7 ms·
This C&D demonstrates a rather alarming ignorance about Bitcoin, and an even more alarming tendency of modern enforcement agencies to halt any activity they don
by javajosh 13y ago
This C&D demonstrates a rather alarming ignorance about Bitcoin, and an even more alarming tendency of modern enforcement agencies to halt any activity they don't understand. It is an embarrassment to Paul T. Crayton and the State of California, and this "default deny" stance on innovation has just as much chilling effect as patent trolls.
- quackerhacker 13y agoExactly what I feel. California is known for incubating tech and embracing new methods. This is about as disappointing as when I heard that Nevada was first to legalize automated vehicles before us and it took lobbying from Google to push the approval here.
- smsm42 13y agoCalifornia people are known for being innovative and resourceful. California government is known for being inept, wasteful, inefficient, incompetent, corrupt and constantly balancing on the brink of bankruptcy. It is a mystery how such wonderful people keep electing such miserable government...
- tankenmate 13y agoYou must be new here... First past the post has a lot to answer for. A largely unaccountable (by design) bureaucracy also has a rather heavy hand in the matter too.
- smsm42 13y agoThis bureaucracy has not come from Mars, you know... I'm still at loss how people in California can invent technologies which alter the whole course of the civilization but are stuck with the government which is, by any outsider account, certifiably insane - and don't even try to do anything of effect about it. Or maybe the said people just have enough money that they don't care? After all, if things go bad you can always take your money and move to the next country which haven't go bad yet.
- nitrogen 13y agoIt's probably the low probability of success, combined with irreversible tarnishing of reputation and threat of prosecution upon failure.
- blasphemy 13y agoDoes anyone think that the governments (Federal, State and Local) won't try to legislate away Bitcoin? Yes, they may be ignorant, but they do have the government behind them. When they realize there's not a person or corporation behind Bitcoin, they'll go after the users. Do we really want an anonymous currency? How would that benefit most of us who are law-abiding citizens? Is staying anonymous worth the effort when you don't have something to hide?
- javert 13y ago> It is an embarrassment to Paul T. Crayton and the State of California Actually, it's completely consistent with the way California behaves and works. Corrupt and anti-freedom.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI see it a bit differently. The system is set up so that an independent interest can raise an issue, the state requests clarification, and the resulting court cases clarify the issue. The State isn't going to take the BitCoin Foundations word that they aren't doing anything wrong, just like they don't take the credit card processors or Treasury departments word that they are doing something wrong. So party A says "They are doing it wrong!" and the state tells party B, "Please stop what you're doing, unless you can show your not doing it wrong." That is how the system evolves its understanding and codification of things. Sure, its obvious for something things (like murder and mayhem) but when its less obvious or more subtle then its unfair to take one side's view of the matter and declare it correct by fiat. You explore the subtleties and need to decide where to draw the line. This is a good thing for the Bitcoin folks because it is the start of the process where the government develops a collective understanding of what Bitcoin is. That, if nothing else, validates that Bitcoin is "real" in the sense that the government must "understand" it in order to work with it. People who dislike the notions will argue its evil, and supporters will argue its beneficial and once we've talked through all the legal ramifications then its future will no longer be in doubt.
- jdc 13y agoShouldn't the burden of proof be on party A?
- enraged_camel 13y agoYes. This is where ChuckMcM's reasoning falls apart. If you accuse someone of wrongdoing, it is your responsibility to provide evidence. You can't just go to them and say, "well, if you aren't doing anything wrong, prove it!"
- ChuckMcM 13y agoParty A, "This Rembrandt is the best he ever painted.", Party B, "No it's not, this Rembrandt is the best he ever painted." In these sorts of actions you aren't trying to prove a negative both parties are proving a positive, which is to say both parties are working to create a consensus understanding of the interpretation of the law. In one view what these folks do is legal, in one view it is not. What generally happens though, and looking at the history of the same sex marriage effort is really a great analog here, is that one view or another comes up short in terms of written law, new law is written with what the consensus is thinking should be rather than perhaps what is. Using same sex marriage as an analog, we started from "Homosexual activity is illegal" to a place where the consensus view was that you couldn't really legislate something which was innate, to "but marrying is illegal" to "well we recognize that your partnership is in many ways like a marriage" to what I expect tomorrow will be "You know, the state doesn't have any business defining the sex of the two people in a marriage." [1] In each stage of this "conversation" (and I realize that term is not perfect but I don't have a better term for millions of people going through a process to reach consensus) we explored particular aspects of the problem. Was it the 'sex' that was wrong? Was it the 'people' who were homosexuals that was wrong? Is the definition of 'family' inextricably tied to offspring of mated individuals? Or is is broader than that? Are citizens harmed by this? Helped? How about their children? Other children? People around them? In every case one party says "It's wrong because 'reason'." and the the other party debates that reason or comes up with a different line of reasoning why its right. Jurists listen, they consider what has come before and will come after, and rule. Then we as a people consider whether or not that consensus was what we intended or want and then we create new law and the process continues. It's slow, its ponderous, but it does converge and it allows things to move with the consensus as the consensus moves. FWIW this is the single most powerful 'feature' of our form of Government. [1] I'll know tomorrow if I'm wrong I suspect but reading about the coverage at the Supreme Court I'm betting its going to come down on the side of same sex marriages.
- threeseed 13y agoPretty sure they understand it. They just don't like it.
- joe_the_user 13y agoThis C&D demonstrates a rather alarming ignorance about Bitcoin, and an even more alarming tendency of modern enforcement agencies to halt any activity they don't understand. Not really, The state knows what it needs to know about bitcoins in the sense that it knows it can stop them easily, which seems to be more than bitcoin supporters know. But this statement demonstrates the ignorance and contradictions within bitcoin boosting; the idea that because bitcoin values have grown that bitcoins are a logical potential currency rather than one more speculative trend in the line with tulip is the most obvious example. There is also the confusion between whether bitcoins will succeed through the very force of encryption to end the state's control of currency or whether bitcoins will succeed because bitcoinists have a moral right create a system to destroy the state's control over its currency. But there's a further confusion - bitcoinists don't get that the dollar's value derives from the state's monopoly of force and violence. Indeed, bitcoinists somehow don't get that the dollar is ipso facto the best currency because people use it even though they want bitcoins to succeed on the same criteria. And there's the part how bitcoinist think the weakness of gold is that it can't be transmitted electronically whereas the fact is that state prevents it from being currency (even if it is still allowed as an investment). And I could on and on...
- wyager 13y ago>The state knows what it needs to know about bitcoins in the sense that it knows it can stop them easily Really? Because whatever they're doing doesn't seem to be working very well.
- jerf 13y agoThis is, at most, a bureaucratic throat clearing, or a shot across the bow, if they decide to go after BitCoin in a serious way. This is not even them trying yet. BitCoin enthusiasts would be well advised to consider this as a chance to get themselves together and figure out how they're going to respond if it does come to that. You do not know when the last such opportunity will emerge. The BitCoin enthusiast community would find it incredibly ill-advised to think that they are in such a good position that they can be as smug as you sound.
- flyinRyan 13y agoAlarming? The lack of understanding from the government is all that has kept the internet relatively safe so far.