5 ms·
So if Nokia wants to stop being more than a niche smartphone player in the future, they'll have no choice but to at least also adopt Android. It's the right str
by pavlov 13y ago
So if Nokia wants to stop being more than a niche smartphone player in the future, they'll have no choice but to at least also adopt Android. It's the right strategy for the Nokia board to pick.
This is exactly the same thing that everyone was saying about Apple in 1996. Apple's board had to decide between several OS alternatives to replace the failed homegrown Copland project. There were BeOS and NextStep that could be bought outright, and they also considered licensing Solaris or Windows NT.
A lot of observers were saying:
"Microsoft has won. If Apple wants to be in the computer business, they have to adopt Windows. It's the right strategy for the Apple board to pick."
Would Apple be around today if they had decided on Windows NT instead of NextStep? Not likely. The obvious popular choice is often not the right one -- it's "skating to where the puck was".
- rodgerd 13y agoUnfortunately Nokia have not merely gone for the lowest market-share/mind-share mobile OS (which could work out for them, I guess), Elop has gutted everything else about their industrial design and manufacturing (which is what Nokia really did well) and turned them into just another box-shifter of generic parts chucked together in a generic form-factor by the same factory in China that all the other generic flat rectangles are made in. Nokia have abandoned everything they used to do well.
- pavlov 13y agoSeriously? Most people seem to think that physical design and build quality is the only thing that Nokia still does really well. The colorful Lumia range is certainly very different from the generic black rectangles that other smartphone manufacturers put out.
- rodgerd 13y agoSony make a bunch of colourful phones - and as far as the physical design, the Lumias seem to be even more fragile than the double-glass iPhones. Perhaps we just get dud ones in my neck of the woods.
- fpgeek 13y agoThere's a difference between choosing to control your own destiny (Apple and NeXT) and choosing between different masters (Nokia and Android vs Windows Phone). I think it's obvious that Android would have been a better master 2-3 years ago and there are plenty of reasons to think the same holds true today. Would a path where Nokia tried to stay in control of their destiny have been superior to both? I think so (and I have my ideas about what that would have looked like), but that's a separate question.
- quattrofan 13y agoThere is a big difference between customer loyalty on a desktop vs a smart phone. Most people rely on specific software they like and use on their laptop/desktop PC to do their job, in the case of Apple DTP back in the 90's was a huge advantage for them. If I am forced to swap my smartphone, far less of a big deal.
- molmalo 13y agoI think that's not a valid analogy. First, the last time I checked, Apple is still a niche player in the global computer market. Their current success is not because of their position in the computer market, but because of their current position in the MP3-Player (iPod) and smartphone markets. And second, because Nokia is not betting on their own OS (as Apple did), but in someone else's OS. That means a different kind of pressure from their investors, and a real submission to another company. And they put all their eggs in the same basket. They did that in order to have something really different to offer (they were afraid to compete without a real differentiating element, and not just a different launcher). But that strategy is not working and Microsoft is trying really hard to get other brands to use their OS. So, if MS is not putting all their eggs in the same basket, why should Nokia do it anyway? Just staying on the same road, knowing that there's a cliff ahead, in hopes that something will happen... may not be the best strategy. Even if they really believe that Windows Phone is the future, they could use another line of smartphones, with a different OS (even using stock Android could be considered a differentiating element...) just to get some cash that gives them some air (especially from their investors).
- ishansharma 13y agoI think that's not a valid analogy. First, the last time I checked, Apple is still a niche player in the global computer market. Their current success is not because of their position in the computer market, but because of their current position in the MP3-Player (iPod) and smartphone markets. But this niche market saved Apple from bankruptcy. Had they not gotten NextStep, they would have been bankrupt.
- bergie 13y agoThe Microsoft investment and their promise to port/maintain Office for Mac OS were what bought Apple enough time to come up with new product categories like the iPod.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThey also suck up a lot of the "profits" in the PC market. So even if their marketshare is 5%, their profit share is like 30%.