5 ms·
A scarier time? The executive branch has been given the power to murder Americans without any proper civilian judicial oversight. The executive branch has been
by adventured 13y ago
A scarier time? The executive branch has been given the power to murder Americans without any proper civilian judicial oversight. The executive branch has been given the power to indefinitely detain Americans, without any civilian judicial oversight. All the while the Feds are tracking and recording everything they can get their hands on.
A few drone strikes? We've built drone bases around the globe and are murdering thousands of innocent civilians with those strikes.
Fund revolutions in other countries? We're doing that in Syria right now. We actively participated in the revolution in Libya.
- rayiner 13y agoMassive hyperbole. I guarantee you its not the first time in history Americans have been killed on the battlefield while fighting for the other side. The executive branch has been given no power to indefinitely detain Americans. See Hamdi v. Rumsfeld. The people who have been detained are not Americans. The scale of proxy wars engaged in then versus today can scarcely be compared its so different.
- oinksoft 13y agoThe drone strikes seldom occur on what a reasonable person would consider a battlefield (weddings, etc.). I think that is what parent is getting at. Certainly American intelligence operatives have murdered their countrymen quietly over the decades. A big difference to me (at least) is that these assassinations are completely out in the open, publicly announced and such.
- LoganCale 13y agoAnwar al-Awlaki was specifically targeted for assassination, not killed on a battlefield.
- rayiner 13y agoYemen, lacking an effective civilian law enforcement system that could give him due process was itself a battlefield.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoKilling is the closest thing to a "natural right" that exists. We bargain it away when we form civilized societies, but no such society binds sovereign nations together. The issue with al awalki was that we were bound, because as a citizen he was party to our social contract. That said, the constitution requires "due process" not a trial in every case. Al awalki was in a place where we could not effectively capture him and give him a trial (he had the option to submit to process by turning himself in-- he was wanted for years).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoIts not a matter of it being a lesser or greater country. Its the matter of it being a different country. There is no "murder" in the state of nature. Nothing limits our use of force other than our bargaining away that natural ability when we form societies. But the fact that Americans have bargained that away with respect to each other does not mean we have done so with respect to non-Americans not on our soil.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- carbocation 13y agoNot really. China has the apparatus to apprehend a person such as al-Awlaki. It has nothing to do with greater or lesser. Emphatically, I am not saying this in defense of the assassination of al-Awlaki, but instead I am saying this because I believe it to be a simple truth that is related to the case.
- waffle_ss 13y ago> The executive branch has been given no power to indefinitely detain Americans Wrong. 1) Section 412 of the USA PATRIOT act permits indefinite detention of immigrants; see Jose Padilla, an American citizen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jose_Padilla_(prisoner)#Habeas_corpus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jose_Padilla_(prisoner)#Habeas... 2) Sections 1021 and 1022 of NDAA FY2012 (which Obama is defending right now in Obama v. Hedges): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NDAA_2012#Controversy_over_indefinite_detention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NDAA_2012#Controversy_over_ind...
- rayiner 13y agoPadilla was ultimatey tried and convicted in a federal civilian court. Obama v hedges has nothing to do with indefinite detention of US citizens. Obama's signing statement explicitly said the act should not be interpreted to encompass US citizens. Given that and the precedent in Hamdi v. Rumsfield, iys clear those NDAA provisions do not apply to citizens.
- obstacle1 13y ago>Padilla was ultimatey tried and convicted in a federal civilian court You're OK with indefinitely detaining American citizens until the government slaps some charges on & convicts? Spooky.
- rayiner 13y agoI'm not "OK" with what happened to Padilla, but the contention was that the executive branch "has been given the power" to indefinitely detain U.S. citizens, and that assertion is false. Read the history of the Padilla case: http://www.nyclu.org/case/padilla-v-bushhamdi-v-rumsfeld-challenging-detention-of-us-citizen-without-charges-or-trial http://www.nyclu.org/case/padilla-v-bushhamdi-v-rumsfeld-cha.... See also: http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/what-supreme-court-really-said-about-jose-padilla http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/what-supreme-cou.... There was a legal wrangling over the scope of the President's detention powers, and Padilla's appeal to the Supreme Court was rendered moot by the government deciding to charge him. No U.S. citizen has been indefinitely detained since.