4 ms·
Clearly the future of design is Metro. Metro is the cleanest and most design-driven GUI ever. And, well, users hate it so much it really has made a ding in Micr
by joe_the_user 13y ago
Clearly the future of design is Metro. Metro is the cleanest and most design-driven GUI ever. And, well, users hate it so much it really has made a ding in Microsoft's earnings. But full steam ahead!
Static graphic beauty and usability aren't the same either on the desktop or with phones and tablets. But given sufficient monopoly power, no one has to care. The tragedy is the GUIs got to "functional enough" sometime in the early 2000's and so they are fated simply get worse since more functional isn't a selling point.
And on the "it's phones, not laptops" point - people do fewer tasks with phones than laptops. They'll never do more tasks with phones than laptops and so
- camus 13y agothat flat fad is out in a year like every other fad before it. Metro already feels old. and wphones are clearly a commercial failure.
- Zigurd 13y agoThat's right. "Flatness" isn't a goal. The goal is to wash out compromises and compensatory strategies forced by the state of display technology, by whatever design direction improvements may lead to. Skeumorphism isn't inherently tacky. There is plenty of design outside of computer UI design that uses it artistically and tastefully. But it is on the outs for a good reason now. Transparency is a similar issue. A few years ago I was working on a UI framework for VoIP devices. The target display technology could not adequately support transparency even though the designers made a strong case for it for a small display on other grounds. The outcome wasn't "transparency bad." It was "transparency can't be done right on our devices."
- jared314 13y agoI keep wondering if the advances in "flat design" are a side effect, coming more from the chance to rework existing interfaces, than the actual flatness. Like rewriting legacy code after you have a better understanding of how the code is, or will be, used.
- Zigurd 13y agoMetro is just a theme. Placing too much emphasis on Metro is going to lead to disappointment. Themes, like lapel widths, go out of style. The success of transitioning Windows to touch devices rests on other factors than the Metro look: Are the APIs for touch apps too limited? What is the evolutionary path for desktop apps? So far, it remains an open question. "Modern" touch apps on Windows are limited compared to desktop apps, and are not taking off. Migrating desktop apps, or adapting them to touch is no more satisfactory than it was on previous attempts at putting Windows on tablets. I doubt Microsoft can force a win without fixing these problems. Google has given them plenty of time by not seizing the tablet opportunity as vigorously as they conquered handsets. But, by next year, you will see tablets displace laptops and desktops, rather than augment them. Sales of replacement PCs has already taken a hit. Now they will start to age-out.
- joe_the_user 13y agoYou are simply wrong. Microsoft has been rather cagey about what exactly falls under the Metro and/or Modern Interface rubric. But whatever-you-call the Windows 8 interface, it is surely more than a theme in the sense that it is quite difficult to remove for the average user and also in the sense that it is a GUI concept and guideline-set rather a modular set of bit-maps and such that thing-actually-called-"themes" involve (on Wordpress or Windows 95 or whatever). I'm also not disappointed 'cause I had no hope for this interface. The idea that Windows needs to "transition" to the tablet or whatever is something I and apparently most users would take issue with. But even the pure windows absent absent the mud of all the "transition" efforts has been a failure so the question isn't that relevant.