5 ms·
Is it me or are most (all?) of these hearings against companies or agencies in this case - a joke? I've watched some of them lately, and the Congressmen always
by mtgx 13y ago
Is it me or are most (all?) of these hearings against companies or agencies in this case - a joke? I've watched some of them lately, and the Congressmen always seem to be butt-kissing the company or agency they are supposed to investigate.
These past 2 hearings don't seem to intend to shed any light on this. They seem to be held to help protect whatever NSA is doing.
- trebor 13y agoJust think of the kind of blackmail material the NSA would have on our representatives under this program. All it would take is "probable cause", which seems very easy to get, to unearth that data and start blackmail or expose the person. These programs give the NSA an incredible amount of power, and it's easily misused.
- skue 13y agoAnd THIS is the ultimate answer to the question: If I have nothing to hide, why should this bother me? It's not whether each of us individually have something to hide: it's whether our politicians, our activists, our reporters, our lawyers, our doctors, our military, our police, our courts, our spies, our business leaders, our celebrities, our friends & family have something to hide. Because if any of them can be manipulated by the data that is being gathered, then all of us lose.
- VMG 13y agoI can see an interesting collective action problem here. In principle, members of congress do not have an interest to be monitored and spied on. However raising protest as an individual member can cause you problems, because the NSA can pressure you. But if they act collectively, they might have a chance.
- axelf 13y agoYep, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Harman#AIPAC_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane_Harman#AIPAC_controversy
- LoganCale 13y agoThat is huge, and I'd never heard of it before.
- addflip 13y agoNot sure if you saw the video from last week but this "hearing" seems staged. They're all reading from a script. Sounds like robots.
- adventured 13y agoIt's the hearing equivalent of a kangaroo court.
- jdp23 13y agoThis is why the makeup of the committee is so important. The Chair controls the witness list and the order of questioning - and gets to ask a lot of questions. So, since Mike Rogers supports the NSA, there aren't any civil liberties witnesses; and 75 minutes into a 2 hour hearing we still haven't heard any skeptical questions at all, or anything that deals with the excellent points being brought up by those watching on Twitter.
- wheelerwj 13y agoExactly,these hearings are a PR session for each of the programs. A total sham.
- chiph 13y agoThe committee usually sends their questions in advance to the people appearing in front of them. Seldom will you see the people testifying caught unaware. It's theater.
- JonnieCache 13y ago"If you believe the security of the realm is at risk you don't hold a security enquiry, you call in the Special Branch. Government security enquiries are only used for killing press stories." - Yes Prime Minister S01E08 More americans need to watch Yes Minister. It will disabuse you of naive notions like inquiries serving purposes other than finding its subjects innocent and generally hiding the truth. There are lots of other apposite quotes but I can't seem to find any just now.
- rtpg 13y agothe chairman is doing it a bit. But some congresspeople are being particularly stringent (Check out what Schiff said concerning court oversight). Things are happening, and honestly what's being said here is pretty tempered, there's not much to get outraged about.
- declan 13y agoThe members of this committee, House Intelligence, generally knew what the NSA was doing in this area. (There are more secretive intelligence programs that are briefed only to the so-called Gang of Eight, a select group of House and Senate leaders that do not include all members of the Intelligence committees.) Think of it this way: If you've been briefed on some supersecret surveillance since at least 2008, when the FAA was enacted, and you never raised a privacy alarm, what do you do when everyone else finds out? Do you say "I was wrong?" Or do you say "Nothing to see here, move along."