6 ms·
Slightly off-topic question, but why did he not just go to Iceland in the first place? Hong Kong does not seem like the best destination here.
by untog 13y ago
Slightly off-topic question, but why did he not just go to Iceland in the first place? Hong Kong does not seem like the best destination here.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoHe has probably considered that and knows more than we do about what his strategy is. He probably hasn't shown his whole hand either. He might not even be in Hong Kong.
- mehmehshoe 13y agoThis. We are seeing reports that are hours old. How he released the NSA data was thought about long ago. I doubt he is in HongKong.
- samstave 13y agoTotally - welcome to the farking cyberpunk future we all dreamed about in the 80s. THis is amazing.
- untog 13y agoIf he lied to The Guardian I would be very surprised. It would be unlikely to help his case.
- cozeulodorieso 13y agoI don't think you've been paying attention. Glenn Greenwald (who writes for the Guardian) and Laura Poitras (who's independent, but has had bylines for both the Guardian and WP) interviewed him in his hotel room in Hong Kong. He definitely was in Hong Kong for a while.
- uvdiv 13y agoA competing theory is that he is actually spying for the PRC. Hong Kong would be an obvious choice for a wealthy, Western spy seeking Chinese protection. They're semi-autonomous, but military affairs are run by the PRC, and in particular the PRC has control over foreign extradition: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/09/edward-snowden-hong-kong-gamble http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/09/edward-snowden-h... If this wasn't a priori the best theory, surely the HK part adds some Bayesian weight.
- sliverstorm 13y agoDo you have more information about this theory? The discussion has been so one-sided, I feel obligated to seek other interpretations.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- untog 13y agoI don't think there is any more information about it because circumstantial evidence is the only connection. Not to say that it isn't true, but at this point a whole wide range of things could be.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI just mean more discussion.
- uvdiv 13y agoI haven't found any interesting information. Apparently this theory is being speculated on CNN (as I said, neither interesting, nor information...) http://www.mediaite.com/tv/former-cia-officer-officials-considering-nsa-whistleblowers-case-potential-chinese-espionage/ http://www.mediaite.com/tv/former-cia-officer-officials-cons...
- mrgreenfur 13y ago
- jckt 13y agoIt says here that he was on leave from his NSA job for treatment for his epilepsy (well, that's what he told the NSA). It's been known that medical tourism is somewhat big in Hong Kong (though mostly for other Asians, particularly mainland Chinese). In this respect, going to Iceland would've raised a few NSA eyebrows, and in light of this I think HK was a good choice (of course, I'm sure there are other, better, choices).
- conroe64 13y agoI still would question why he didn't then hop on a flight from Hong Kong to Iceland before he let the cat out of the bag. Edit: Maybe he left Hong Kong after the interview but before they published it?
- jckt 13y agoCheck out beggi's post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5852564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5852564 Iceland cannot make guarantees either. Also, I suspect that booking a flight would raise a lot of suspicion. Spies spy on spies -- people like Snowden are just as likely, if not more likely, to be watched, than your typical civilian.
- scanr 13y agoIf you didn't have any direct relationship and assurances from a government that you'd be protected from extradition, which one would you go to?
- dagw 13y agoOther than one minority party MP trying to win votes, what makes you think Iceland would be better? Iceland has an extradition treaty with the US, is a NATO member and the current conservative government doesn't show any desire to piss off the Americans.
- StavrosK 13y agoIsn't the obvious answer that China would be less willing to extradite people to the US? Not as unwilling as, say, Iran, but still.
- cheald 13y agoI thought it was fairly shrewd - any kind of "extra-legal" action against him in Hong Kong would almost certainly piss China off, and they're really the only tiger that the US isn't in a hurry to get into a wrestling match with. A hit on Snowden in Hong Kong would be an immense international diplomatic incident. A hit on him in Iceland would be a flash in the pan (what's Iceland going to do about it?). My hunch is that he's banking on diplomatic tensions between China and the US to shield him. Hong Kong puts him under China's diplomatic shield without necessarily directly exposing him to the PRC's equivalent of the NSA, who I'm sure are eager to get their hands on him.