3 ms·
> Also, a question: do you think there is anyone online reading HN that has not already heard this line of argument, that both governments and terrorists kill c
by bambax 13y ago
> Also, a question: do you think there is anyone online reading HN that has not already heard this line of argument, that both governments and terrorists kill children?
So? Does this make the argument wrong? Or does this mean that arguments that have been used once, cannot be used again? Arguments as toilet paper, in some way?
I'm French. France was occupied by Nazi Germany (as every American I ever speak to likes to remind me).
Resistants were ordinary French people who blew up trains in order to make the life of Germans in France as difficult as possible -- and of course German propaganda called them terrorists. I'm not putting this word in quotes, because of course that's what they were. They were trying to terrify the occupiers. It was a good thing.
Terrorists try to murder your children because your compatriots murder theirs.
- Dylan16807 13y agoIt's not that simple. When 'terrorists' are in their home country fighting the occupiers, it is sometimes justified. When they go into another country to attack civilians any justification of fighting for freedom is lost. As a category 'terrorist' is imprecise and problematic, and likely better off not being used.
- bambax 13y agoAgree totally. The word "terrorist" is useless. It's even less useful when used against anyone who hasn't yet been convicted, in order to justify bypassing normal judicial due process (as the parent was implying, and as many countries have done, including the UK and, shamelessly, France). The only way for the terrorists to win is to transform modern democracies into paranoid, self-centered, hysteric societies. Terrorists appear to be winning so far, but it's a long game. We should really not play their game.