4 ms·
This ruined any credibility that blog post had for me: "If major market FM stations paid the same rates as Pandora, based on audience, some would be paying tho
by adventured 13y ago
This ruined any credibility that blog post had for me:
"If major market FM stations paid the same rates as Pandora, based on audience, some would be paying thousands of dollars for every song they played. How much do they pay performers right now? Zero."
He's using industry jargon to pretend like FM radio doesn't pay out to artists. The reality is, he's being very deceitful.
I own a group of radio stations. We've paid out more to music rights than we've generated in profit over the last two decades. If the artists want a different form of royalty representation, such as direct royalties from radio stations (instead of getting a small downstream cut from the licensing companies), they need to abandon the labels and the status quo. Radio stations didn't arrange this formula, and I'd personally vote in favor of abolishing it tomorrow if I could. I'd rather the artists get 100% of the fees we pay for music rights.
- earbitscom 13y agoHe said "performers". If your radio station pays performers, you need to fire your accountant.
- adventured 13y agoYeah he said performers, and that's exactly the part he's attempting to be deceitful about (as I said, he's using industry jargon to pretend that FM stations don't pay out to artists). He intentionally blends that right into the conversation about how much radio stations pay for playing songs, and what a play is worth. Blatant case of Westergren being scummy in attempting to pave over Pandora's own sins.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- coreyja 13y agoNo he isn't being deceitful at all! He explicitly says that he is talking about the performance fee and not the song writer fee. He is very clear to distinguish them in his post. Yes he blends them into the conversation about how much radio stations pay, and what a play is worth, because it is relevant to the discussion! Performers deserve to get paid for performing their songs as well as the writers.
- adventured 13y agoIt is deceitful. I can prove him wrong in about 5 seconds. Do any musicians own the rights to their own songs? Do any musicians write their own music? Do any musicians get royalties for radio plays? And there you go, I just proved him wrong. He presented a case claiming X was 100% true, and he lied. Plain and simple.
- Natsu 13y agoI did not find it confusing. Then again, I did understand that there are different royalties being compared here and that those royalties are paid out to different people.
- radiusq 13y agoPerformance fees aren't the same as royalties you mope. Sounds like you don't know what you're doing with all those stations you own.
- kevincrane 13y agoAren't radio station royalties only paid to songwriters and publishers? I could be wrong on that, but that's what I thought I remembered reading in the past. If that's true, then he's right in saying nothing goes to the performers.
- adventured 13y agoThe royalties are paid to the rights owners (through organizations like ASCAP and BMI). Whether you get paid for plays on FM as an artist, depends on if you own any rights to your music, and or what deal you've signed. The best thing you can do as an artist, is try to retain maximum ownership of your music, and make sure you get the best deal possible if you sign with a publisher. Westergren is completely wrong about nothing going to the performers. First of all, the fact that some performers also own their music rights and are songwriters with royalty cuts, proves him wrong. Second, the cut that goes to the performer is determined by the contract they sign.
- rurounijones 13y agoSorry, I am getting confused by all the jargon being used here and in the article. You say you pay artists but then you imply that you pay associations / labels who then pay artists based on their contract with the association / label. Doesn't that mean that you do not pay artists in the same manner as Pandora? (also, if you have the time, I am not exactly sure what the performer, artist etc. separation is regarding payments, could you clarify?)
- adventured 13y agoArtists get paid based on their contract with publishers for radio plays. Some musicians get paid well by publishers for radio play, others get completely screwed. It depends on what deal they sign. The fact is, and this is a fact: artists get royalty cuts from publishers based on radio play. The details of it varies from one contract to the next (eg what Madonna makes versus Joe Nobody). Also, sometimes artists are the songwriters, that's not uncommon at all in fact. Sometimes artists have very lucrative rights ownership over their own music. That all depends on the choices they make along the way. Radio doesn't pay artists directly (would have been wildly impractical until recently), but that's also not by choice. Radio stations don't get to choose how they license the music, that's dictated by the rights holders of the music (the publishers and companies like Sony ATV hold most of the power).
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI'm trying to understand where you are getting deceit from. He references the excellent breakdown on royalties we talked about yesterday, and in that breakdown there were three that Pandora pays, songwriter, publisher, and performer, and only two that radios pay songwriter and publisher. Since the royalty that Pandora pays to the performer is per listener (it is per spin, and each spin represents exactly 1 listener [1]) and a typical radio station in a large market can have hundreds of thousands, if not millions of listeners. If the Radio played the performer royalty it would be very expensive for them. That seemed pretty clear from his discussion. [1] Yes I've been in restaurants where the background music came from Pandora (probably not part of the ToS)
- dkulchenko 13y ago> Yes I've been in restaurants where the background music came from Pandora (probably not part of the ToS) They were more than likely licensed for it, it's only $24.95/month for business use (http://www.dmx.com/pandora/ http://www.dmx.com/pandora/).
- ChuckMcM 13y agoOh, that is awesome. I was not aware of that. Now I don't have to feel guilty about enjoying it!
- pisarzp 13y ago>> We've paid out more to music rights than we've generated in profit over the last two decades. Did you mean profits of revenues? I don't understand why radio should have profits higher than one of it's largest costs item
- adventured 13y agoI don't recall arguing otherwise. I completely agree. You're making my point. Radio pays out significantly to music rights owners. In my case, about three fold greater than the profits generated since 1990. It's up to the artists to determine the contracts they sign with publishers, and the extent to which they own the rights to their music. That dictates how much they get paid for radio plays.
- lakethun 13y agoDid you read yesterday's post linked in the article [1]? WHO PAYS FOR: Pandora AM/FM Songwriting/Publishing YES YES Performance YES NO And those performance royalties Pandora pays are 13 times songwriting/publishing! Not to mention your royalties are capped at 1.5% of revenue. You are paying less than 1/10 what Pandora pays for each listener hearing an artist's song. Please enlighten us if this is incorrect or how this is fair? [1] http://theunderstatement.com/post/53867665082/pandora-pays-far-more-than-16-dollars http://theunderstatement.com/post/53867665082/pandora-pays-f...
- adventured 13y agoI don't recall arguing that radio pays less royalties than Pandora. I'd like you to show me where I said that (you can't). You've almost completely ignored what I actually said. Your position claiming that radio pays 10% what Pandora does for each listener hearing a song is bogus, just on the fact that you can't actually show me how many people are hearing a song on my radio stations at any given time. Thus you are presenting false data. I specifically said that the claim that radio doesn't pay out to artists is deceitful. It is. If your issue is that publishers are ripping off artists when it comes to the cut from radio plays, then why aren't you arguing in favor of fixing that? Radio stations don't get to choose how they license popular music; they don't get to pick whether they pay publishers via BMI / ASCAP or artists directly. Also, in fact, in the past I have indeed argued that Pandora is getting screwed compared to radio. It's obvious they are.