5 ms·
Is "silly rich" now defined as "bloated with VC money"? That's a bit like contending that you're silly rich because you've got a $1M credit card limit (though
by otterley 13y ago
Is "silly rich" now defined as "bloated with VC money"? That's a bit like contending that you're silly rich because you've got a $1M credit card limit (though the comparison is admittedly imperfect because debt and equity aren't the same).
To me, "silly rich" would suggest they're immensely profitable, which is rather unlikely since they probably wouldn't seek more investment if they were.
- askimto 13y agoAgree. GitHub is ultimately doomed because not enough people will pay up.
- chii 13y agohow do you know that? I m sure they are profitable.
- U2EF1 13y agoNot quite, but on track!
- coreyja 13y agoI disagree. I think enough people are willing to pay for a service that makes their lives easier, and developers especially so. GitHub does exactly that, and their pricing is at a good point where it isn't prohibitive for people just starting out.
- noir_lord 13y agoGitHubs biggest problem is BitBucket. Unlimited repo's for teams of less than 5 compared to GitHubs pricing model for private repositories is a strong challenge. Throw in that BitBucket is Atlassian backed and they can afford to subsidise BitBucket to sell their other tools (though I would observe that BitBucket does not do heavy sales tactics at all). I actually prefer bitbucket to github day to day (I have about a dozen repo's with them) and they have excellent support for mercurial as well.
- xsace 13y agoit's not about your individual preferences, it's about where the open source community is
- noir_lord 13y agoSince I'm talking about where I prefer to host my projects I think in this case it is about my personal preferences. Obviously GitHub is the major git hosting solution for open source projects and yes I have a github account and yes I visit the site as much as I do bitbucket but mostly to pull repo's, check issues and read documentation.
- jurre 13y agoIf you have an active open source presence then you're already using github a lot of the time, personally I don't like switching tools a lot and I guess a lot of people feel similar. Personal preference aside.
- EnderMB 13y agoIf they'd offer a couple of private repos I'd jump over to GitHub in a heartbeat. I use BitBucket for private stuff, and then port over to GitHub when I want to make the code public. At work we use BitBucket because of the unlimited private repos, and we've got a fairly good setup built on it. Every office I know either keeps their repo hosted, or uses BitBucket. I've only known one office that uses GitHub, and due to the nature of their work they keep their stuff public. It's not even up for debate anywhere I work. BitBucket, or a private hosted repo is the only choice to make.
- zimbatm 13y agoIt's all speculations at that point but if the only reason to go to BitBucket is price then Atlassian is creating a community of poor/cheap people. The scenario for up-sell seems quite compromised in that regard. Another thing is that if you're using open source products then they're likely on github. I agree that both platforms have a general feature parity but if you're going to interact with these projects often enough then it's better to stay on a single platform and avoid the context switch. Personally this only is already worth the $50-100 that our company is paying. You can see that I am biased but something I would also like to point out: on more than one occasion github has prompted me to open-source things. When you reach your repo limit you're faced with a choice that you don't have with unlimited repos. There's a case where you don't want to think about it and just want to keep working as usual but for me space constraint is what keeps my home tidy.
- gundy 13y agoBitBucket killed any inclination in me to pay github a penny. And I will stick with them when my team grows because everything is there anyway and the pricing is better. Github tools are really not there to justify the huge sticker price.
- __--__ 13y agoYou're forgetting about corporate accounts. They pay through the nose for something no other tool does right now (at least not as well). Nothing else I've used in the corporate space works as well as Github, especially for code reviews. It's also more expensive than anything else, too. The only problem we saw was it didn't handle large repos very well. And by large, I mean 20+gb. Don't look at me like that, storing every asset in a large 3d game in github made sense at the time! No, it didn't, we were just lazy.
- coreyja 13y agoI agree but I think the author may have been pointing out the it was a sudden move, since GitHub had turned down VC money in the past. More pointing out the sudden change from their past record of turning down VC's
- nostrademons 13y agoThe article says they made $1000 on their first day. And they've been around for 5 years (pretty sure the article has the timing wrong, I was putting stuff on GitHub in 2008) without taking any funding, which is pretty hard if you're not profitable. My guess: they're gearing up for an IPO. Maybe not for a couple years, but they see their market size as being big enough to go public, and they want a prominent financial backer in their corner when they do. That's the usual reason why profitable companies take investment. Microsoft famously eschewed all venture funding until a mezzanine round right before they went public, which was a.) so they could vet their investment bank and develop a relationship with them before it really mattered and b.) so said investment bank would have an incentive to hype up the stock and get the highest possible price at IPO time.
- otterley 13y agoThe amount of dilution the current shareholders will have to swallow for $100M in investment is an extremely high price to pay to get into bed with an investment bank.
- rrrene 13y ago> pretty sure the article has the timing wrong I think they mean "been around for 4 years before taking funding last July" which would equate to 5 years.
- gundy 13y agoInvestment banks are scum. They do basically nothing themselves and eat millions in profit. Simply because of their position and nothing else.
- sjwright 13y agoHaving money is a valuable service to offer. It's why we have interest rates.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoInterest rates is why there is always more debt in the system than money, and why capitalism as a whole can be more likened to cancer than anything else. But don't take my word for it, wait until the host dies.
- jere 13y agoIt's no worse than suggesting that Kevin Rose "made $60 million in 18 months" from Digg. http://37signals.com/svn/archives2/dont_believe_businessweeks_bubblemath.php http://37signals.com/svn/archives2/dont_believe_businessweek...
- gundy 13y agoSo Kevin Rose is not a sixty-millionare. I am disappoint.
- jt2190 13y ago> To me, "silly rich" would suggest... What's really silly is debating exactly what "silly rich" means. How about discussing this? > A big chunk of the $100 million has been earmarked > for... [opening] its collaboration tools up beyond the > software kingdom. The company has already seen > designers, legal teams, and public relations pros using > its technology. "It has not been optimized for those > things yet, but it works for them," says Preston-Werner.