4 ms·
For the record, the only people who see the USA as the "beacon of democracy" are Americans. I'm not saying this to start a flame war, but to simply point out t
by enraged_camel 13y ago
For the record, the only people who see the USA as the "beacon of democracy" are Americans.
I'm not saying this to start a flame war, but to simply point out that the USA is no more democratic than many other Western nations.
(My personal opinion is that the USA is much more of a beacon of imperialism than of democracy. But that's neither here nor there.)
- deelowe 13y agos/americans/american government and media(for a lot of us at least)
- jlgreco 13y agoTo be fair, those people are exclusively Americans. Not all Americans think of America as a "beacon of democracy", but pretty much anyone who does is themselves American. Also, rectangles are not squares, though squares are rectangles.
- gknoy 13y agoNearly every American __wants__ our country to be a beacon of democracy, however, which is why this type of behavior by our government is so frustrating.
- tomp 13y agoNearly every person wants their country to be a beacon of democracy (and freedom). Except those in power, of course (in America and elsewhere).
- rorrr2 13y agoUS is actually less democratic than many countries - Canada, Australia, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Finland. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Democracy_Index_2012_green_and_red.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Democracy_Index_2012_gree... [2] http://www.democracyranking.org/en/ranking.htm http://www.democracyranking.org/en/ranking.htm If we're talking about economic freedom or the freedom of press, it's even worse: [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Index_of_Economic_Freedom [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_Freedom_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_Freedom_Index
- contingencies 13y agoThe notion of democratic itself is a flawed one - meaningful representation left the building a long time ago. It is often used to evoke some sense of greater social justice. Notice though, how notions such as 'willingness to invade other sovereign nations' or 'laws on books against fundamental human rights' or 'presence of any constitution or meaningful court of higher appeal' or 'centralization of media ownership' or 'measured trajectory of higher educational capacity' or 'number of excuses government can use to spy on or detain citizens' also seem conveniently out of scope. Simply put, the notion we are sold of western democracy as some all-solving wonderland of equality and transparent empathetic good-governance is a farce. The more people lend rankings like these ones credence, the harder that is for people to see. (Though they certainly do have some utility, it is important also to see them critically.)
- rorrr2 13y agoWhy don't you create a better ranking and see how it does? I bet the results will be nearly identical, if not worse for the US.
- adventured 13y agoThe US was never a beacon of democracy. That's not a desirable goal. It was a Constitutional Republic.
- philwelch 13y agoThis semantic argument is completely tiresome. There's no contradiction between being a democracy and being a republic. The US is a democratic republic. Non-democratic republics include ancient Rome and 18th-century America (where slaves couldn't vote). Democratic non-republics include the UK, Canada, and Holland (which are monarchies). "Republic" doesn't actually mean anything aside from "not a monarchy". When the founders of the United States wrote movingly about being a republic, they were firstly trying to emulate Rome and secondly trying to emphasize the then-popular Enlightenment ideal that monarchies were outdated and it was better to govern explicitly in the name of the people. (The word "republic" emulates Rome because it's the term used by and for the Roman state. It's derived from the Latin "res publica", for "public property", which is exactly synonymous with the English word "commonwealth".)
- pandaman 13y agoThere is no contradiction between being a democracy and being a republic however, as you add "constitutional" in front of "republic" it becomes a constitutional republic, which is not a democracy.
- philwelch 13y agoThat's absolute nonsense by any meaningful definition of the word.
- pandaman 13y agoCan you elaborate? It's pretty simple in my opinion: democracy is the power of people and in a democracy (which would be also a republic, since it's not a monarchy or a theocracy) the people is the ultimate source of power. That could be either a direct democracy (where all people get to decide) or representative democracy, where the people choose representatives to decide everything. There is no power above the people's in a democracy. In the USA the ultimate source of power is the Constitution of the US. It rules over the power of the people. Since the ultimate source of power in the USA is not the people it cannot possibly be a democracy.
- hughlomas 13y agoThe United States, despite what it may now be, has a historical foundation as the "beacon of democracy". The seeds of philosophies from antiquity and the enlightenment took root in the founding of the country, and the United States pioneered modern western democracy.
- jlgreco 13y agoI don't think "beacons" work through time like that. I don't think you would say that Damascus is a "beacon of medical science", though there was once a time (preceding and during the Islamic Golden Age) that you could have certainly said that.
- rhizome 13y ago"You are free, because this is what freedom looks like."