" is "that a punishment must not by its severity be degrading to human dignity," especially torture. * "A severe punishment that is obviously inflicted in wholly arbitrary fashion." * "A severe punishment that is clearly and totally rejected throughout society." * "A severe punishment that is patently unnecessary." These "principles" probably themselves have oblique legal meanings seperate than what we'd expect, and there's probably been a new ruling or two on the 8th amendment in the past 41 years. -- [0] IANAL. [1] Yes, I know.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoYes, but there are notable clauses where this does not apply. The list of exceptions for the death penalty alone is pretty long: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eighth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Punishments_forbidden_regardless_of_the_crime http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eighth_Amendment_to_the_United_...
- Ihmahr 13y agoHow about 23 hour solitary confinement for multiple years as a cruel punishment?
- flyinRyan 13y agoYou might not have noticed, but the US government doesn't really follow the laws they make. Those are for citizens.
- weland 13y agoMany civilised countries explicitely forbid this -- you only execute the highest punishment you are given if the accusations are related. So if you are accused of money laundering and get 8 years for that, and of information theft (which helped you do the money launering) and you get 5 years for that, the final punishment is 8 years -- because, arguably, what you're guilty of is money laundering, information theft or not.
- jlgreco 13y agoThe problem is how do we make migrating to such a scheme politically tenable? Right now we are in a situation where politicians dream up new "multiplier" laws (for instance, throwing on extra punishment or at least higher minimum punishments for committing a crime while wearing a mask) so that they can be seen as "tough on crime". We aren't just coasting in the wrong direction, we are making an effort to go in the wrong direction. It seems hopeless to me. The general population doesn't give a shit, they are bloodthirsty and think of "criminals" as some distinct segment of society that they don't need to empathize with (hell, we can't even get executions widely abolished, a far more egregious issue...) So long as that is the case the politicians will keep on making the situation even worse for personal gain.
- ath0 13y agoUnder the U.S. sentencing guidelines (e.g. http://www.ussc.gov/Guidelines/2011_Guidelines/Manual_HTML/5g1_2.htm http://www.ussc.gov/Guidelines/2011_Guidelines/Manual_HTML/5... or state equivalents), this is already the case. Although you may be sentenced to "105 years" for multiple crimes, if they're related to the same activity, those sentences are usually served "concurrently." It's left to the judge's discretion. Your complaint at this point should be with prosecutors that use the most draconian possible sentence to promote themselves and pressure defendants, and with a media that loves the shock value of numbers like "105 years" when such a sentence would almost certainly never happen.
- jlgreco 13y agoWithout the laws to enable it, the prosecutors would be unable to do that, and the only way to prevent prosecutors from doing that is to make laws that forbid it. The only way to change this while working within the system is through the legislators.
- counterpointer 13y ago>This idea of "adding" sentences is ridiculous, and my guess is it's only (ab)used as a way to force people into agreeing to declare themselves guilty, and the prosecutors going "easy on them" and only asking for 30 years in prison, instead of 100, if they win. Unrelated to this case, if you don't do that, won't it encourage people who are knowingly committing big crimes to commit smaller crimes on the way? Why would you want to essentially grant immunity because someone committed a bigger crime? Where's the deterrent?
- bradleyland 13y agoYour question boils down to, "Is a 105 year sentence a better deterrent than a 25 year sentence?" To answer that question, I'd direct you to a 2010 paper from The Sentencing Project. The thesis presented is that the certainty of being caught is a greater deterrent than the severity of the punishment. Further, increased severity does not appear to have a significant effect on deterrence. http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/Deterrence%20Briefing%20.pdf http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/Deterrence%20Briefing%2...
- gwgarry 13y ago> That's not justice and people should be opposing this. Much like everything else people are opposed to but apparently apathetic because they have no means to effect change. So things will keep getting worse ... I give it at most another 100 years at most. Until the suffocation is to a point where no one can stand it. At that point governments will have significantly more control than they do today, and the result of this suffocation will be devastating globally.
- mpyne 13y agoThis was all gone over with Aaron Swartz's case though. Normal guidelines for sentencing in U.S. Federal trials is for concurrent sentences for charges stemming from the same crime. Prosecutors only have 1 trial for each given crime due to the principle of double jeopardy so they have to charge the suspect with everything they think they can prove in case one of the charges gets thrown out on a technicality. The flip side to that is that typically any conviction(s) on those same charges results in concurrent prison sentences. IANAL so I don't know what types of cases end up in the atypical sequential sentencing but I don't see how this case could possibly end up with sequential sentencing, unless maybe Barrett threatened a cop's family or something like that.
- malandrew 13y agoBut that's the problem. The goal isn't to put them in jail for any possible thing that can stick. When someone commits a crime (from which other crimes can stem), the purpose of bringing them to court is to get justice for that crime (not all the other incidental crimes). With that in mind, if the suspect is shown to be not guilty of that crime that prompted the trial in the first place then they should be freed. The prosecution should not being going out and looking for anything that sticks. The entire premise of our legal system was founded upon the idea that it is better to let 100 criminals go free than let one innocent person rot in jail. Throwing several additional charges in the hope of getting a plea bargain is antithesis to the original intention of the system.
- flyinRyan 13y agoThis doesn't explain situations like Brown's mother being charged. That's clearly just being vindictive and showing other would-be journalists how far the state will go if you out them.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoPlea bargains bother me, in general, because they conflate two distinct ideas: 1) I am guilty of the charges 2) I believe I am not guilty, but I believe that I will be found guilty, nonetheless. To limit my risk of a bad outcome, I'm pleading guilty to lesser charges. These are very, very different. Number (2) is actually an indictment of the system, not of the accused. Is there a way to formally declare (2)?
- mikegagnon 13y agoI believe a "no contest" plea is a formal declaration of (2). See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolo_contendere http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolo_contendere
- nknighthb 13y agoIn the US, an "Alford plea"[1] is a clearer vehicle for a protestation of actual innocence wrapped in a plea of legally guilty (or at least convict-able). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alford_plea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alford_plea
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bcbrown 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alford_plea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alford_plea
- wisty 13y agoThey are also disturbing because they increase maximum prison times. If real criminals are getting short sentences (because they were smart, and took a plea bargain), then politicians will be forced to increase sentences. Eventually, you reach a state where the maximum sentences are insanely high, to compensate for the fact that criminals will always get them discounted.
- ivanca 13y agoYeah, we have that in our country (sentences can't be summed together); and that's the reason one infamous killer and rapist of more than 140 children may be released soon (if they were added the sentence would be of 1800+ years)