4 ms·
Which "democracy" isn't a republic? I don't think any country actually has direct/pure democracy. They are all republics and have representatives and Parliament
by mtgx 13y ago
Which "democracy" isn't a republic? I don't think any country actually has direct/pure democracy. They are all republics and have representatives and Parliaments.
That being said, US could use a whole lot more "democracy" into its system. I don't think the delegate system works very well. Gerrymandering has also been abused for decades.
- rosser 13y agoAnd that's exactly why it's important to make the distinction. Calling the US a "Democracy" suggests the power lies with the people. It doesn't.
- mindcrime 13y agoCalling the US a "Democracy" suggests the power lies with the people. It doesn't. It's supposed to, and if it doesn't, that only tells us that things have gone very wrong. But you don't have to have direct democracy (as opposed to representative democracy) to adhere to the idea that the ultimate political power rests in the hands of the people.
- CapitalistCartr 13y agoSupposed to, according to whom? In the original constitution, members of the Senate were chosen by State legislatures; the president was chosen by the members of the Electoral College who were not simply tokens, but really had the choice. The vote was restricted to white male landowners. Most importantly, the point of having a constitutional republic is the constitution protects the minority from the tyranny of the majority.
- baddox 13y agoActually, calling the US a republic suggests the power lies with the people. That's what "republic" means, and is why the last six letters of the word are "public."
- Ma8ee 13y agoMany European democracies, such as Sweden, Denmark, and of course United Kingdom, are monarchies. We don't have presidents, but kings and queens. Not that it matters that much, since the monarchs have very little real power, and usually the prime ministers have more of the same role as the US president. One difference is of course that the prime ministers are elected by the parliaments and not directly by the people.
- jlgreco 13y agoIf we are being pedantic, then the US president is not elected directly by the people either. Presidents are elected by the electoral college.
- mpyne 13y agoSadly that's not always a strictly pedantic point. Even besides Bush v. Gore, it also has led to the concept of "Battleground States" which I find abhorrent to a proper republic.
- jlgreco 13y agoVery true. The "pedantic" is misleading.
- baddox 13y agoYou're always going to have "battleground regions" unless you can guarantee a uniform population density and uniform distribution of political tendencies across the entire nation.
- nitrogen 13y agoBattleground regions aren't as big of a deal when a 1% change in the popular vote of a state no longer results in a 100% change in the electoral vote.
- claudius 13y agoThe way the head of state is chosen doesn’t really matter with regards to whether the state is a republic or a monarchy. Monarchies have crowned head of states, republics don’t. For example, the Holy Roman Empire (aka this bundle of German states existing in the middle ages) was a monarchy, but the emperor was elected (by a set of dukes and such), whereas the UK is a monarchy while the queen isn’t elected.
- frisco 13y agoSwitzerland is a direct democracy.
- brazzy 13y agoNo. It's a federal parliamentary republic (just like the USA), but allows citizen-initiated referendums to challenge all laws passed by the parliament, or even to change the constitution.
- pbhjpbhj 13y ago>allows citizen-initiated referendums to challenge all laws passed by the parliament, or even to change the constitution // Wouldn't you say that fits within the term "direct democracy"?
- brazzy 13y agoNo, but it's probably as close as you can practically come at scale. A real direct democracy would have all relevant decisions made by citizens collectively, not just potentially challenged.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoIt's possible for the citizenry to alter any decision directly without recourse to elections. That's why I'd say it is a form of direct democracy.
- CCs 13y ago"Dictatorship of the majority" vs "Rule of law" http://www.diffen.com/difference/Democracy_vs_Republic http://www.diffen.com/difference/Democracy_vs_Republic
- tbrownaw 13y agoWhich "democracy" isn't a republic? I don't think any country actually has direct/pure democracy. The state of California is closer than most I think. IIRC part of their budget troubles were because some issues require a referendum.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Which "democracy" isn't a republic? Many countries that are, like the US, representative democracies are, unlike the US, not republics (an obvious example is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, which is a constitutional monarchy rather than a republic, but nevertheless also a representative democracy.)