5 ms·
What If Scientists Didn’t Compete?
- jwb119 18y agofor a scientist, he doesn't make a very scientific argument: >His experiment in cooperation with four other laboratories, he said, yielded “a very compelling body of data validated by many labs,” and has inspired the researchers to go on freely sharing with one another.”< Would competition have produced a _more compelling body of data? Very likely if you ask me.
- tokenadult 18y agoWould competition have produced a _more compelling body of data? Possibly not, depending on how the experimental stratification was allocated among the labs. The press release about the research http://newsroom.ucr.edu/news_item.html?action=page&id=2077 http://newsroom.ucr.edu/news_item.html?action=page&id=20... linked to from the submitted article doesn't make clear the nature of the collaboration among the various laboratories, but makes the claim that the previous competitive atmosphere among labs led to results that could not be replicated. Apparently the currently announced results have already been replicated.
- scott_s 18y agoI doubt it. Competing research teams involves a lot of duplicated effort. Novelty is usually required for work to be published, and if you're scooped, there's two options: drop the project, or find some way to differentiate yourself from prior work. In theory, the difference you come up with should make your publication still a worthwhile addition, but in practice, I don't think it usually is.
- asciilifeform 18y ago> Competing research teams involves a lot of duplicated effort. Competing anything involves massive duplication of effort and wasted talent. One day people will realize this. http://sciencecareers.sciencemag.org/career_magazine/previous_issues/articles/2009_02_13/caredit.a0900021 http://sciencecareers.sciencemag.org/career_magazine/previou... "Tournament markets... discard huge amounts of very high-quality talent, training, and skill. In the mythic version, science rewards effort and ability... In the real world, casting off large numbers of extremely capable people is simply how a tournament market works." For as long as everyone believes that the only alternative to cutthroat competition is sclerotic dictatorship, much human effort will continue to be thrown away in this manner. I give you Be, its patents bought up by patent trolls to prevent its technologies from ever being used: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BeOS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BeOS I give you Symbolics Genera, languishing in obscurity forever because of our society's obsession with property rights.
- frossie 18y agoThe implication that scientists compete due to their egos is not totally accurate. Yes, some do have egos, but like the programming world many are just geeky types who want to find out the answers and are happy to co-operate if that helps. What forces them to compete is the money. When your entire research program is based on your having to convince your funding agency to give the bucks to you and not to the other guy, you create competition and moreover you are rewarding the people who are the most competitive. I agree with the point of the article that sometimes better science would get done with more openness and co-operation (I have seen numerous examples of that in my field), but absent an infinite supply of money I don't see how it can be done. I'd love to know though!
- paulbaumgart 18y agoCould it be enforced, or at least encouraged, by the funding agencies? That still leaves the problem of reputation-building; a paper where an individual is only one of 20 authors probably isn't so impressive on a CV.
- scott_s 18y agoNot just reputation building, but getting the researcher merit badge in the first place - the PhD. A PhD dissertation is expected to be the work of the student; it's supposed to prove that the student can do self-directed, novel research in their field. Of course, people do defend dissertations based on work that was a collaboration with others, but I think we're considering a level of collaboration not usually seen.
- azanar 18y agoThat still leaves the problem of reputation-building; a paper where an individual is only one of 20 authors probably isn't so impressive on a CV. Is the effort expended for the paper able to be divided cleanly into chunks 1/20th the size, to be credited to each author in turn? Doing research, or any creative work, is not a manufacturing process; the output does not inevitably scale linearly based on the number of inputs. It is possible that a paper could describe something that was very impressive for 20 people to accomplish.
- amichail 18y agoAcademia tries to give you some freedom as if you were managing your own company. But unlike a standard company, you seek funding by submitting proposals to your competition (!). And unlike a standard company, you have grad students instead of employees who may do what you want and then again may just ignore you. To top it off, you have to teach as well. Given all this, do you really think scientists would be open to have whatever remaining freedom they have taken away through greater collaboration?
- tokenadult 18y agoThe empirical finding here is that scientists can sometimes be persuaded to cooperate. How general that could be across how many disciplines, and whether the interesting institutional constraints you mention could be modified to increase cooperation, remains to be seen.
- bcl 18y agoIt sounds to me like they need to adopt an open source model of operation. That may not be possible with the current funding system so someone would need to figure out a better way to distribute funding. Wouldn't it be better for them to be sharing information and results with each other? They would be able to catch mistakes sooner (ie. before publication) and build on and verify each other's work more quickly. Imagine what it would have been like if the 'cold fusion' fiasco had ben share between more scientists sooner?
- param 18y agoNot sure I agree with this approach. I would rather have the waste of competition than 20 mediocre scientists coming together and putting out dubious research simply to protect reputations. Failure of an individual is much easier to stomach and forget.
- tokenadult 18y agoI would rather have the waste of competition than 20 mediocre scientists coming together and putting out dubious research simply to protect reputations. I would rather have neither waste nor dubious research. In the case reported in the submitted article, there is (considering the journal that has agreed to publish the research) an important research finding that had not been achieved under the former system of dueling research labs. In this case, it appears that getting the various labs to collaborate both reduced wastage of research resources and improved the quality of the research result. I have no idea how generalizable this happy result might be in other fields of science.
- nialllarkin 18y agoThe author impresses upon us that the scientific community is competitive. And that collaboration is rare. These are contradictory ideas. In competitive environments, collaboration is far from unusual. In competive environments, it is usual for collaboration to break out between competing individuals. This is especially true in the most cut-throat competitive environments. In a truly competitive environment, survival depends on the individual gaining a competitive edge. The most effective way for the individual to capture a gain is by joining forces with competitors for mutual gain. In a truly competitive environment its: collaborate or perish. In conclusion, the scientific community is not nearly as competitive as the author is inclined to believe.
- jleyank 18y agoIn the old times, young faculty members who collaborated rather than did original work didn't get tenure and so left "in failure". Graduate students can't collaborate as that's not the purpose of the exercise (as others here have written). Post-docs CAN collaborate, but they're trying to make a name for themselves which is somewhat anti-collaboration. This leaves the tenured profs, but they're off chasing money to fund their groups. Not a great system, which is why I left it.
- timr 18y agoI'd refine that second statement: it's not usually in a graduate student's best interest to collaborate on a project, but the student's PI typically has a competing interest (and a longer time horizon), and so collaborations still happen. The smart PI just manages the risk by assigning collaborative projects to his students -- he gets to reap the rewards of the rare good collaborations, whereas the bad collaborations merely crush the unfortunate grad student to whom they are assigned...and nothing of value is lost. Part of the game of grad school is recognizing and fending off the "collaborators" who will do nothing but slow you down and/or take credit for your work, while still remaining open to that rare collaboration that can make your career -- the two most successful graduate students I know basically walked into career-defining projects as a result of collaborations that were handed to them in their first year. Of course, you can be torpedoed by a bad collaboration at any stage of your career, so this isn't a dilemma unique to graduate students. Collaborations are useful only so long as you're getting more than you're putting in.
- lutorm 18y agoWhile I have nothing against collaboration, there is a place for "competition" if you by competition mean "independently confirmed results". In the specific case I'm most familiar with, there are several research groups making software that does the same thing (n-body simulations, hydrodynamics, radiation transfer) and it is a massive duplicated effort. However, I don't think it's necessarily wasted. In my mind, having everyone collaborate on one code would vastly increase the risk of results being incorrect due to bugs or simply unjustified approximations. When several independent groups perform the same calculation, with different pieces of software using different approximation methods, you can have more faith in that the result is correct. It's the fact that the academic "system" values being the first to publish a result that pushes everyone towards a competition at all costs approach, but that's only one of the things about incentives for scientists that can be criticized. I spent my PhD thesis writing a piece of software that I then released under the GPL. It's possible I could get more papers by close-sourcing it and only working with people that would collaborate with me, but I made the calculated gamble that giving the community a free tool in the end would boost my recognition faster due to a wider adoption and more citations.
- lutorm 18y agoActually, the article is mislabeled, I think. It seems to not so much argue against competition, but rather for the public dissemination of data. Writing papers but withholding the data so that no-one can reproduce your results is very different from simply trying to be the first to complete a study but then publish all data so it's available to others. In my mind, writing papers but withholding the data that your results are based on is a highly dubious practice.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- tybris 18y agoIf they didn't compete there wouldn't be any evolution.
- Tichy 18y agoDoesn't science already work like a gift economy, at least in parts?
- roc 18y agoPerhaps we just need to put strings on public funding so that study/experiment data is made publicly available (after a short period of exclusivity). It wouldn't be too different from the Patent system. In that, in exchange for a limited-time monopoly, you agree to publish the details of your invention to further the state of the art. It might also help scientists learn from each others mistakes, as it would also catalog -failed- projects. Something journals don't do and which doubtlessly results in redundant efforts.