51 ms·
Man on the run: Former CIA spies on what they'd do if they were Snowden
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- varjag 13y agoI never seen so many former federal employees promoting their books in one post.
- mahmud 13y agoAnd not just any federal employees: spooks. Gotta milk that James Bond cachet, I guess ;-)
- varjag 13y agoIt's funny how they all seem to be rather theoretic, context-free comments, not taking the details of Snowden's circumstances in account. He wasn't really trying to hide, otherwise he wouldn't have made a public statement from a known location. And it seems most of those spooks interviewed never actually had to run for their life, putting their theories to the test.
- tn13 13y agoI will not be surprised if he is found dead by killing himself like Aron Swarz.
- 6d0debc071 13y ago"How do you know it was suicide." "There was a note. Jimmy, have they found the note yet?..."
- tn13 13y agoI think the best alternative for him is to get himself arrested in a wide public eye. I am absolutely sure that several people would come up in his support. He can turn himself into a symbol. Any court case around him will be closely followed and analyzed.
- codeulike 13y agoDid he plan for a picture of his face to be plastered all over every news site for a week? Presumably yes, in which case he's probably not planning on trying to disappear.
- Pherdnut 13y agoAre the CIA basically the not-so-bad guys now? Seems like they haven't been busted for doing anything super-nasty lately.
- cglace 13y agoThey are too busy toppling countries.
- rdl 13y agoAside from running drones everywhere except Afghanistan itself (and even there I assume they run some). All those Pakistan, Yemen, etc. civilian casualties due to drones = CIA. And secret prisons, both gitmo and worse ("black sites", many of which are still unknown to the public.) Ongoing.
- joshAg 13y agono the nsa is still cuter, cuddlier, and less deadly than the cia.
- fakeer 13y agoThere was some novel where I read NSA has their own resident tough guys. was that pure fiction?
- rdl 13y agoThere are plenty of military assigned to NSA, to do things like operate SIGINT aircraft, or handle key distribution to the military on the COMSEC side. NSA doesn't do much field intelligence stuff; it's mainly radio/etc. intercepts on military bases, aircraft, ships, etc. Their regular site security is either military or contracted out to Wackenhut or other private security companies, after all (which is apparently what one of Snowden's early jobs was). The real tough guys of the signals world are the Army's ISA, who do tactical sigint and killing, all in one. I'm sure ISA and NSA cooperate a lot. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_Support_Activity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_Support_Activity They're the guys who caught Pablo Escobar. Essentially the most secretive of the tier-1 JSOC units. IMO, the world's most awesome job for a bofh sysadmin -- you get to listen in to enemy communications, and use their improper security procedures to find them, and then punish them (by killing them).
- mindcrime 13y agoYou almost wonder if he'd be better off "hiding in plain site" if he does intend to hide, by staying in the (continental) US. I mean, the USA is a BIG place, and outside the major cities, there are some damn remote areas in the US, where the population density is pretty low, and you could probably hole up out of site for quite some time and rarely even be seen. Look at how long Eric Rudolph stayed hidden in the Appalachians, for example. Although, to be fair, while he may not have been a "trained operative" he was apparently a survivalist type, and had quite a bit of skill at living in the woods and living off the land. I have no idea where Snowden falls on that. But still, it's not that hard to find a job in the US doing some kind of manual labor, where they don't ask for any ID, pay cash, don't pay any taxes, and where the crew usually all go back to the bosses house and burn a few joints after work. If you're willing to swing a hammer and can run a mitre-saw and/or rip a piece of plywood on a table-saw, without cutting your hand off, you can probably find a construction job working "under the table". Finding a place to say would be tougher, since most (all?) US states require hotels / motels / etc. to collect ID information. But if you can find somebody friendly to let you crash on their couch, or find a low-paid motel clerk in some hick town, who'll take a small "donation" in order to rent you a room without ID... Bus around the country, move periodically, and dye your hair a different color, grow a beard, let your hair grow out, and you could probably stay hidden in the US for quite some time.
- skwirl 13y agoTo me, living in the woods as a survivalist is a fate worse than prison, and when you are eventually caught you have to serve the entire prison sentence on top of the time you spent eating squirrels and freezing in the woods. But there are definitely a few notable cases of wanted people who have lived in plain site for a long time before being captured. A convicted serial rapist named Gary Alan Irving was caught a couple months ago after 34 years on the run living near Portland, ME. He married and had children and grandchildren during this time. I think you could totally do it in many cases. But I'm not sure that you could do it in this case. Snowden's face has been plastered all over newspapers, TV, the Internet, etc. Video of him, including his voice, has been all over TV and the internet. He has some distinguishing features that would make it fairly easy to confirm his identity. Also, hawkish conservatives (of which there are many in rural areas) are going to view this man as a traitor and delight in turning him in. If he did stay here he probably would have many people willing to harbor him and give him food and shelter. But eventually they are going to slip up and he is going to be caught.
- kunai 13y agoThis really sounds like something straight out of some Ludlum book, which, incidentally, I loved. This is by no means advice for Snowden, but it's worth a shot. When you're on the run, burn your passport. Get rid of your wallet except for cash. If you can, withdraw as much cash as possible and close your bank accounts. Toss your wallet in a fire, taking only cash. Get rid of any physical attributes that could be used to easily find you. If you wear the same type of shirt every day, wear a different one every day. Shave your facial hair, and get a new hairdo. Be a nomad. Sleep in homeless shelters, and go from place to place, never staying in one location too long. Set false breadcrumbs, like Facebook logins, at strategic locations. Map out a route of where you plan to go, and map out the route where you'll leave linked IPs, logins, property along the way, maybe make a call or two with a prepaid phone and dispose of it. When your money supply is running low, forge your own identity. Create a new name, with a new ethnicity. Get a job. Live there for a while, never getting too close to anyone. Disappear. Get off the grid permanently. If the United States approves a pardon, then show up only after 4 months, it could be a decoy. Always stay on the run. And never. Trust. Anyone. ------ for added effect, listen to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dc7qiosq4m4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dc7qiosq4m4
- tn13 13y agoWithdraw cash ? really ? I am sure triggers have been set on his card. The moment he puts his card in an ATM, the police will probably reach there in 5 minutes. At least they will know his location to begin with. They then will have to just create a perimeter around him. Firstly, before he decided to be a whistle-blower he should have made some plans. If he has not, I would say just go deep into some forest and live there like a hermit for at least a year.
- jiggy2011 13y agoI guess the idea would be to stuff your pockets full before you blow the whistle.
- tn13 13y agoIn that case he could have planned everything in a much better way. He could have gone to a much safer place such as a European country like Iceland or Sweden or he could have simply got lost in the crowd in India.
- runjake 13y agoWith all due respect to the former CIA officers, there's a bunch of poor and outdated advice in this article. The one I'll point out is using a dead person's birth certificate to get ID and an SSN. The databases for the death index were cleaned up after 9/11 and if you try this, your attempt will be flagged and you'll likely be visited by law enforcement pretty shortly. You will not get an ID nor an SSN. The best way to hide is to not leave any (legitimate) money/electronic trails. Practice disinformation. For example, use a credit card to buy a plane ticket to Bangkok on Saturday, then go buy a bus ticket to Mongolia with cash for Friday and similar tactics. It won't stop professionals from eventually finding you, but it will buy you (sometimes significant) time. All this is pointless because almost certainly the US IC knows exactly where Snowden is already. It's laughable that anyone believes they're still searching for Snowden.
- jlgreco 13y agoI assume they will know if you don't use a plane ticket that they know you bought, but the idea is that by the time they could know that you are already in a different place? That is pretty clever. I wonder if tickets with less verification could be even more effective (for example, two bus tickets; one with cash and one with credit for a day later.) Might buy you more time, but the lower ticket price might also make it less convincing.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI believe by "state" they meant "nation," not "administrative region in the United States." Do you work in intelligence?
- exit 13y agohey, maybe he has some bitcoins
- einhverfr 13y agoIn a couple points. Much of the advice may be more valid for overt CIA operations than in Snowden's case. Snowden is writing his own rulebook and it is based on a fairly narrow array of relatively novel tactics plus more standard tools I suspect he picked up in his special forces training (remember he has at least some special forces training). A careful look at Snowden's tactics is that he is working off an understanding at how to play various groups and people off eachother. He has a keen sense of what everyone's interests are. His goal is not to be invisible but rather to be too hot to handle for anyone.
- vellum 13y agoI don't think he got much if any special forces training. Basic + AIT is about 13 weeks. Jump school is 3 weeks. He left after four months, so that's before or at SF preliminary tryouts. He probably picked up a few things when he was working in the intel field, though.
- taktix 13y agoI wish more people understood the situation like you, but there are many fickle HN users who are silly putty in the hands of big media.
- einhverfr 13y agoAlso according to some sources he has been planning for years (according to some sources he held off in 2008 because he was hoping for action by Obama). He is uncommonly bright and prepared. I don't think the choice of regions or timing can be a coincidence at all. He announced he was in Hong Kong when the leaders of both Hong Kong and China were in the US, and he has managed to very skilfully play various groups off eachother. He almost comes across as too prepared. Occasionally I have wondered if someone was coaching him, but if he has been planning for years, he could have half a million dollars stashed somewhere (or at least a sizeable fraction of that), and he may simply have spotted his opportunity and known it wouldn't come again.
- antimagic 13y ago
- rdl 13y agoI assume he's actually in a journalist's apartment, not going out. Intelligence agencies may know where he is, but no one is going to go after him.
- syncerr 13y agoIf he's smart, he's not even in Hong Kong anymore, nor has he been for some time. Prerecorded video explicitly stating where he's located? Seems like a ruse.
- toddh 13y agoA large house in a suburban neighborhood in Pakistan has proven to be an excellent place to hide.
- gadders 13y agoYes, but you need ISI support to pull that one off.
- guelo 13y agoThe CIA is not going to disappear him now that he went public. And he can't slip out of Hong Kong without everyone knowing. Seems to me that this can only workout in one of two ways. Either he requests and receives asylum from some 3rd party country before the US requests extradition so that Hong Kong can't stop him from leaving. But I suspect he has a short time window to make this happen, maybe only days before the US delivers the extradition request. At which point Hong Kong will probably take his passport. If that doesn't happen then it'll just work its ways though the Hong Kong courts. If he attempts a legal delay and obstruction tactic similar to Assange it could take years. Meanwhile the US demonization will continue and the US/China/Hong Kong politics will wax and wane. But most probably he'd end up in a US jail eventually, with all the political fallout that that will entail.
- rdtsc 13y agoHe could be somewhat valuable for the Chinese in countering some PR claims against itself -- "China is monitoring dissidents", "China is hacking peaceful countries" etc etc. All that is true, but now that they have him in exchange of asylum he could become a talking head for them so they can now say "Aha, but US can't tell us anything concerting privacy, look at what they are doing!" And then invite him on a TV show to describe all the massive NSA surveillance apparatus. What would he do? Would he cooperate with the traditional enemy? That might put his motives in question and he would become an easier target to slander. ("aha, he was a traitor all along, a Chinese spy etc etc.")
- aptwebapps 13y agoIt wouldn't work for the reason in your second paragraph: he would loose too much credibility if he was seen as a mouthpiece for China.
- ra 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised if he left Hong Kong before we'd even heard of Edward Snowden. I imagine getting overland from China to Europe wouldn't be too difficult (we're talking high values of difficult here). Equally he could have previously acquired an alternateidentity during his planning, and might even be in South America by now.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- itazula 13y agoAll of your comments have been duly noted. ;-)
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoEveryone seems to think this guy should go and hide. But if he is hiding he can't defend himself publicly. I think we all know that the US can eventually find him. We also know that if he is found cowering in some hole, far from media scrutiny, that he's likely to be killed, or secretly rendered for torture. Retreating to a semi-friendly place like HK where the press might not be completely captured by US influence, where the gov't might not be completely pliable may have been the best thing he could have done.
- itazula 13y agoWhile trekking The Peak (formerly Victoria Peak) in Hong Kong, I ran into a housekeeper walking the family dog. We saw a group of men getting into a very nice car. She mentioned to me that the license plate on the car allows them to travel into China without the usual checks.