5 ms·
The New College Try
- pg 19y agoIt may be that the solution to this problem is not to reform the elite colleges, but to go around them, so that they are no longer the gatekeepers they once were. That's what happens with technology, anyway. You don't beat the incumbents; you make them irrelevant.
- Alex3917 19y agoAdmissions have broad implications beyond just who gets admitted. For example, the curriculum of primary schools can't change because of high school admissions, high schools can't change because of college admissions, and colleges can't change because of U.S. News & World Report. There a couple of solutions. First, as you suggest, the system could be completely circumvented. Second, the system as a whole could become less tightly coupled so that, for example, high school grades and SATs have much less influence on college admissions. There have been a couple of proposals along these lines. To me though it seems like the system isn't going away and there is no practical way to make it less tightly coupled. I think the most practical is to add a new layer to the top of the stack that will pull on everything underneath. My money has been on digital identity for a while.
- robg 19y agoI agree that individuals have that choice, and unless they want to do research, there's little reason to attend a major research university apart from the brand recognition. But I'm not sure the elite can be made irrelevant because the products are mostly uniform and the consumers seem happy enough with the status quo. It's a Coke/Pepsi decision and the major players are so entrenched that they can continue to dominate, even among the liberal arts schools. That's not to say regional elites can't emerge (see Wash U and Emory) just that the system is tied to the culture. Where technology fascinates me is in the meritocracy of great work. But even then the major players (Gates, Bezos, Yang, Googlers) had the authenticity stamp that an elite association afforded. You can get a great education at probably more than two hundred schools in the US alone. But if given the choice, I bet most would choose the brand over the unknown. How can we quantify an education and how can a new product demonstrate its superiority to influence that choice?
- jimbokun 19y agoI like this idea: "This could take the form of reserving a modest number of places in the freshman class -- say 5 percent to 10 percent -- for applicants who, having met a high academic threshold, would be selected at random. While the admissions office would know the identities of the students admitted by lottery, no one else -- not faculty, not employers and not the students themselves -- would." I agree with the author that it would be a good way to assess if the more involved admissions process selected higher quality students.
- mynameishere 19y agoThe paucity of students from poor and working-class backgrounds at the nation's selective colleges should be a national scandal. If you solve this problem, one generation later you have re-created it, as the children of previously poor families have gained the wealth associated with Harvard diplomas. The truth is--the problem such as it is, genuinely existed through almost all of history up until the middle of the 20th century. The problem was solved, and It's all but gone now. The poor are largely poor because of themselves and not circumstances. Where exceptions to this exist, they will be quickly eradicated by individuals who partake the widely available financial aid for college.
- yters 19y agoI think the author makes a good point about criteria that are most easily fulfilled by the privileged.
- robg 19y agoI can't disagree more. Social mobility exists but poverty is nowhere as easy to escape nor self-created nor eradicated as you suggest. And the income gap appears to only be getting worse. The median household income is somewhere around 50k. Good luck trying to raise a family (food, car, rent/mortgage) and save for their education on that. And the financial aid you point to is usually loans that are paid off over a decade - add that cost to the next generation. Selection could always be biased to uplift rather than simply advance. The debate has been dominated by racial inequities. By addressing socioeconomic discrepancies in education across the color spectrum it's possible to redistribute wealth through a Horatio Alger ethos generation after generation. Problem is, those differences are exacerbated by local school districts and so the best hope of focused change is through college. But fewer than 50% of the American populace goes on to attend. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_...
- mynameishere 19y agonowhere as easy to escape nor self-created nor eradicated as you suggest Um, yes it is. 100 years ago almost everyone was "poor" by absolute standards. Today, almost no one is. Poverty has been all-but eradicated and it's something you almost have to aim for now. And the income gap appears to only be getting worse This is a make-believe problem. If I get a raise, the income gap has just increased (or decreased, depending). Whichever might occur doesn't change the basic advantage of getting a raise. around 50k. Good luck trying to raise a family (food, car, rent/mortgage) and save for their education on that Um, let's see...90 percent of the people I new growing up (actually much less than 50K), including my family, would fall in this category. So, you may have a very pampered sense of what is required to survive in this world, because it's totally foreign to me. it's possible to redistribute wealth through a Horatio Alger ethos generation after generation If that is your goal by itself, then a good mugging will do the job with much, much less in the way of administrative costs than redistributing money through a school system or some other structure. At any rate, the prices for schools are strictly nominal and are invariably lower for low-income students. This is just how schools segment the marketplace, and the fallacious sticker-price of schooling shouldn't distort one's view of society. But fewer than 50% of the American populace goes on to attend And fewer than 25 percent should attend. Your average person should enter vocational training rather than pretending to become a professional by spending 1000s of dollars on art history classes.
- danteembermage 19y agoIn the spirit of "When you've got a hammer" as a business school guy I'm always thinking what's best from a discounted present value sense. It's hard for me to believe that the difference between decent performance at Harvard and better performance at a slightly less selective school is worth the enormous up front cost of the former.unless your marginal utility of a dollar really low. Another way to look at this is perhaps "Rich families transfer wealth between the generations in a tax-advantaged, inefficient, socially acceptable way" I went to a perfectly good college on academic scholarship (and therefore almost certainly could have gone somewhere better (well, more selective) not on scholarship) and my friends were going to UChicago and Yale for econ PhDs right out of undergrad, so I don't really feel slighted in terms of opportunity. The big advantage as I see it would be being surrounded by really smart people all the time and sneaking something ridiculous to the top of the dome would do wonders for self confidence later in life.