13 ms·
Coming Out as a Porn Addict
- another_addict 13y agoAs a recovering alcoholic, current caffeine addict, occasional nicotine user, and porn user, here are my thoughts. I had a complete physical, mental, and spiritual addiction to alcohol. Parts of my life were falling apart around me and I was completely powerless to put down the bottle. Everywhere I went I had to have a plan as to how I would drink, and the possibility of being away from alcohol for a day threw me in fits of panic. When I did quit (years ago), I suffered from acute alcohol withdrawal, including delirium tremens, and had to taper off with benzos to prevent seizures. For me to successfully quit, I had to go to rehab and attend AA meetings everyday for months. Nowadays I'm a big coffee drinker. If I forget to drink some sort of caffeine on any given day, I will get a headache sometime in the afternoon. I suffer physical withdrawal which is somewhat uncomfortable, but the fact that I could forget to have caffeine in the first place indicates a different sort of addiction than my alcoholism. If I wanted to quit, I would just have to go through a couple unpleasant days and be done with it. As for nicotine, I've gone weeks, even months without any and haven't suffered withdrawal symptoms, but I enjoy it, so I use it on a semi regular basis, and have been for the last 6 years. "Addiction" is a term which can describe a wide variety of conditions. As an alcoholic, I have a tendency to downplay addictions that aren't to dangerous substances. However, the author obviously has some mental obsession with pornography, he saw a problem with his porn use, and he felt like he needed some sort of external support to cope with and curtail his use. I don't think the term addiction is wholly inappropriate in his case. What I don't like as much is applying the label of addiction to other porn users. I think it's up to the individual to be honest with themselves and decide whether they need to take drastic measures to curtail their porn use, whether it's a bad habit, or whether it's just another outlet and presents no threat to their emotional well-being.
- quitting_porn 13y agoI agree with this point entirely and will chime in with my own anecdotes on quitting smoking and quitting porn/masturbation. I was a moderate smoker who experienced minimal physical withdrawal symptoms when quitting. In contrast, the psychologically/emotional symptoms were horrible. This included short-term depression worse than I had experienced with any breakup. Even minor life stresses felt near unbearable without the aid of smoking. Surprisingly, I've recently encountered similar psychologically withdrawal symptoms when eliminating porn and masturbation from my life. This has included short-term depression and the reduced capacity to cope with stress. I was not expecting such symptoms as I consider myself a moderate porn user (1-3 times a week) and regularly go a week without even thinking of porn. None-the-less, at both the 2 week mark and the 2 month mark I've encountered significant short-term depression as I can only attribute to giving up porn and masturbation. While I don't consider myself an addict, I do believe porn/masturbation has been an important coping mechanism in my life. The question is whether it is a harmful coping mechanism. On the beneficial side, I do believe porn has assisted me in getting over breakups and prevented me from jumping into potentially bad relationships just for the sex. In contrast, it may be too helpful in this manner: it has now been over a year since my last date. Further, I do believe porn may have warped my views on beauty and sexuality as may have limited my stratification in past relationships. That is why I'm experimenting with quitting porn and masturbation.
- sergiosgc 13y agoMy coffee intake regularly creeps to the level of having a headache on withdrawal. Personally, my approach is this: a) Never drink coffee on Saturdays. The routine change makes it easy to skip coffee one day. b) If a coffee free Saturday induces a headache, skip coffee for a couple of days. This is, for me, enough to lower the volume of coffee I drink, thus maintaining an acceptable level (by acceptable I don't mean healthy, I probably still consume way too much caffeine; I mean controllable)
- angersock 13y agoInteresting bit from the article: "The height of my porn watching was my adolescence -- high school -- when each relationship felt like a splintering slat on a long rickety bridge. Porn didn't just serve as an outlet for my sexual frustration; it was a steadying beam to fall back on." I wonder for how many men this is true. It's interesting also to see this juxtaposed with the "All men are rapists" meme--one wonders if the absence of open affection, sexuality, and broken standards is promoting this sort of behavior and in turn perhaps causing the very thing that many authors claim to be afraid of.
- Tichy 13y ago"it was a steadying beam to fall back on." What does that even mean? I reckon a lot of adolescents (and also older men) would fall back to masturbation after having frustrating encounters with the other sex. With or without porn.
- hedonist 13y agoIt's also not necessarily such a bad thing -- i.e. using porn (or alcohol, pot, or anti-depressants; or over-eating, or compulsive shopping) to get through the rough spots in one's dating cycle. Mind you, I'm not saying it's a good thing, or that it's without its downsides. I just mean we should look at these things in perspective: if our dating culture (with all the head games) is so broken that some people have to go through years and years of phases where they just can't find a relationship that's both gratifying and sustainable over any length of time -- and btw this includes many people I know, even some very attractive people with plenty of sexual options on the table -- then maybe we should start talking about that, and how people can learn to do better for themselves (and their potential mates). And not so much about the rather crude (if temporarily effective) medicines some people feel forced to use to get them through the darker stretches of depression and anxiety that they can't seem to help falling into, again and again. As a reward, it would would seem, of just wanting to find someone they can love, and be loved by in return. PS, re: anti-depressants -- having worked in the pharma industry for a while, I'd recommend healthy, sex-positive, consensual amateur porn over these insidious, soul-numbing and possibly long-term toxic concoctions they market as "cures" to well, more or less the basic human condition, any day.
- sebcat 13y agoPorn addict, food addict. I don't think negative habitual behavior equals addiction. Not to marginalize people who has problem with porn or food habits, but poor self-control and bad habits does not equal addiction in my book. I'm probably wrong definition wise, but I think this stance trivializes real addiction. I mean, yes, dopamine and all that. Reward of negative behavior. But you make your own decisions in life. You're not an insect, you're a conscious human being.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- a_c_s 13y agoThe theory of 'addictive personality' is no longer a valid scientific explanation of addiction.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- leephillips 13y ago"But you make your own decisions in life. You're not an insect, you're a conscious human being." Do you regard the human brain as belonging to the physical universe, or somehow apart from it? If the former, where and what is the "you" that is making the decision?
- msg 13y agoObviously there is a can of worms here. Can I just suggest that if you are not a conscious human being who makes choices, but instead, like a billiard ball, are whacked around by the myriad balls and cues you encounter in your meaningless existence, with thoughts caused by minds caused by brains caused by effects chaining back forever... then being swayed by one more argument or not makes zero impact on your status. You remain a mere effect of your circumstances. If you want to pretend to take part in a rational discourse, you should also pretend to be a conscious human being to whom discourse makes a difference and reasons can be better or worse as they conform to reality or not. Your alternatives are limited by the nature of the forum you've chosen.
- Tichy 13y agoFind it hard to trust that piece, too many possible agendas come to mind that could motivate publishing it. For what it's worth, I've been watching porn now an then and it didn't spiral into more and more kinky and what not stuff for me. I still prefer "playboy style" most of the time. The thesis that porn worsens your sexual taste is probably the foundation for a lot of ideological campaigns...
- ImprovedSilence 13y ago>> For what it's worth, I've been watching porn now an then and it didn't spiral into more and more kinky and what not stuff for me. I still prefer "playboy style" most of the time. yeah, and I drink alcohol from time to time, and it doesn't spiral into binging and/or addiction. But just because that is the case for me, doesn't mean it's the case for others as well...
- Tichy 13y agoObviously it is a problem for some people, but the distinction that it's not a problem for everyone is an important one.
- hedonist 13y agoYeah. Also disappointing is the tendency to be completely oblivious (it would seem) to the difference between correlation and causality. For example: At the 2003 American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers meeting, two-thirds of lawyers reported that compulsive Internet use played a significant role in divorces over that year, and 56 percent of those divorce cases included a partner who had an obsessive interest in pornographic websites. i.e. one of the partners was using porn as a band-aid to ease the pain of a much deeper problem -- which typically takes one of 3 forms: (1) both partners love each other and are doing "everything right" but one has discovered, before the other it would seem, that they just aren't really compatible sexually; (2) they're still hot for each other, but other distractions (fighting, money, kids) are getting in the way; or (3) one of the other parts has "discovered" that they have a different chromosomal preference. Nasty and potentially intractable issues, indeed. But porn watching by itself -- even excessively so? In comparison, not so much.
- hedonist 13y agoAnother interesting tidbit: At Brigham Young University in 2007, 21 percent of male college students reported watching porn "every day or almost every day."
- Killswitch 13y agoI watch porn every day... Not to masturbate though. It's my job.
- xtc 13y agoIn their eyes it beats a carbonated beverage addiction.
- rogerbraun 13y agoA strange article. It all rests upon the implicit assertion that watching porn is a bad thing in itself. Is it supposed to be shocking that 20% of college students watch porn every day? They probably just visit pornhub and masturbate for five minutes, so what's the deal? And why did the therapist tell her patient that he is sick because of his sexual fantasies? Are we back in the 50's? I used to visit reddit (and HN) much more often then I really wanted to, and it was stealing my time, so I blocked it (I know, SO BRAVE). But I know that there are lots of other people who can visit reddit just fine, without any addiction (or however you want to call it), or just have enough time on their hands. I know I did when I was a child. If any kind of uncontrolled behavior dominates your life in a way you don't want, you should try to change it. If you need help for that, try to find it. But for others, this behavior might not be uncontrolled, or unwanted. So don't try to demonize the object of your addiction.
- md224 13y agoReading this article, I get the feeling that the real problem isn't porn at all, but rather societal attitudes toward porn and the web of shame that the author finds himself ensnared in. He seems to admit as much towards the end of the article. Personally I find it kind of anthropologically fascinating that society has a natural impulse to record the reproductive act and view such recordings as a leisure activity.
- chevas 13y agoPorn is destructive in itself and should not be dismissed as neutral, even if you've never seen it in your own experiences or in those around you. Porn is about control. A person tells themselves a false story about their sexuality (even if they can't articulate it or form it into words) that goes something like "I am not satisfied with my current sexual experiences, but if I find the right type of images/videos/fetishes and watch them, I will be satisfied" -- The person fulfills their sexual desires through porn use, but then it doesn't satisfy and they are back for more the next time. You can't control a real person as easily as porn and so the user continually goes back to porn. Over time the user prefers porn to the other person in the relationship (usually a woman). Women especially, will try to compensate for the gap by comparing themselves to the women in the porn videos, but to no avail and the woman feels more and more dejected. Heavy porn use also leads to erectile dysfunction and other issues (even if not in a relationship). Some helpful info is here: http://yourbrainonporn.com/ http://yourbrainonporn.com/
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- md224 13y agoIf you're not satisfied with your current sexual experiences, the solution is to explore your own sexuality and find what actually turns you on. If porn helps you achieve that, then that's great. Obviously you should work on finding a consensual partner that shares your sexual interests, but in the absence of such a partner, I'm not convinced viewing pornography in moderation is destructive.
- VLM 13y ago
- Zikes 13y agoI think it's telling that the author draws a parallel with the so-called rape culture. It feels like the concept of porn addiction (which is far too loosely defined in this article to be seriously considered) is being used as a tool to retain control over the male libido. Whereas previously women held the proverbial keys to the kingdom, men now have a safe and easily accessible outlet. But society shames that outlet, attaching emotions such as guilt and repression, and drawing a tenuous connection to an eventual loss of self-control. It does not directly address what should be considered a healthy libido, only that by refraining from any sexual activities at all the brain will somehow eventually reset to a "natural" state, which seems to be defined only by a lowered interest in sex. The part where the author describes his experience sharing his porn with his partner I found especially disturbing. His partner expressed outright disgust, and then described what followed as mere "fucking". This does not properly address the facet of the libido that demands fulfillment without the pressure of a performance. Men are under tremendous pressure to perform with almost every sexual act, even with long-time partners, and sometimes it's easier, simpler, and more appropriate to fill those needs alone with non-judgmental and even wholly private materials.
- reader5000 13y agoPlease give an example of "society" shaming porn.
- farinasa 13y agoGo watch some porn in public.
- stinkytaco 13y agoIt's not so much watching porn in public... I wouldn't want to see to people having sex in public, but how even talking about it is a verboten subject. Of course, talking about your sex life is probably also problematic, so I don't know. Does society shame porn?
- 13y ago
- namuol 13y agoAre all fetishes addictions? I think the individual is the one who decides whether they're addicted or not. As I understand it, true porn addiction is when it interferes with your sex life to the point that you can't enjoy sex without it, when you want to enjoy it without it. Anything else is just a fetish. I'm tired of watching society try to neatly categorize things as amorphous as sexual behavior. As soon as the "experts" have something to say, people find a reason to stop thinking about it.
- lotharbot 13y ago... or when it interferes with other parts of your life. If you're constantly late to work because you can't shut off the porn when it's time to go, that's a definite sign of addiction.
- namuol 13y agoRight -- life interfering stuff, in general, but I just think the most prevalent issue is the interference with one's sex life once one becomes "dependent."
- lotharbot 13y agoThere are people for whom "interferes with sex life" is irrelevant (they don't have one) or isn't a symptom they have (sex continues at a normal frequency) -- but who definitely have symptoms in other parts of their life, such as work, other family interactions, or other hobbies.
- scythe 13y agoThe Last Psychiatrist, ever controversial, suggests that in some men, viewing pornography (and relevant compulsion) is a way of maintaining a state of denial regarding their own poor sexual performance. It's an interesting hypothesis. http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2011/02/hes_just_not_that_into_anyone.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2011/02/hes_just_not_that_int... I don't have a useful personal contribution, I guess. I'm used to closing my eyes and imagining things. My stuff's better than porn, anyway. The one part that grinds my gears: we're all well acquainted with the stench of amateur pseudoeconomics, amateur pseudopsychology, and amateur pseudosociology that infest every Internet discussion like a splotchy, shouting Bill O'Reilly discussing the movement of tides. Move aside, fellas, here comes amateur pseudoneuroscience: >I posted this on Your Brain Rebalanced, and someone pointed out the obvious to me: neurons the fire together, wire together, and if I was still indulging those fantasies, I was still keeping those reward pathways strong. Yeah, if you don't activate the 5-ht4nonsense receptor for a little while, stupidtonin production returns to normal levels. Check, please. By all means, share your experiences, what works and doesn't, but don't get attached to your claims as though they're related to some fundamental law of neural processing. The brain is a mighty complex thing, and two-bit highdeas about the effect of a fantasy aren't helpful and may distract from real self-improvement. Just pay attention to what is actually happening when you do things. Though I think the article's barometer is off: the question is not "do you have weird fantasies at all anymore". You have memories, memories don't go away unless you do something stupid. The question is "are you fulfilled by having sex with your partner". In that vein, remember this: "Ambition is the death of thought" ~ Ludwig Wittgenstein Oh, most importantly: stop thinking of sex as a performance. It's not. A partner, male or female, who expects otherwise is a bad person.
- nicholassmith 13y agoNailed it. There's so much pseudo science around these topics it's hard to find any actual facts to back up their positions. Sharing experiences is important, but don't frame it as science.
- gizmo686 13y agoTry search google scholar. I haven't looked in this topic specifically, but I have looked into other politicized/psuedo-science heavy topics on it, and it has always brought up good science.
- farinasa 13y agoMen are sexually stimulated almost wholly by visuals. Some women enjoy porn, but any attack on porn is a direct attack on men. Also, many men will spontaneously ejaculate if not stimulated. Honestly, it is not much different than needing to urinate or defecate. It is a bodily function that must be taken care of or your body will take care of it for you. Watching porn is not a bad thing. Some porn is bad, but watching it certainly is not.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoYou make it sound like it's impossible to ejaculate/masturbate without using pornography. Watching pornography isn't a bodily function. Moreover pornography [abuse/addiction] doesn't simple allow ejaculation, it encourages you to seek more sexual stimulation. >Some porn is bad, but watching it certainly is not. // Being a part of the system that stimulates the production of more pornography means you have a part in any moral degradation that causes. Perhaps you meant something else but suppose the porn you watch is of a genuine rape, are you really going to say that "paying" for that to be done is not bad?
- Raphmedia 13y agoThis article is bullshit. Addiction is an illness. Pornography is not. Pornography by itself, as strange as the video may be, is not a problem by itself. I don't know what country / generation / family the author is from, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to come from there. I talk openly with my friends and some coworkers about sex and pornography and I sure don't feel ashamed to do so!
- lotharbot 13y agoFood is not a problem by itself, but there are people addicted to eating (sometimes specific types of foods.) Same with alcohol. Having a drink is perfectly healthy, but there are people who are addicted to the bottle. "Addiction is an illness" -- and one can be addicted to things that are otherwise perfectly acceptable. This does not provide a basis for excluding pornography from the category of "things someone can be addicted to".
- Raphmedia 13y agoI am not saying that it is exempt from being an addiction for some people. The issue for me with this article is the approach the author takes. The article reeks with guilt toward pornography.
- tokenadult 13y agoComments here decry pop neuroscience. I will recommend here a new book, Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience by Sally Satel and Scott O. Lilienfeld, who are both thoughtful and appropriately skeptical researchers on neuroscience topics. http://www.amazon.com/Brainwashed-Seductive-Appeal-Mindless-Neuroscience/dp/0465018777 http://www.amazon.com/Brainwashed-Seductive-Appeal-Mindless-...
- tux1968 13y agoPorn is used in medicine. Reproductive clinics use porn to help their patients reach climax in order to provide seminal fluid samples. This to me suggests, that like most things, porn can be a good thing, or a bad thing. It's much more about moderation or addiction in general than porn in particular.
- baddox 13y agoI don't think the medical argument is sufficient. They also break your ribs to do heart surgery.
- tux1968 13y agoThat's exactly the point. Sometimes breaking a persons ribs is a good thing. The medical argument I made was just meant as an example of a positive use of porn. There are surely others, such as in sexual dysfunction therapies, and perhaps in spicing up intimate relations within long term relationships. It's just not a black and white situation where porn should clearly be cast as a societal evil. My goal was to illustrate at least one uncontroversial use of porn that was positive. Someone willing to concede this point must then think more carefully about which uses of porn are positive and which are negative rather than dismissing them all as inherently negative.
- baddox 13y agoBut I used the ribs example to show that something can be used medically that is (correct me if I'm missing something) universally bad outside of that specific medical use. It's not a matter of moderation.
- yason 13y agoIt's not about porn, it's about addiction. If your psyche needs an addiction you will find one. It could be tobacco, porn, alcohol, or shopping, but nevertheless you will find your outlet for your addictive behaviour. Different addictions come with different consequences. Porn is a relatively safe addiction (well, I suppose it's possible to physically wear out your genitalia so that it begins to hurt?) so I don't get the title, really.
- dlss 13y agoTo quote the cryptonomicon, "Clarity of mind (Cm) is affected by any number of factors, but by far the most important is horniness" http://www.euskalnet.net/larraorma/crypto/slide63.html http://www.euskalnet.net/larraorma/crypto/slide63.html Until an article like this one considers the impact of its recommendations on productivity, the entire debate is on the wrong topic IMO. I mean, I'm sure by some metric I'd live a better life if I never ate alone... but I'd also be hungrier, more focused on food, and almost surely less productive. For whatever reason most people seem to think that orgasam sits separate from the other natural functions of the body. I don't. If I'm hungry I eat. If there's someone I can eat with, all the better. I don't see why that algorithm needs to change when it comes to sex.
- mkramlich 13y agoReplace 'porn' with 'sex' in any discussion about porn 'addiction' and it will have an enlightening effect, I think.
- rnernento 13y agoI think people are missing a big point here, in the age internet pornography a lot of us can be exposed to some pretty weird shit potentially at some really young ages. We don't get a chance to talk about those things rationally and reasonably because of societal pressures and psychologically that's not a great thing.
- MartinCron 13y agoAs a parent, this is the thing that scares me most. The most risqué thing I found as a kid is very, very tame compared to mainstream Internet porn and I wonder what that kind of stuff might do if (when) my kids stumble upon it.
- mrcactu5 13y agothe internet is made for porn ♫♫♫ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bQo05WkHyc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bQo05WkHyc