4 ms·
I'm honestly shocked that many of these companies aren't being sued in European courts. There is more than enough evidence now to support this. Hit every compan
by malandrew 13y ago
I'm honestly shocked that many of these companies aren't being sued in European courts. There is more than enough evidence now to support this. Hit every company on their bottom line. Europeans need to present the following dichotomous choice to every American tech company:
(1) Operate in Europe and make money here, but no spying on any EU citizen.
(2) Continue spying, but don't operate in Europe.
Alternatively, eliminate the tax evasion benefits of routing everything through Ireland. The tax hit of forcing many US companies to pay the full amount of US corporate taxes should be more than enough to change their tune.
- criley2 13y agoIf the NSA is tapping fiber at providers, a la Room 641A, then the companies behavior is completely irrelevant to the spying, and the NSA watches all traffic in and out of their networks anyway. So your choice, as a European, seems to be utilize networks that don't pass through America at all, or have the NSA spy on you. I apologize for the inconvenience.
- jtome 13y agoWrong, if they are tapping at the wires they only see that your using gmail, not the content of your email or who you are speaking to (Unless you turn off ssl for some strange reason).
- csirac2 13y agoIsn't the whole point of all this outrage that NSA have equipment or data exchange arrangements with GMail etc. so that SSL is irrelevant?
- jtome 13y ago"Isn't the whole point of all this outrage that NSA have equipment or data exchange arrangements with GMail etc. so that SSL is irrelevant" Yes which is why the NSA needs the cooperation of the companies, since this info can't be gotten just by listening on the wire.
- pvnick 13y agoHow likely is it that these companies can be compelled to turn over their SSL private keys via FISA court?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sitkack 13y agoVery likely. Even if it was for a specific case.
- darkarmani 13y ago> If the NSA is tapping fiber at providers, a la Room 641A, then the companies behavior is completely irrelevant to the spying, and the NSA watches all traffic in and out of their networks anyway. Then why would the companies need blanket immunity?
- nano111 13y agoRussia promises legal action over NSA surveillance scandal -> http://rt.com/politics/internet-surveillance-western-prevent-928/ http://rt.com/politics/internet-surveillance-western-prevent...
- MisterWebz 13y agoAccording to the General Data Protection Regulation(GDPR) which is an expansion of the current Data Protection Directive and is planned to take effect in 2016, companies that are located outside the EU and that process EU citizen's data are supposed to be compliant with the GDPR. The GDPR allows much greater control over one's own data. The current Data Protection Directive apparently does not take into account many of the foreign online services, but the new GDPR does. On wikipedia: The proposed new European Union Data Protection Regulation (a draft for which was unveiled in January 2012) extends the scope of the EU data protection law to all foreign companies processing data of European Union residents.[1] I'm wondering if and how the EU will enforce this law? Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulat...
- jholman 13y agoI wish this plan of yours made any sense. Btw, IANAL. First of all, I strongly disagree with "enough evidence now". Next, to sue successfully, you need to prove that the thing happened (and that it happened in a way or in a place where the relevant law claims jurisdiction). How will your imagined plaintiffs get actual evidence? Subpoena the companies? Seriously, imagine you're a successful, law-abiding, US company. And imagine that a European court orders you to reveal facts XYZ, blah blah blah. Normally, because you're law-abiding, you try legal ways to avoid it, and then you obey the court. But in this case, the NSA has a gun to your head, and it's a legal gun (both in the sense that the gun is not illegal, and in the sense that the gun is made-out-of-laws). What do you do? You can't obey both laws at once. What you do is obey your own country. So the only way they'd get evidence (assuming your unfounded accusations are true) is if there were enough whistleblowers inside each sued company. If those people existed, they'd probably be coming forward already. ALSO, not counting the UK, profits in Europe are pretty small, overall. Not small enough to ignore, but way way way too small to threaten US profits. Even all of non-UK Europe put together, actually, but especially if you're talking about individual countries. And finally, you seriously have no clue how tax avoidance (not evasion) works. If big companies were forced to move out of Ireland, they'd move to any of the dozens of alternatives. Even the UK and France, for example, when they're not hassling big-corps, literally brag about how good their tax incentives are. There are LOTS of tax havens. Many countries would rather have 10% of a lot than 50% of nothing. You can disapprove or whatever, but that's the world the the politicians have created, when they're not pretending to be angry about that very same world. The thing is, although I think nearly every sentence of your comment is ill-conceived, I wish your plan made sense. Because I would like to see the truth come out, whatever the truth is. If my company is innocent, I'd like proof. If my company is guilty, I'd like proof, so I can quit, and pressure fellow-engineers to quit, to send a message that would actually affect the bottom line. But your plan will never help me to learn the truth.
- malandrew 13y agoI reckon you could use link honeypots to prove emails are being read. Send out enough emails from many accounts with links that aren't meant to be followed and see how many are followed and what IP addresses the links are followed from. If you do that across enough accounts, you should be able to figure out whose accounts are being wiretapped. I'm sure there are other types of honeypots that could be set up.