49 ms·
I general, I find it bizarre that a law should exist, that protects some middleman position. Isn't it nonsense to protect such monopoly through the law? How can
by shmerl 13y ago
I general, I find it bizarre that a law should exist, that protects some middleman position. Isn't it nonsense to protect such monopoly through the law? How can it coexist with the antitrust regulations?
- jusben1369 13y agoIf you find a law that's been on the books for a long time "bizarre" show some restraint. There is likely a very good set of reasons for its existence. Go and research those and see if you agree with them or not. But these "I'm totally bewildered how could this possibly be?!" comments add very little.
- shmerl 13y agoIf instead of brushing it off you could explain what those reasons are, it could be more helpful. Thus my question. If you don't know them and assume they exist - I'm not convinced. There are bad laws which are pushed in by various lobbies (like DMCA). The fact that they can exist long is not a proof of the sanity of such laws.
- joezydeco 13y agoThis Planet Money podcast: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-435-why-buying-a-car-is-so-awful http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-... and this paper (PDF) http://faculty.som.yale.edu/FionaScottMorton/documents/StateFranchiseLawsDealerTerminationsandtheAutoCrisis.pdf http://faculty.som.yale.edu/FionaScottMorton/documents/State... Should be a useful primer. It explains how the dealership/franchise structure came to be, and why automakers prefer this model today.
- shmerl 13y agoI listened to the podcast. So it boils down to the fact that in the past manufacturers had really rough relations with dealers, and the later passed tons of protection laws which gave them essentially a solid monopoly. And most of those reasons have no meaning today. Though I didn't get the part that fighting that now is futile (there were not enough details in the story). If enough people will be against these laws - they'll be cancelled, no matter how much power these dealers wield.
- sliverstorm 13y agoYour parent didn't say fighting it was futile. Your parent said automakers prefer this model today.
- shmerl 13y agoI was commenting on the podcast, which makes a point that "fighting is futile".
- joezydeco 13y agoYou can find all the people you want to oppose these kinds of laws but, as they say, money talks. In a lot of political districts, the local auto dealer contributes more in taxes to the state/district/municipality than any group of citizens does. When these dealers call their congressman, the call gets answered.
- shmerl 13y agoSo, it's a legal monopoly which results in poor customer service and overpriced products? Some really weird legal / economical quirk. Fighting unhealthy monopoly can be successful, even if they have tons of money.
- koenigdavidmj 13y agoAbout 50% of the human race is middlemen, and they don't take kindly to being eliminated
- shmerl 13y agoMiddlemen don't necessarily need laws to protect their position on the market. If they offer some value with their services - people will use them. If they need laws, it can be that their services aren't necessary at all for the consumer.
- makomk 13y agoThey do offer some value to both consumers and manufacturers - they allow manufacturers to sell cars without the capital costs of setting up dealers everywhere themselves. The trouble is that, without legal protection, you basically have to be a sucker in order to set one up; if the manufacturers can set up dealers themselves, they can just cherry-pick the most profitable locations and drive their independent dealers there out of business. This actually happened with Games Workshop, whose resellers didn't have any legal protection - as soon as their stuff took off, they set up stores everywhere and drove the hobby stores who took on all the risk of marketing their products out of business. (To the detriment of customers I might add.)