8 ms·
Booz Allen fires leaker Snowden
- staunch 13y agoThis is seriously the weirdest part of this story so far. Why is it news that this guy, who clearly has resigned, is being "fired"? And why was his precise salary released? Why is it being reported on? Why does it matter that he did, or did not, finish high school? It feels like some kind of desperate attempt to disparage him. As if someone hopes it will sound like he's a disgruntled former employee that was fired. Or that he was some low level hack of an employee. And yet no one is disputing that he worked for our spy agencies for the better part of a decade, or that he had a job that would tend to give him significant access. No one is disputing anything he's said at all, as far as I can tell. This shit is irrelevant.
- jrockway 13y agoThis is called the twenty-four hour news cycle. People want to hear more about this story, but there is nothing more that anyone knows. So we dive into the human element, speculate as to "why", and so on. People keep clicking the ads, so it must be what they want. (We read it, right?)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 13y agoI don't think so. Let's say that media became subscription-sponsored instead. You have a subscription to the New York Times and your friend has a subscription to Fox News. She says, "hey, did you hear that gossipy gossip about the NSA" and you say, "no, the NYT isn't reporting anything about that". Then you cancel your subscription to the Times and switch to Fox. I guess it's a race to the bottom, that's all.
- gohrt 13y agoBut under a subscription model, the best set of stories wins, not the best set of clickbait headlines. So if people want the gossip, then yes, subscriptions would still have quality problems. But if people want good information, then the publisher would not profit from serving crappy content under an enticing headline.
- randallsquared 13y agoDo you doubt that people mostly want the gossip? I was about to say that people don't really know the difference between "good information" about current events, and gossip. After thinking about how to word that, though, it occurred to me that maybe there really isn't a difference.
- adamnemecek 13y agoIsn't that how news used to work :-)?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bob13579 13y agoMaybe because federal taxpayers paid his salary?
- adamnemecek 13y agoI actually posted the article since I found it amusing more than anything. As if anyone was still wondering what happened to his position.
- Ygg2 13y agoThey'll probably rewrite the PR so that he was fired before he quitted. Snowden will be a fired, highschool dropout with no job.
- asveikau 13y ago> As if anyone was still wondering what happened to his position. Maybe it'll show up in the next "Who's Hiring" thread here on HN. :-)
- adamnemecek 13y agoIt would be pretty funny if he just came back to work next Monday and pretended like nothing had happend. "Bill, have you seen the game last night? What, why is everyone looking at me? Do I have something stuck in my teeth again?"
- majelix 13y agoIf I had to guess, it's http://careers.boozallen.com/job/Honolulu-Systems-Administrator%2C-Junior-Job-HI-96801/2653617/ http://careers.boozallen.com/job/Honolulu-Systems-Administra... . At least you have a starting point for salary negotiations, and an easy talking point on ethics.
- epoxyhockey 13y agoAnd why was his precise salary released A little known fact is that thousands of companies participate in this (including Booz Allen): http://www.theworknumber.com/Employees/index.asp http://www.theworknumber.com/Employees/index.asp This is an Equifax-owned entity that may resell salary information and dates worked at a company. It is possible that a reporter just bought the salary info, but in this case it does seem that Booz Allen plainly released it. More info: http://redtape.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/01/30/16762661-exclusive-your-employer-may-share-your-salary-and-equifax-might-sell-that-data http://redtape.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/01/30/16762661-exclusi...
- spikels 13y agoBooz Allen added Snowden's salary in the revised press release announcing his firing. Strange. Here's the text of the current version of the press release dated 6/11: Booz Allen can confirm that Edward Snowden, 29, was an employee of our firm for less than 3 months, assigned to a team in Hawaii. Snowden, who had a salary at the rate of $122,000, was terminated June 10, 2013 for violations of the firm’s code of ethics and firm policy. News reports that this individual has claimed to have leaked classified information are shocking, and if accurate, this action represents a grave violation of the code of conduct and core values of our firm. We will work closely with our clients and authorities in their investigation of this matter. http://www.boozallen.com/media-center/press-releases/48399320/statement-reports-leaked-information-060913 http://www.boozallen.com/media-center/press-releases/4839932... Here is an earlier (original?) version of the same press release dated 6/9: Booz Allen can confirm that Edward Snowden, 29, has been an employee of our firm for less than 3 months, assigned to a team in Hawaii. News reports that this individual has claimed to have leaked classified information are shocking, and if accurate, this action represents a grave violation of the code of conduct and core values of our firm. We will work closely with our clients and authorities in their investigation of this matter. http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-09/booz-allen-promptly-condemns-snowdens-grave-ethical-violation http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-09/booz-allen-promptly... Edit: add press release text Edit2: add original press release text
- gohrt 13y ago
- aspensmonster 13y ago>It feels like some kind of desperate attempt to disparage him. Not desperate at all; the tactic is wildly successful. Just look at what happened with Wikileak's work with its editor Assange and source Manning. The same tactics will come up against the Guardian with journalist Greenwald and source Snowden. The situations are similar in enough ways.
- espadrine 13y agoSlowly, they will try to justify its conviction and torture. From what I read, he is ready for that. I wish companies like Google and Microsoft asked for his amnesty. Would that even help?
- kintamanimatt 13y agoI was going to say that looking at it through a more cynical lens it's to discredit him, but I'm not sure such a lens is required. The difference in reported income, the firing, the criminal investigation, and his job being re-listed as a junior level position are tools to do this. The reason for this smearing could be a PR stunt to shore up investors' confidence (and therefore the stock price), or it could be character assassination and to make casual readers think this was a low-level employee with problems telling the truth and holding down a job. The article that's linked half way through paints Booz Allen as a wonderful, benevolent employer that was gracious enough to hire someone without formal credentials (in this job climate, no less!). It's most certainly to bolster its reputation on Wall Street and also to make people think Snowden was an ungrateful chump for giving up such a cushy position. I've seen it reported in other articles, but I didn't see mention in this article about him not finishing HS. Was this original article edited?
- JPKab 13y agoBooz took zero risks hiring this guy. Zero chances at all. He has a TS/SCI clearance combined with whatever bullshit IT security certs gov't contracts demand, which means he is a guaranteed revenue source. The risk that was taken was giving him a TS clearance at all. I don't agree with or like it, but the clearance process is supposed to eliminate people who don't like authority or the socially approved path. Somebody who drops out of high school despite being intelligent is clearly not someone who fits these criteria.
- downandout 13y agoCNN has been focusing on trashing this guy since his identity first came to light. Their reporting has also been quick to minimize the extent and importance of this scandal. Partisan reporting at its finest - they are going to be the last ones on Obama's sinking ship.
- sage_joch 13y agoAnother thing I noticed is that every Onion story related to the scandal has been pro-NSA (today I learned pro-NSA humor exists). It reminded me of the recent gun control debates in which every Onion story related to that was pro gun control. I'm not saying they're part of a larger concerted effort to sway public opinion, but it does make me question their integrity as a comedic organization.
- Vivtek 13y agoPro-gun control? You don't remember the one with the gorillas, I think it was, advocating for gorilla control and with people complaining that the keeping of gorillas in public was a Constitutional right, and even if a few people in stores get savaged by gorillas occasionally, that was a small price to pay for freedom?
- sage_joch 13y agoUm, that one was extremely pro gun control. Read it again. "Gorilla Sales Skyrocket After Latest Gorilla Attack". This is making fun of people who buy guns in the aftermath of shootings, and who seek the preservation of 2nd amendment rights. It argues (by analogy) that such people are silly to fight for such antiquated rights, and that there would be complete chaos if everyone owned a gun.
- Vivtek 13y agoIndeed - I think my brain short-circuited there somehow and I took "pro" to mean "anti".
- 13y ago
- raverbashing 13y agoThe funny thing about this high school thing is that it could go both ways. "So, they hire people that haven't even finished High School to take care of top secret information"" But since this is CNN and is not the official spin it's ignored
- signed0 13y agoWhile it seems to be working, the worse they make him sound the more foolish they look for hiring him in the first place. They are just further ruining any remaining reputation they have for being able to keep privileged data secret.
- hkmurakami 13y agoironically I, as someone who holds pieces of papers from some of the most highly esteemed institutions of education in this country and others, listening to Snowden speak for 30 seconds and digesting the implication of his actions has easily convinced me that he is a man of greater intellect, integrity and courage than myself or many of my similarly degree-equipped classmates. the lack of a degree makes his star shine even brighter for me.
- JPKab 13y agoYou, sir, are a true intellectual. I agree with you. I suspect a lot of the journalistic sniping is due to the fact that the writers invested heavily in pieces of paper, and years later have a significantly lower salary. Their bitterness and envy shapes their thoughts.
- hkmurakami 13y agoThanks. That means a lot to me. :)
- znowi 13y ago> This is seriously the weirdest part of this story so far. Why is it news that this guy, who clearly has resigned, is being "fired"? And why was his precise salary released? Why is it being reported on? Why does it matter that he did, or did not, finish high school? It's called "character attack" to discredit the source. Same happened to Assange.
- mjolk 13y agoI don't think it's an attack for Booz Allen to release the numbers to clear up a lie he (Snowden) made in an interview in which he was referencing the company. Imagine that you're an employee for the company with a degree and a decade of experience or even a shareholder. Now you read that your employer was paying some low-level contractor 200k/yr in Hawaii. As an exec at Booz Allen, why wouldn't you try to minimize your damage?
- madaxe 13y agoOnce you take into account a ~30% annual bonus (normal for BAH), a company car, and relocation expenses - all of which you can be sure he had, as they're also de rigeur for NGO contractors, that $200k figure is about right.
- znowi 13y agoSee? It works :)
- mjolk 13y agoIf by "once you take into account," you mean "if you pretend/arbitrarily decide he received," then sure. I'd like to see your source that states that a 30% annual bonus is typical.
- madaxe 13y agohttp://www.glassdoor.com/Bonuses/Booz-Allen-Hamilton-Bonuses-E2735.htm http://www.glassdoor.com/Bonuses/Booz-Allen-Hamilton-Bonuses...
- UVB-76 13y ago> And why was his precise salary released? He claimed to be earning $200,000 in his statements to The Guardian — his intention, presumably, to emphasise the extent of the sacrifice he has made in releasing these documents. A side-effect of that revelation is that Booz Allen Hamilton have been reported on in a decidedly unfavourable light, as the greedy contractors in cahoots with the US government to bleed the taxpayer dry. Booz Allen Hamilton obviously want to counter that notion, so have produced a much lower, slightly more reasonable, figure for his salary. As always, the truth probably lies somewhere in between. The figure Snowden gave is probably rounded up for simplicity, and the figure BAH provided is probably excluding parts of his compensation package.
- atwebb 13y agoSnowden's figure most likely includes bonueses and other perks which I've always considered part of total compenstation.
- leephillips 13y agoIf his salary is over $100,000 then he is probably "earning" over $200,000 for his employer. Also, as others have pointed out, your salary is significantly less than what you actually get paid.
- leephillips 13y ago"No one is disputing anything he's said at all" This was probably true when you wrote it eight hours ago, but in the past hour someone who should know[0] was interviewed on NPR, and said that there is no way that Snowden had the abilities and access that he claimed in an interview. She strongly disputed his claim that he had been able to "wiretap" anyone at will, sitting at his desk. [0] A professor of something like national security studies, who worked for intelligence agencies for years before academia.
- joezydeco 13y agoIt seems likely that Booz Allen has other contractors still working on NSA projects besides Snowden. There's a certain amount of damage control they need to do if they want to keep their client happy and keep the contracts coming.
- nullc 13y agoOverheard on IRC: "Mr Snowden's employer, defence contractor Booz Allen Hamilton, said on Tuesday it had fired the 29-year-old infrastructure analyst for violating its ethics code." … They found out that he had some.
- mililani 13y agoI was thinking before, how in the hell is a sys admin contractor making $200k/year??? Especially in Hawaii. $122k seems about right. Regardless, this does seem to cast some doubt about Snowden's character. Why lie? It seems like such a trivial point. At any rate, I really hope the ad hominen attacks don't sway public opinion about the gravity of the overall message: even though the messenger may be disingenuous, the government has already admitted to mass spying. 4th amendment rights are being disregarded. edit: Ok, I'm seeing all kinds of conjecturing. I know a lot of people who work as civilian IT contractors in Hawaii. I grew up there; I used to work there at Square USA; my uncle is a retired military officer who is now working for Northrop Grumman as a civilian IT contractor in Hawaii. There is NO way any civilian IT contractor is making that kind of dough in Hawaii even working tons of overtime. When my uncle was working as a civilian IT contractor in Korea back during the dot com boom, he was telling me that most of his employees were making $125k. However, most of that was tax free. So, they were making money hand over fist. Since then, he's said that salaries have stagnated and even gone down. He's a programmer and an Oracle DBA; and nowadays, he's not making more than 100k. I personally don't know anyone who is making $200k in IT. Even my friend at Goldman Sachs who has a masters degree in comp sci from Cornell is only making $125k without bonuses. And he said the bonuses are only 10%. So, really guys, the $200k is most likely baloney. I'm not buying that. But, regardless, it's a moot point. The government is screwing us over; they've already admitted to it in so much words.
- jrockway 13y agoSalary != total compensation.
- yen223 13y ago> "I was thinking before, how in the hell is a sys admin contractor making $200k/year???" Government contracts, especially defense contracts which require clearance, tend to result in inflated salaries.
- rdtsc 13y agoYap most likely, NSA billed $200/year, he was given $120/year, BAH pockets $80/year.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rikacomet 13y agomy reaction, if I was Snowden: You don't say!
- nikcub 13y agobefore somebody jumps down his throat for saying he had a salary of $200k a year, the original part of the article is as follows: > He has had "a very comfortable life" that included a salary of roughly $200,000, a girlfriend with whom he shared a home in Hawaii, a stable career, and a family he loves. The $200k part isn't in quotes, so it is possible that the writer mixed up a statement on what he previously earned, what he earned in total in the last year, or something else. The point of that part of the story was to set out just how much he was leaving behind, no doubt he had a comfortable life. I wouldn't read too much in the discrepancy between what Booz say his salary was and what it was states as in The Guardian - except that it is a bit weird for a former employer to include in a statement about a person being fired what their salary was. They likely only mentioned it because $200k was mentioned in the original article, a further attempt to discredit although a soft one.
- Taylorious 13y agoWhy are people focusing so much on the salary? Besides, for all we know that 122k is his base salary he got serious bonuses, stock options, etc and so he valued his annual earnings at close to 200k.
- ck2 13y agoLet's fire Booz | Allen | Hamilton Freaking war profiteers.
- gexla 13y agoWow? Fired? That's pretty harsh! This seems like it would be obvious. Did we really need an article for this? After the gov yanks your network access and security clearance, you aren't much help. Bigger news would be that Booz Allen gets fired. ETA: Though I doubt the gov would fire Booz Allen. That's probably too much expertise to replace and leaks can happen anywhere. I assume they would work together to find ways to tighten up.
- yardie 13y agoBAH is pretty damn big in DMV (DC,MD,VA). The government would be hard pressed to fire them outright. And this is nothing to them, sliding a few campaign contribution checks to a few congress critters will make sure they'll still be on every bid.
- beedogs 13y agoThere are nearly a million Americans with top-secret military clearance. Let's hope this is the start of a trend, and that more are encouraged to come forth and help us figure out what our governments are doing to us.
- balabaster 13y agoUm... isn't releasing his salary (bear in mind he works in the private sector for a private contractor and wasn't a government or public sector employee) a violation of privacy laws? I love the level of irony of every layer of this story. It gets more comical by the day.
- Zikes 13y agoMy salary is only about 70% of my earnings, due to yearly bonuses and equity.