4 ms·
So which is it? Is he "welcoming a debate over spying on Americans" or is he prosecuting the whistleblowers (again) and requesting state privileges to protect t
by mtgx 13y ago
So which is it? Is he "welcoming a debate over spying on Americans" or is he prosecuting the whistleblowers (again) and requesting state privileges to protect themselves against further scrutiny? I don't think the two can really co-exist. And if all of this was "already known" what's there to prosecute then? The amount of double-speak from the Obama administration astonishes me.
- mayneack 13y agoWhat's the point of classified information if you don't punish those that leak it? Don't get me wrong, the treatment of Bradley Manning is absurd, and there shouldn't be any sort of prosecution of the journalists involved (which has been happening recently), so it's fair to complain that they are coming down too hard on whistle-blowers. However, you have to expect some sort of investigation into who did the original leaks. We can also have the debate about whether they overly classify things and should be more open in the first place, but that's not the same thing.
- kingraoul3 13y agoWe can't have that debate if we aren't informed about what's being kept from us.
- ownagefool 13y agoWe barely even need to have that debate, we know our Government are using classified information to cover their own asses and for political reasons. Transparency is pretty much the only weapon we have against Government corruption, thus we really should to be doing more to help protect legitimate whistle blowers and to stop documents being classified or redacted without some overseeing from a party without skin in the game.
- jivatmanx 13y agoIt's one thing to oppose a system such as PRISM in the legal abstract, quite another thing to hear about the wanton details of a real one, and see the CEO's of Microsoft, Facebook and Google publicly fib under FISA gag orders.
- kunai 13y ago> We can also have the debate ... but that's not the same thing Yes, it is. The whole thing is cohesive. Penetration at the source is the only thing that will halt government secrecy, and condemning those who leak classified information is egregious and a grave disservice to those people. Classified information should only pertain to anything with national security at stake. The in-country data mining obviously did not.
- rhizome 13y agoI believe that "national security" reasoning has been expanded to cover the country's reputation. The security being protected is that of a portrayed image.
- mtgx 13y agoSo the whistleblower law is just a "pretend-law"? Whistleblowers are needed for a healthy democracy, unless we have a pretend-democracy at this point, too. How do you uncover dirt on the government if every single act of whistleblowing and investigative journalism on the government is being prosecuted? Not only does that create a very chilling effect, but it also takes out everyone who did it, "before they cause too much damage". And doesn't this begin to resemble a little too much with some of those oppressive regimes? The government classifies everything it doesn't want the public to know these days, and then tries to arrest everyone who leaks those documents. I think we need to stop thinking about what's legal and what's illegal, and start thinking about what moral and immoral. Many of these laws are immoral.
- doktrin 13y ago> So the whistleblower law is just a "pretend-law"? Not sure why you used the phrase 'pretend-law' in scare quotes, since the post you responded to said no such thing. Either way, there isn't really such a thing as the whistleblower law (IANAL). Aside from the first amendment, the closest thing I could find was the Whistleblower Protection Act [1]. It's a young law by any standard (1989), so you'd be hard pressed to argue that we didn't have a functioning democracy in its absence. Your central point is well received, but you rebutted a partial straw man. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower_Protection_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower_Protection_Act
- logn 13y agoI found this which explains a variety of protections: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower_protection_in_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistleblower_protection_in_Uni... Additionally it would be interesting if the leakers leaked more to get a softer punishment: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turn_state%27s_evidence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turn_state%27s_evidence Also, I have to add, I'm a little ashamed of my country today. But I feel vindicated as a programmer that we were right! We knew it all along. Things like this have been reported for years. But no one cared. Finally this is plastered on every major publication and people no longer think it's some conspiracy theory or exaggeration of normal security measures. So now's the real test. What do we do? How do we fix this? Our innate liberties have been trampled and threatened. Have some self-respect and speak your mind at work, people.
- jivatmanx 13y agoThe process of classifying material is uncontroversial because in general parlance, we assume that material is specific intelligence of people, place, and times. The extension of that definition to include classified courts with classified rulings used as the legal basis for programs like this... is not the generally accepted one.
- mpyne 13y agoI don't know why you'd assume it's specific intel of that. Classified info is literally anything that would be a risk to national security if released in an uncontrolled fashion. The 3 different tiers of U.S. classification are literally just the 3 different levels of damage that would accrue to U.S. national security, nothing more. So in the case of programs like this, if the hypothetical terr'ists know about it, that lets them know services to avoid, or communications methods to avoid, etc., which might enable them to form networks that the NSA would otherwise have been able to unravel before their next terrorist attack. So it's not completely inconceivable that there's a valid reason to apply classification standards. I happen to think that the importance of transparency is such that we need to at least have that public discussion about what types of records NSA would be storing, searching, and examining. But at the same time the NSA has literally been doing this for decades, Congress has had classified hearings for longer, and the Republic has refused to fall. I don't know for sure about classified courts, but neither would that surprise me too much.
- jivatmanx 13y agoThere is no Salafi army capable of achieving military victory against the United States. The existential threat is zero. Therefore, I see no reason why our sacred liberties should be secretly sacrificed as "tactics" in an eternal, global war. Better to declare global perpetual war against pools, bathtubs, or uncooked food. It would be cheaper and save more lives. Oh, and, preserve the sacrifice of those who died fighting for our freedom. Or, is a life lost to a one who has claimed jihad worth more than one from uncooked food? It may be that Bush was right, that terrorists wish us to abandon our liberties. So, too do the disciples of Leo Strauss who want to elevate to warriors the ideology of people who are merely sad, pathetic men no different from the killers of random school shootings, and deserve no more.
- lifeguard 13y agoAs wikileaks has shown the government tends to classify EVERYTHING.
- staunch 13y agoI have trouble deciding whether people intentional misunderstand him, simple can't, or just prefer to be outraged. The program is classified. Its more effective if it remains so. Since it is now public, though he wishes it wasn't, he's happy and willing to publicly debate the issue of privacy vs security. He's made it quite clear that he struggles with the issue himself. Leaking classified information is illegal, thus it generally should be prosecuted. Though we also have whistleblower laws that protect people who are leaking evidence of criminal conduct.
- ohazi 13y agoWe're in the midst of several legal cases that are trying to argue that the NSA spying program is criminal conduct.
- mpyne 13y agoWell that the flip side of "innocent until proven guilty" is that merely having an open case is not enough.
- steveklabnik 13y agoHow can we prove something guilty when we don't even know it exists?
- mpyne 13y agoWe knew PRISM existed though. It's even mentioned in job postings, and we already knew about FISA and Section 702 as well. We just didn't know we cared.
- magicalist 13y agoThe parent poster should have been more specific. The reason lawsuits have largely be stymied has been the claim of state secrets (whether or not everyone in the room knew the program existed, the executive branch argued that details would reveal things that would be detrimental to the state) and because no one who sued could prove they had standing to sue because no one knew who was actually being monitored. So, yes, we knew section 215, FISA, etc existed, but no one has been able to (yet) successfully challenge them fully because any legal basis for challenging has been (in many cases actively) kept secret.
- detcader 13y agoThat this doublespeak surprises anyone shows the tragedy of the small size of Glenn Greenwald's readership. He has been writing on Obama's abuses and misdirection since Obama admin has been in power; and before that, he's written about Bush's (published three books about Bush, in fact)
- cenhyperion 13y agoI've pretty much come to the conclusion that he does the direct opposite of whatever he promises. He promised to end all this when he was elected, yet expanded on what Bush had started.
- rhizome 13y agoI have had to consider the possibility that the military has gone rogue and it's not his decision to make.