8 ms·
Oh God why. I've got nothing against flat design done well, but this just makes everything so much harder to SEE. Look at the example screen for "Control Cente
by crazygringo 13y ago
Oh God why. I've got nothing against flat design done well, but this just makes everything so much harder to SEE.
Look at the example screen for "Control Center" -- it looks like a geometric indistinguishable mess. The line around buttons is the same as the line dividing sections is almost the same as the line in sliders.
The example screen for weather shows thin white text against a light blue background, which I can barely make out on my monitor, let alone on a phone.
If anything, phones need extra affordance as what is a label and what is tappable, since we have fat fingers, hold phones faraway where things are small, and often in bright sunlight where there's little contrast we can make out. Phones need extra contrast, not less.
I'm really not one for hyperbole, but Steve Jobs must be rolling in his grave. This isn't about an aesthetic choice, it's just about common-sense usability and quality control. That weather app looks completely useless in the real world, and the fact that Apple's internal processes have allowed this to be launched does not bode well.
- rabino 13y agoWhy don't you wait until you have a freakin' phone in your hand and try it?
- jlarocco 13y agoBecause once the upgrade is installed there's no going back?
- bennyg 13y agoThen use one of your friends that has the developer account, or wait till it's on every phone in the Apple Store. Either way, the point is to reserve judgment until you use it. Just like everything else.
- tripzilch 13y agoThen why do they show it. "That is iOS7." "It appears to be different from iOS6." "That's an iPhone!" "I see that Apple made this." "Well this discussion is getting a little bit too heated for me, I think I will go and reserve my judgement somewhere else for a minute."
- sneak 13y agoBackup your device-specific SHSH signatures for 6.x now! (Or has Apple closed this hole yet with timestamping?)
- madeofpalk 13y agoOf course you can downgrade. You just can't downgrade after iOS 7 goes gold.
- gurkendoktor 13y agoThe copy right next to the download link explicitly says you can't. Blogs report otherwise, but that is a very fragile "of course".
- Alphasite_ 13y agoIts always been possible, in the past (and now - i believe) you just need to enter dfu mode first, then restore it.
- nodata 13y agoBecause then there would be no comments here :)
- pbreit 13y agoWell, watching the "in action" videos on an iPhone is pretty darn close. You do realize you are on a web site designed for commentary on tech matters?
- rabino 13y agoTech commentary used to be more more than baseless hipster-y. Oh the good ol' days.
- mcintyre1994 13y agoThere is Apple marketing material they've made available. It's perfectly valid to make judgements from that in my opinion.
- rgbrgb 13y agoIt's perfectly invalid to make judgements on usability without using it though.
- WayneDB 13y agoYou can absolutely pass valid judgement on quality of usability on sight alone. If I showed you a picture of a 4 foot wide ship wheel and said I was going to install it in my Mazda Miata - you'd know instantly that it would be unusable, right? How about a screen-shot of a text editor that only shows you one giant character at a time? Even as we move away from the ridiculous end of the spectrum of examples - you can know how usable something is based on past experience with similar environments.
- rabino 13y agoThose are screenshots of a beta! How categorically can you judge something until you have the final release in front of you?
- furyofantares 13y agoOne of the big reasons to put something through a beta is so people will judge it before its final release
- simonbarker87 13y agoAt the risk of getting flamed, you haven't actually tried it in the real world yet - you've looked at it on you monitor ...
- miguelrochefort 13y agoThe same can be said for Windows Phone.
- freyr 13y agoThat nobody in the real world has actually tried it yet? Fair enough. But I remember when Apple first made the iTunes icons monochromatic, and everyone complained that they'd no longer be able to distinguish the icons. People seemed to adapt pretty quickly though.
- inthewind 13y ago> That nobody in the real world has actually tried it yet? Surely someone somewhere has bought a Windows phone ;)
- joeblau 13y agoI have one :). I will say that it's surprisingly a lot better than I thought it would be.
- ldubinets 13y agoI haven't met a person yet who hates their windows phone.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoSome things, like the alarm app, really annoy me, but overall the interface is nice. If only there were more third party apps, we don't even have facebook or skype on the marketplace my phone supports (which is hardware locked dammit!).
- richardking 13y agoyeah, the thin, light text didn't look great during the presentation, but i can't imagine they wouldn't test it in bright sunlight/normal mobile phone situations, so I'm gonna wait til its actually out and in front of me to judge.
- gurkendoktor 13y agoI'm inside and I find it straining to read the labels of the four dock apps. Of course I know what they are, but I always find low-contrast, Helvetica Superthin designer porn very insulting to the user. Either show something or don't.
- ctdonath 13y agoThose who knew said it would be "polarizing". Indeed.
- tensor 13y agoThat's a pretty easy prediction though, the previous skeuomorphism was already polarizing and thus removing it would also be polarizing.
- Steko 13y agoRegardless of what they had put out, is anyone doubting that the top comment of the most upvoted HN comment would be a groanfest? #slatepitch
- bcks 13y agoAgreed. Did they do any kind of usability / legibility studies on the thinner typeface? I mean, I mostly use my phone to read email. Why would they reduce contrast on the default text and make it even harder to read?! Just because you have higher resolution screens, doesn't mean you can get away with a thinner sans serif. What's the point if everyone has to increase the size of the text to read it?
- munificent 13y ago> Just because you have higher resolution screens, doesn't mean you can get away with a thinner sans serif. Yes, it does, actually. As resolution increases, so does the Nyquist frequency, which means you can accurately convey higher-frequency signals. In spatial terms, more resolution means finer lines without aliasing errors.
- intrazoo 13y agoSurely there is a hard limit on this though (unless we have bionic eyes and/or small expanding robot fingers (like in ghost in the shell (http://youtu.be/PkyZGZRnQb4)) http://youtu.be/PkyZGZRnQb4)))
- munificent 13y agoCertainly, there is. Laser printers print at about 300 dpi and most users can't see any visible pixels there, so at normal reading distance, that seems to be close to the maximum resolution you need to visibly pixel-free from the user's perspective. Going higher than that probably means thinner blank lines will just appear fainter and not thinner.
- typoking 13y agoA 0.01mm line is going to be invisible on a super high res is going to be pretty much invisible, regardless of Nyquist frequencies.
- rabino 13y agoAre you seriously asking if Apple did usability testing for a design decision? Really?
- bane 13y agothe white text on light backgrounds is unbelievable
- fibbery 13y agoseems pretty inconsiderate toward those with impaired vision. there's little contrast, lots of light gray on white with pastel accents.
- madeofpalk 13y agoI guess that's why for people with impaired vision, there's always been a High Contrast mode in iOS
- blindhippo 13y agoSssssshhhh, let the people whinge. They need to complain about something, don't contradict them with facts.
- conradfr 13y agoThey will never see the button to activate it !
- fudged71 13y agoIt gets worse. In their design guidelines they say that instead of visual cues for buttons you should use COLORS. As a colorblind dude I'm fucking apalled.
- protitap 13y agoThey could have at least added a little shadow or something, like they would usually. I don't know what they were thinking. I usually trust Apple with these design matters.
- timsaunders 13y agoIf only we could get great quality text on all OSX retina display's now.. All my apps lag behind with blurry text on my macbook pro
- gte910h 13y agoThat could look just fine on a phone when looking hard to read on a projector in a auditorium
- JumpCrisscross 13y agoIsn't the whole point of flat design replacing the loud superfluousness of skeuomorphism's textures with equally jarring psychedelic colour schemes? That's how designers prove their worth, by adding more stuff, right?
- drivebyacct2 13y agoExcept neither Android nor WP8 follow that assumption/conclusion.
- coldtea 13y agoAnd neither does iOS 7. I mean, where do you see the: "jarring psychedelic colour schemes"? If anything the grant-parent brings up the example of the Control Center, which is the opposite of that, just a two-color subdued thing.
- drivebyacct2 13y agoSorry, I wasn't really agreeing with any of the GP comment - I think iOS7-UI was exactly what they needed. A very modern refresh and I think it's sharp (and I love Holo and WP8 has a very unique style certainly). I don't like the background of CC myself, but I think that's actually because they're letting the hue of the homescreen icons below bleed through too much. It's "neat" but I think it's kinda visually gross :S
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]