10 ms·
Members of Congress Go Silent Over Prior False Testimony On Surveillance
- ttrreeww 13y agoI still remember Larry page's denial and Mark Zuckerberg's denial. We can never trust them again.
- obviouslygreen 13y agoAgain? We should never have trusted them in the first place. You should never trust anyone until they've proven themselves trustworthy, and trusting a company is just over the top. The amount of trust we grant these people and companies in the first place may not be the root of the problems we're facing lately, but our collective naivete about other people's motivations and scruples has most certainly contributed to the lengths at which our rights and privacy can readily be violated by both the people we're throwing our data at and the governments that want access.
- jlgreco 13y agoTo be fair, if you ever trusted Zuckerberg then you were a "dumb fuck". ;)
- rayiner 13y agoI mean, didn't he take someone else's idea and turn it into a billion-dollar company for himself while cutting them out? Multiple reasons not to trust him!
- irishcoffee 13y agoAnyone with a facebook account "trusts" him.
- myko 13y agoWhat are you talking about? Nothing in either of their denials has been shown to be wrong.
- mayanksinghal 13y agoExactly. Someone really needs to have very tilted perception to not see the perpetrators at this moment.
- betterunix 13y agoNot wrong, but still dishonest, and deliberately so. The denials all focused on "direct access" to their servers and what is allowed/required by law.
- myko 13y agoWrong. They were accused of giving direct access to the government. They in fact aren't doing that. All they do is provide information when legally required to do so. What exactly do you think Facebook and Google have done wrong?
- Splendor 13y agoFrom what I understand PRISM splits the fiber coming out of the companies implicated on it's way to the backbone. This does not require the knowledge of the companies implicated. Since it's actually splitting the light inside the fiber, PRISM is a cute name.
- jlgreco 13y agoThat is basically a continuation of the Room 641A concept. There are a few problems with that theory when you consider that these companies are using SSL now. They cannot MiTM data from a beam splitter and we know they are not actively MiTM'ing traffic from a spliced cable with their own private key signed by a cooperating CA (doing this would be noticed quickly if they tried it en masse). If they have the companies private keys then they could be passively decrypting the traffic, unless DHE/ECDHE were being used. If that was the case then they would need the companies private key and the ability to do an active MiTM. I don't doubt that they are doing something, but I don't think we have enough information yet to say what. Hopefully further releases will shed more light on this.
- twinge 13y agoAdd on top of that the PRISM program only costs $20m/year. There is just no way a massive nationwide clandestine fiber tap collecting data from companies moving petabytes a day between datacenters can cost a mere $20m/year. The thing that is most frustrating about this leak is we only get 4 slides out of a 41 slide deck, and are left to fill the gaps with paranoid worst-case assumptions. And the Internet is a great echo chamber of paranoid assumptions.
- jlgreco 13y agoWell, we also don't know if PRISM is piggybacking on another, possibly far more expensive system (the hypothetical hardware could already be in place, and under the budget of another far more expensive program). Really, we just don't know. We don't know anything, except that it sure seems that something is going on. The documents are not getting the same treatment as the fabricated documents of a raving lunatic anonymous coward on Slashdot. It seems fairly prudent to assume the worse case scenario, better safe than sorry, but it is important to not confuse that assumption with knowledge.
- chiph 13y agoEven if they knew about the program, they couldn't have said anything because of the gag order part of the National Security Letter they were handed.
- gcb0 13y agoBut then they wouldn't come forward as fast as they did to boast that their companies are sparking clean... That's lying.
- chris_mahan 13y agoThey realize the instant most people around the world realize storing stuff on "the cloud" is equivalent to forwarding a copy to the CIA, their business is SOL internationally. Imagine if I was sending copies of everything (emails, internet uploads, photos, videos, skype recordings, aws server snapshots) to China's Ministry of State Security... I'd have the FBI at my doorstep in no time.
- deelowe 13y agoThere's no proof to suggest they knew otherwise. Anything stated thus far is speculation. All that's been shown as "evidence" is a slide with company logos on it and some statements from the NSA which claims to collect "Facebook" data, which could really mean anything. Plus Google openly submitted a request to allow them to publicly disclose the number, type, and scope of NSLs it receives. I have more reason to doubt the Govt than these other companies. Also, given the name "PRISM," isn't it pretty obvious how this program worked? Think about it... What does a prism do? Meanwhile, Verizon and ATT have been completely silent and government representatives are making up new definitions for the term perjury.
- uvdiv 13y agoAlso, given the name "PRISM," isn't it pretty obvious how this program worked? Think about it... What does a prism do? It's obvious a spy agency isn't trying to communicate how their program works to everyone who stumbles across their codename.
- wavefunction 13y agoThey always seem to love clever acronyms that are tangentially related to whatever it deals with, like USAPATRIOT Act is actually about how to not be a good US patriot.
- irishcoffee 13y agoGenerally (pretty much always) the name of a government program is an acronym. I wouldn't try and draw much meaning from it.
- latj 13y agoIt is a dangerous game they are playing when the U.S. Congress knowingly allows lies to go into the record. http://www.propublica.org/article/defenders-of-nsa-surveillance-web-omit-most-of-mumbai-plotters-story http://www.propublica.org/article/defenders-of-nsa-surveilla...
- freddealmeida 13y agoFar more dangerous when American citizens allow it as well.
- prawks 13y agoNow would be a great time to write to your Congressmen to inform them of your (and your friends'/neighbors') displeasure.
- enraged_camel 13y agoI'm very interested in whether writing to Congresspeople actually does anything. Have there been any studies done that show any correlation between number of calls/letters a politician's office receives, and how they actually vote on bills proposed?
- gee_totes 13y agoIdk, but empirical evidence suggests call-ins against SOPA were successful.
- mindcrime 13y agoWell, at least one member of Congress is working to make a big stink out of the perjury issue: http://hotair.com/archives/2013/06/12/amash-to-clapper-perjury-is-a-serious-crime/ http://hotair.com/archives/2013/06/12/amash-to-clapper-perju...
- Afforess 13y agoAmash has been a great representative for Michigan. I'm extremely lucky to have him as my house representative. He campaigned on complete transparency and posts writeups and explanations for every single decision or vote he makes. I'm not completely sold on his libertarian views, but these days I value a politician who doesn't lie to me over their political ideology.
- Taylorious 13y agoAs a Michigan resident I second this. I don't support his politics really, but he is the perfect example of what a politician is supposed to do for his constituents. I often visit his FB page to see what he has been up to. He always has very thorough summaries of what he voted on and why he voted the way he did. Simply fantastic. I can't imagine how he deals with his slithering counterparts on a day to day basis.
- socillion 13y agoOriginal statement, for anyone curious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwiUVUJmGjs&t=6m42s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwiUVUJmGjs&t=6m42s
- nostromo 13y agoA few more are taking on the phone record issue directly: > H.R. 2014, the Telephone Records Protection Act, was introduced by Rep. Justin Amash (R-Mich.), Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), Rep. Mick Mulvaney (R-S.C.) and Rep. Jared Polis (D-Colo.) and would require court approval for the government to demand phone records from service providers. It's also been fun to watch Jared Polis' tweets mocking the NSA: https://twitter.com/jaredpolis https://twitter.com/jaredpolis For those not aware, Polis was an internet startup guy before going into politics.
- salimmadjd 13y agoThe moment the "House of Representative" changed from representing the people to representing just a few we should have realized our Democracy is changing to an Oligarchy. So let's stop pretending and stop using "Democracy" in our conversation.
- rosser 13y agoThe US is not a "Democracy", and never has been. It's a Republic. You conflate those two things at your peril.
- arjie 13y agoA curious distinction. To me it appears as if the US is a constitutional democratic republic and an indirect democracy. The two terms are not in opposition.
- rosser 13y agoThe point of making the distinction is to emphasize where the power actually lies.
- alexqgb 13y agoThere is no "the power" in a system of divided government. That's the whole point of a system of divided government. Power is distributed. The people have some, their representatives have some, the judiciary has some, the executive has some, the press has some, etc. Ideally, the distribution is designed in a way that maintains a stable set of checks and balances between the various centers. More to the point, "Democracy" has a fairly broad meaning, and encompasses a range of systems and traditions. You'd have to be exceedingly pedantic to insist that using it to describe any form aside from a pure, direct democracy is a misuse of language.
- baddox 13y agoAnyone can argue all day over the semantics of "where the power actually lies." I would say that it lies in the hands of people who frequently use physical weapons to harm and threaten to harm others, which for the most part is government.
- ccarter84 13y agoI'd be quite surprised if they went at this guy with anywhere near the ferocity they went after that idiotic IRS chief's testimony.
- protomyth 13y agoI agree to a point[1]. The establishment Republicans will give the NSA a pass along with most Democrats (no waves for our guy). The younger Republicans are going after all three current scandals pretty hard (Benghazi[2], IRS, NSA). Plus, there is the distraction of the Immigration reform bill[3] to contend with. 1) although FBI Director Robert Mueller got some very nasty questions on NSA and IRS today (Jun-13-2013) 2) this is going to keep coming back until there is some clarity of the timeline 3) I wish the Senate was working on something to fix immigration instead of crafting a bill that won't pass the House and will give talking points for 2014
- ISL 13y ago"Least untrue" - perhaps clocks do strike thirteen. Doubleplus ungood.
- dsuth 13y ago"No sir. Not wittingly." WTF is that! Synonymous with "No sir. Mostly." These weasel words are ridiculous, and the fact that they stand up in a congressional hearing, is mind-boggling.
- tlrobinson 13y ago"In other words, they were all lying to the public and, under our new relativistic world, a lie told by everyone is treated as the truth." That sounds terrifyingly like something out of "1984".
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoSome are complicit. The ones in the know can't say anything without becoming leakers themselves.
- bane 13y agoIf you ever think you can't be powerful, if even for a moment, remember this. A highschool dropout has been, for a moment, more powerful than the DNI, the Director the NSA, the members of Congress who knew about this and the President. He's stirred the lords of nations and brought fear to the fear makers. Was he right? I can't speak to that, but was he powerful? I can say yes.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoHouse, Senate Intel. Cmtes. Receive NSA Briefings http://www.c-span.org/Events/House-Senate-Intel-Cmtes-Receive-NSA-Briefings/10737440047-2/ http://www.c-span.org/Events/House-Senate-Intel-Cmtes-Receiv... In which Keith Alexander claims to have stopped "dozens" of terrorist attacks, and that too much disclosure will "cause" attacks. Mike Rogers (R-Mich) and Dutch Ruppersberger (D-Md) then go on to confess to the world that the US hires lowly high school dropouts, and gives them high security top secret clearance; but in the next breath claims that you shouldn't believe anything Snowden says because he is a high school dropout who can't hold a job. Then they go on to imply that Snowden is working with the Chinese. Claim that whistleblower laws would've protected Snowden (I bet Thomas Drake and Bill Binney might beg to differ). The two congressmen sound more like used car salesmen to me, and tell what sounds like more lies, half-truths, and cute word games. Rogers claims "at least 10 terror attacks averted"
- jbooth 13y agoHere's how you avert a terrorist attack: 1) Find some idiot talking about how he'd like to blow something up on his phone 2) Approach idiot, try to sell him explosives 3) If he's dumb enough to say "ok" out loud at any point, then slap on the cuffs, you foiled a terrorist attack, you're officially a hero. It's a numbers game.
- duncan_bayne 13y ago> 1) Find some idiot talking about how he'd like to blow something up on his phone That could be me after a day of working with certain legacy systems.
- victorf 13y ago"Terrorist and black-hat hacker Duncan Bayne was arrested yesterday after posting his bombing plot on a forum for hackers. Lawmakers state that he never would have been caught without the aid of PRISM, and drafted new legislature allowing body scans at entrances to legacy systems. Next up: why gay marriage is going to destroy traditional families and why you should be concerned exclusively with preventing it and not care about, say, the Fourth Amendment."
- ChuckMcM 13y agoMy Grandfather (and Jonathan's great uncle I believe), who was US Attorney, would seriously approve of the questions Jonathan raises. The way to move this forward is to put these folks on the spot with HR 2014 and other amendments which would curtail the powers that have been given to the Intelligence agencies under the guise of the war on terror.
- ig1 13y agoThe question has to be asked, were there members of congress or the executive who were aware of the perjury but failed to take any action about it ?
- mindcrime 13y agoOK, in light of the Snowden reveal, how is it that none of the press seemed to find this revelation and link it with everything else, and report it? A former FBI counter-terrorism guy went on CNN, and admitted that they have everything, including content, over a month ago. http://dailycaller.com/2013/06/13/do-americans-love-big-brother/ http://dailycaller.com/2013/06/13/do-americans-love-big-brot... http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://rt.com/usa/bill-binney-nsa-leaks-546/&strip=1 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- grappler 13y agoPeople say lots of things, all the time. Nothing gets attention like a leaked set of Top Secret files.
- bobwaycott 13y ago> Our leaders have embraced that core view of Lenin that “A Lie told often enough becomes the truth.” Excuse me, but core view? Injecting the supposed words of Lenin, sans any context or source attribution at all, from which one might be able to understand the purpose behind the words, and the author wants to throw this in at the end and call it Lenin's core view? Bullshit. That's akin to saying Jesus' core view was "My god, my god, why have you forsaken me?"
- pvdm 13y ago"war is peace freedom is slavery ignorance is strength" We spy on you to keep you free.
- vidarh 13y agoSomewhat off topic, I'm trying to find a source for the supposed Lenin quotation ("A Lie told often enough becomes the truth") as I wanted to see the context. Anyone know what the source might be? There are a slew of repeats of the quotation online, yet none of them appears to include a cite. I've tried searching various archives of Lenins works, and wider archives like marxists.org that might have included references to it by other authors but have come up empty. It could very well be hard to find because the common wording of it is paraphrased, though.. But it would be rather hilariously ironic if it is misattributed, and so providing its own proof...
- samwyse 13y agoPlease sign my petition to prosecute James R. Clapper Jr., director of national intelligence, for perjury in his denial of spying on Americans. http://wh.gov/l3gRA http://wh.gov/l3gRA